Attorney Joseph Patrick Murphy watched in horror Tuesday as a routine traffic court hearing devolved into a foot chase on a busy highway after his client fled ICE agents who had shown up to arrest him at the hearing in Leetsdale.

Mr. Murphy, primarily an immigration attorney, said he was aware that his client wasn’t a U.S. citizen when he was hired to represent him for a handful of traffic violations — among them an illegal U-turn and driving with an expired inspection sticker.

When he arrived at the Magisterial District Court, Mr. Murphy said the first thing he noticed was how many law enforcement officers — in police uniforms and in street clothes — were there.

“There were more police in and around that courthouse than defendants,’’ he said. “They were all watching us.”

Advertise with us

Then, as they waited for the hearing, Mr. Murphy said his client, a Mexican, started to walk back toward his car. A plainclothes agent approached his client and, moments later, chaos ensued.

“People were grabbing at each other,” Mr. Murphy said. “He had my case file. All the papers went up into the air and the next thing you know, my client is running right into traffic on [Route] 65 followed by half a dozen police officers. As I’m watching this, I’m like ... someone is going to get killed.”

As the Trump administration continues its deportation campaign, which has seen hundreds detained in Western Pennsylvania since the president took office, attorneys have become increasingly concerned with Immigration and U.S. Customs Enforcement agents making courthouse arrests.

In addition to the arrest in Leetsdale, ICE has also detained several people Downtown at the Allegheny County Courthouse, according to county Sheriff Kevin Kraus.

Mr. Kraus said his department has met with Homeland Security, ICE, court personnel and other federal agencies so the sheriff’s office will be notified when agents enter county court buildings.

Advertise with us

He said his department does not take part in the arrests, but sheriff's deputies are responsible for security in the courts.

“If they take somebody out, we don’t assist with that,” he said. “There’s a lot of different feelings about that. We’re not only there to keep order, but to keep people, if we can, from interfering to the point they get arrested, and to keep people safe.”

It is unclear how many people in total have been arrested by ICE at courthouses this year, but the operations have been reported across the country and have sparked concerns among lawyers and even some judges that it could make people less likely to show up for hearings.

Mr. Murphy, who said he was shaken up after watching his client get chased and tackled by officers, was torn on the issue of immigration arrests at courthouses.

“As a citizen, I look at it and say, ‘Fine, somebody’s breaking the law and that’s an easy way to get them,”’ he said. “As an officer of the court, I do not think it's a good idea at all. This doesn’t really belong in what is historically called the justice of the peace. It looked like the NFL over there.”

Advertise with us

Leetsdale Police Chief Daniel Raible referred questions about the incident to ICE, which did not respond to requests for more information regarding the arrest.

The sharp increase in ICE enforcement actions across the country comes after the Trump campaign, during last year’s presidential race, promised to launch the “largest deportation program of criminals in the history of America.”

Two days after Donald Trump took office, former acting ICE Director Caleb Vitello reversed a Biden-era policy that had discouraged most courthouse arrests.

In late May, acting ICE Director Todd Lyons issued a new directive that loosened restrictions even more by allowing agents to arrest people at courthouses without coordinating with the local Department of Homeland Security attorney.

Under pressure to ramp up deportations, the agency moved quickly.

Advertise with us

In May, CNN confirmed at least a dozen ICE arrests near courts in Virginia, New Hampshire, North Carolina, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, and Wisconsin — including a man who was arrested by the agency during a jury trial in Boston.

The tactic has been used under other administrations, drawing persistent scrutiny.

During Trump’s first presidency, courthouse arrests by ICE became so prevalent that dozens of former state and federal judges in 2018 penned a letter to then-acting ICE Director Ronald Vitiello to express their concern.

“We know firsthand that for courts to effectively do justice, ensure public safety, and serve their communities, the public must be able to access courthouses safely and without fear of retribution,” the letter said. “For many, however, ICE’s courthouse arrests have made courts places to avoid.”

The group of former judges went on to claim that ICE enforcement at courthouses led to a drop in crime reporting, particularly in cases of domestic abuse from the Hispanic population.

Advertise with us

The letter said several domestic violence cases were dropped by Denver’s city attorney after victims declined to cooperate out of fear they would encounter ICE, and the number of domestic violence reports had declined as well in Hispanic communities in Los Angeles, San Francisco, San Diego and Houston.

“ICE arrests have even put judges in the position of facing defendants who request to be detained, rather than released, because they know ICE officers are waiting outside the courtroom,” the letter read.

As ICE enforcement has ramped up in the second Trump term, Pittsburgh-area attorneys have said they expected to witness the courthouse arrests personally.

“I knew sooner or later I’d see one, I just didn’t expect it to be something quite that kinetic,” Mr. Murphy said.

Moving forward, Mr. Murphy said he plans to double down on the advice he has been telling clients since the year began: Do not run.

Advertise with us

“Law enforcement has a very difficult job and there’s no doubt in my mind that everything they did [on Tuesday] was in good faith,” he said. “Cops train every day to catch people. That’s their job. There’s more of them. You’re not going to get away from this stuff with self help. If you’re going to get out of this, it’s going to be from someone like me.”

Mr. Murphy, however, did offer some words of warning to the agents and officers who chased his client onto the highway.

“If I was advising the government, I would also say don’t play in traffic because they have this guy’s address, they know where he was going,” Mr. Murphy said. “To have [stuff] like what happened [Tuesday] go on for a consistent level, it won’t be very long until somebody really gets hurt.”