The organizers of the Pittsburgh Home & Garden Show are suing the company behind the upcoming Monroeville Home & Garden Show, alleging the use of “home & garden show” in the event’s name is trademark infringement meant to deceive patrons and capitalize on the Pittsburgh show’s reputation.
Organizers of the Pittsburgh show are seeking an injunction that would stop JACE from using “Home & Garden Show” in the name of the event, slated to start Sept. 5.
The lawsuit names JACE, the company organizing the Monroeville event, and James McClintock, who the filing indicates also goes by the name James Michael. Mr. McClintock is referred to in the lawsuit as “JACE’s apparent principal.”
A JACE representative told the Post-Gazette the business is “in the middle of preparing [court] filings” in response to the lawsuit.
The lawsuit notes that Pittsburgh organizers trademarked “Home & Garden Show” and “Home & Garden Show with Design” in Pennsylvania in 1991, noting in the trademark application they’d been using those titles since 1985.
The trademarked names, according to the lawsuit, “have acquired secondary meaning in the minds of the commercial firms and consumers” in that they connect the names with the actual Pittsburgh Home & Garden Show and the positive qualities they associate with the show — “all as a result of Plaintiff’s time, hard work, risk-taking, business acumen and promotional and advertising efforts.”
Attached to the lawsuit was a copy of an email from a prospective exhibitor of the Pittsburgh Home & Garden Show “looking for info on the upcoming show at the Monroeville Convention Center.”
Pittsburgh organizers indicated they asked JACE to voluntarily drop the trademarked phraseology from the title.
According to the lawsuit, Mr. McClintock called attorneys for the Pittsburgh show and “stated unequivocally” that JACE would continue to use “home & garden show” in the event title and “that he would see [attorneys for the Pittsburgh event] in court.”
That phone call, according to the lawsuit, was followed by a letter from JACE that seemed to take a shot at the Pittsburgh event, reading in part:
“It is worth noting that many exhibitors have mistakenly assumed we are affiliated with the Pittsburgh Home and Garden Show and have expressed a reluctance to participate due to the number of complaints they have with that event. We have no interest in being associated — directly or indirectly — with an event that carries that type of exhibitor dissatisfaction.”
In addition to the injunction, Pittsburgh Home & Garden Show organizers are looking to recoup attorneys’ fees and other court costs.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.