After months of mostly peaceful meetings, the recent uses of a racial slur in emails by a longtime jail oversight board attendee led to a fiery back-and-forth at a meeting Thursday — and Allegheny County’s president judge screaming at two of the board members.

John Kenstowicz, a longtime attendee of jail oversight board meetings, was set to deliver his public remarks about a new correctional officer survey he was about to start. But Judge Susan Evashavik DiLucente, president judge and chair of the board, said Mr. Kenstowicz was being unfairly attacked for emails he had sent to board members in recent months.

Those emails concerned an incident where Mr. Kenstowicz said that someone sent him a text message and called him a racial slur. Mr. Kenstowicz said he had spent five days in the jail parking lot for getting petition signatures, after which the text was sent. He then alerted the board members via email, using the racial epithet used to describe him.

Tanisha Long, another longtime participant in the meetings, read those emails during her public comment. Ms. Long said that after Mr. Kenstowicz used the slur once to describe the incident, a board member — Muhammad Ali Nasir, who goes by MAN-E and is a Black man — replied that he found the term offensive and asked for an apology.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kenstowicz apologized, but used the term two more times in follow-up emails. The most contentious part of the exchange came before Ms. Long’s reading of the emails, when Mr. Kenstowicz defended himself against the attacks before giving his remarks.

Judge DiLucente, however, did much of the defending. She said that County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam, a fellow board member, had “completely misrepresented to the public what had happened.”

In a matter of minutes, Ms. Hallam and the judge were yelling at each other about the emails. Ms. Hallam said that her issue was not with Mr. Kenstowicz’s first use of the slur, even if she disagreed with it. It was the follow-up emails, she said.

“He was no longer quoting what was said to him,” Ms. Hallam said. “MAN-E asked him a second time to please not use the n-word in an email that MAN-E and other Black people are on ... and he used it a third time.”

As part of his public comments, Mr. Kenstowicz said that he was not aware of a county rule that a racial slur cannot be written in emails, even if people are quoting someone else.

Advertise with us

“This is blind ignorance on my part that I didn't know the rule,” he said. “That's what this boils down to.”

But Ms. Hallam replied that anyone should judge the emails for themselves — which Ms. Long read as part of her public comments. After another back-and-forth, Judge DiLucente got out of her chair, stood over Ms. Hallam and MAN-E, and yelled: “Stop talking, both of you! Or I will remove both of you from the meeting ... if you interrupt [Mr. Kenstowicz] one more time!”

After the meeting, the president judge did not dispute that the epithet was used in the emails. But she declined comment on multiple follow-ups from reporters about her actions, before finally adding: “Disputes pop up, and you move on.”

Warden details staffing changes at jail

Before the hectic back-and-forth involving the emails, jail Warden Trevor Wingard said there have been multiple improvements in health care staffing at the jail.

There are now four EMS personnel in the intake portion of the jail, with a fifth person currently “being onboarded,” Mr. Wingard said.

Advertise with us

Jail officials are also working with Allegheny Health Network to increase telehealth capabilities within the jail. One hurdle is making sure that information shared between the jail and AHN remains secure on both ends, the warden said.

“We continue to work towards improving — starting at intake, but through the whole entire facility regarding medical services,” Mr. Wingard said.