The refrain from family members and friends of Noah Sadowski and Dylan Morris was constant throughout the two hours of testimony Monday morning: They were stunned, they said. The men they knew weren’t capable of the violent torture they pleaded guilty to.

“This crime is completely out of my brother’s character,” said Morris’ brother, Christian Morris.

“This isn’t him to any degree in my mind,” Sadowski’s sister, Charity Skowvron, told Common Pleas Judge Katherine Emery. “That’s not Noah.”

The men they described bore little resemblance to the men who attacked Jon Olson inside his Sewickley home late one night in April 2024 and spent the next five hours torturing the man to the point he prayed “for God to take me away from the pain.”

Advertise with us

Sadowski, 34, and Morris, 31, attacked Mr. Olson as he went back inside his Little Street apartment from smoking a cigarette late April 7, 2024.

“The next five hours were the worst hours of my life,” Mr. Olson, 62, wrote in a letter read by Assistant District Attorney Grant Olson, who called the crimes sadistic and premeditated.

They handcuffed him, cut him, pummeled him and threatened to kill him, according to the details of the attack, which lasted into the predawn hours of April 8. They glued and taped his eyes shut, pistol-whipped him, took turns urinating on him and burned him with cigarettes. They used his phone to call drug dealers, he said, and used his Cash App to order an Uber. They threatened to cut his implanted medication pump out of his body.

“I have never prayed so deeply for God to take me away from the pain,” he wrote.

He said the pair ransacked his home before they left him bloodied on his floor, even taking, he said, his father’s World War II service medals.

Advertise with us

Mr. Olson wrote in his statement that the length and cruelty of the attack “demonstrated this was not a drug-riddled escapade they were on.” Rather, he said, it was planned and premeditated.

“I no longer feel safe anywhere. I’m in a constant state of fear and anxiety,” he wrote. “The trauma has changed me permanently.”

A mitigation specialist said Sadowski and Mr. Olson knew each other, and the attack stemmed from an alleged crime Sadowski believed Mr. Olson had perpetrated against him. The allegation was never reported to authorities, and the assistant district attorney called the claim “ludicrous.”

Both men pleaded guilty in June to robbery, burglary, aggravated assault and conspiracy. Sadowski also pleaded guilty to one count of strangulation, and Morris also pleaded to possession of an instrument of crime, reckless endangerment and criminal use of communications.

The judge sentenced both men to six to 12 years in prison.

Advertise with us

Even Judge Emery called it “hard to reconcile” what she heard from loved one with the details of the crime. She was stunned, she said, that such an attack came from two people with no serious criminal history.

“I’d like to say there’s a low risk of future crimes of violence,” she said, “but no one saw this coming.”

Trauma, mental illness and addiction

Sadowski lived with several foster families in Texas before he was adopted at age 4 along with two of his three siblings by a family in Beaver County. The mitigation specialist, Lauren Stoner, said Sadowski began using drugs early in life, and he was in the midst of a downward spiral by the time he and Morris attacked Mr. Olson.

Ms. Stoner said Sadowski was kicked out of Avonworth High School but later studied culinary arts at technical school. She said he’s been diagnosed with generalized anxiety disorder, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder.

His sister, Ms. Skowvron, said the two still have grand plans for a food truck and restaurant, and maybe a cookbook.

Advertise with us

“Noah was my baby brother,” she said through tears. “He’s soft. Behind everything he puts out, he’s soft.”

At the defense table, Sadowski buried his face under the collar of this jail jumpsuit.

Morris wept as loved ones talked about the trauma of his childhood and spiral toward addiction and mental health issues. He was 9 when his older brother took his own life in their family home, and family members said Morris always blamed himself.

Christian Morris said he and Morris were close when they were kids but their lives diverged when he moved to California. Weeping, he told the judge that if his brother had “a fraction of the support that I had, none of this would have happened.”

Family members of both men pledged that, when they are released, they will have strong support systems to come home to.

Advertise with us

“I’m his boulder, and I’m here. When I say, ‘we’re here,’ I mean ‘we’re here,’ ” said Sadowski’s mother, Deborah Stuligross, emphasizing the words as she said them. “And we’re not going anywhere.”

Tanisha Long, an organizer with the Abolitionist Law Center whose friendship with Sadowski goes back more than a decade, called him reliable, caring and loving. She said the courts often judge defendants based on their worst moments and, many times, people are outraged by the details of events but fail to “look at what can bring a person back.”

It’s a fact, she said, that Sadowski will one day be released from prison one day.

“We want him whole,” she said. “We need a Noah who gets treatment and programing.”

If he’s incarcerated too long, she said, “none of that will matter because he’ll be institutionalized.”

Advertise with us

Sadowski and Morris both said they will use their time in prison to better themselves.

Morris apologized to Mr. Olson, saying his actions that night were spurred by substance abuse — something that wasn’t to shift blame, he said, “but acknowledge reality.”

“I take full, complete responsibility,” he said. “I hope my actions can show the sincerity of my apology.”

Sadowski read from a hand-written statement, first apologizing to Mr. Olson, who watched from the courtroom seating.

“I’m truly and sincerely sorry, Jon,” he said, pledging to take advantage of all therapy and substance abuse treatment offered to him in prison. “I can and will be a productive member of society.”