Tensions ran high before, during and after the sentencing hearing Tuesday for a Harrison woman who pleaded guilty to shooting her boyfriend and dumping him in a McKees Rocks alley in 2022.

Brook Lynn Lank pleaded guilty nearly a month ago to voluntary manslaughter, admitting she had shot and killed Anthony Lofton Jr. because she unreasonably believed her life was in danger. In a letter to the judge dated June 30, Lank wrote that she took “full accountability.”

That changed Tuesday. As Lank stood, about to be handcuffed, and absorbed Common Pleas Judge Kelly Bigley’s sentence — five to 10 years in prison — she tried to take it back.

“I’m not guilty,” she said, referencing a report from a private investigator. “I did not kill anybody.”

Advertise with us

By that point, the judge had already imposed her sentence — one that would likely send Lank, who had been out on bail for nearly two years, behind bars.

“Now you’re telling me you’re not guilty?” Judge Bigley asked. She told Lank she would appoint her a public defender to file an appeal.

Lank’s defense attorney, Nina Martinelli, had asked Judge Bigley to sentence her client to time served — 536 days in jail — or a further period of electronic home monitoring. She had been released on such conditions in August 2023 by now-retired Judge Anthony Mariani.

Judge Bigley said she wrestled with sentencing, noting “no one really knows what happened in that vehicle” other than Mr. Lofton, who can’t speak for himself, and Lank.

She said she had watched video evidence that showed an incident earlier that day at Lank’s house in which Lofton pulled a gun on Lank during an argument. Lofton left but later came back, and he and Lank left together. A fight later on as they drove prompted Lank to open fire, attorneys said.

Advertise with us

The judge said she found inconsistencies between Lank’s actions and her explanation that she feared Mr. Lofton would kill her in that moment — including the fact that, after shooting Mr. Lofton, Lank recruited the help of an ex-boyfriend to dump the dead man in an alley and then clean the car.

“I’ve gone back and forth about this,” she said.

Tensions were high in the courtroom even before anyone was sworn in, as Mr. Lofton’s family members became emotional as sentencing neared.

More than a half-dozen sheriff’s deputies stood between the courtroom gallery and the front of the room where Lank stood to receive her sentence. Judge Bigley told family members that if they couldn’t comport themselves, they needed to leave. Mr. Lofton’s brother left.

“I’m sorry about my son,” the victim’s father, Anthony Lofton, told the judge. “He’s upset.”

Advertise with us

The victim’s oldest sister, Simone McMeans, told the judge that her brother “didn’t deserve to die like that.”

“He was not a piece of trash to be thrown on the streets of McKees Rocks,” she said. “She shot him three times and left him for dead.”

She called the manslaughter plea “B.S.”

“She murdered him. It was homicide,” she said, her voice rising. “He was loved. He loved us and we loved him.”