Dozens of homeowners affected by the 2023 home explosion on Plum’s Rustic Ridge Drive have filed lawsuits against utility and other companies, alleging the companies’ negligence led to the explosion that caused property damage throughout the neighborhood.

The filings come on the heels of four wrongful death lawsuits filed last week by the families of the six individuals killed in the blast: Homeowners Paul and Heather Oravitz and neighbors Kevin Sebunia, Michael Thomas, Casey Clontz, and Clontz’s 12-year-old son, Keegan.

The two separate lawsuits, both filed Thursday, represent 33 homeowners living on and around Rustic Ridge Drive. The filings name Penneco Gas and Oil and 17 associated companies, Peoples Natural Gas, the A.O. Smith Corp., Grasinger Homes and eight unnamed individuals listed only as John Does.

The homeowner lawsuits mirror those filed by the surviving family members, alleging that gas line leaks in the neighborhood allowed methane to build up in the basement of 141 Rustic Ridge Drive — the Oravitz home and epicenter of the blast.

Advertise with us

The lawsuit cites a failing compression regulator that Peoples had ordered Penneco to repair or replace a week before the explosion. Penneco, the lawsuit alleges, failed to do so, and Peoples failed to take action to reduce pressure on the line.

At the same time, there was a leak in the 4-inch suction line that attorneys say caused odorless natural gas to spill out, collect near 141 Rustic Ridge, and ultimately seep into the home’s basement through its foundation. Attorneys allege that by the time Paul Oravitz and his neighbors gathered in his basement Aug. 12, 2023, to troubleshoot issues with his hot water heater, gas had been collected unchecked for anywhere from days to months.

Though someone had shut off the gas to the hot water heater, according to the lawsuit, the appliance continued to run on the gas that had connected in the basement. Shortly before 10:30 a.m., something ignited the gas, setting off a massive explosion that leveled the Oravitz home, destroyed the houses on either side, and damaged dozens of others in the neighborhood.

Those homeowners allege negligence and recklessness by the four defendant companies, saying their actions directly caused the explosion that resulted in the property damage.