Allegheny County’s recently fired chief public defender has sued the county manager she said is responsible for her termination, alleging that subordinates within the office conspired to file false complaints against her and have her ousted from her role.
Lena Bryan-Henderson, the first Black woman to lead the Public Defender’s Office, was appointed by county Executive Sara Innamorato in January 2024 and terminated last month.
The lawsuit, filed Wednesday, named John Fournier in his role as county manager and alleges wrongful termination. Ms. Bryan-Henderson is seeking to be to be reinstated, claiming the county manager doesn’t have the authority to fire her and noting that Ms. Innamorato never “indicated her position on the termination.”
County spokeswoman Abigail Gardner declined to comment on the litigation.
The lawsuit does not specifically allege racial discrimination, but it does claim that Ms. Bryan-Henderson “was not put in a position to be successful” and the “younger, predominantly white senior leadership” in the office didn’t support her appointment from the get-go.
Often, her attorney wrote in the lawsuit, “[her] initiatives faced backlash and growing pains.” Among them, she alleged, was direction from the county executive’s chief of staff to hire a specific individual as her chief deputy rather than the individual she wanted to hire.
Read More
The lawsuit detailed a series of conflicts Ms. Bryan-Henderson had with an office manager — what she described as disrespect and insubordination, including allegedly leaving in the middle of the day without permission.
The same day that Ms. Bryan-Henderson told the office manager he couldn’t leave his post without permission, “12 fabricated anonymous complaints were allegedly filed in a concerted effort to remove Ms. Bryan-Henderson,” according to the lawsuit.
The complaints, according to the lawsuit, “alleged bogus performance issues and alleged discriminatory statements and actions,” including that she “treated Black attorneys and candidates more favorable than their white counterparts.” Those complaints sparked an investigation, and Ms. Bryan-Henderson was placed on leave in early April.
Ms. Bryan-Henderson said she was informed May 14 she was being terminated on the internal investigation that, according to the lawsuit, cited those 12 anonymous complaints — “a small fraction of the 144 full-time staff.”
The lawsuit claims that Mr. Fournier said that he alone was responsible for her firing.
In addition to reinstatement, Ms. Bryan-Henderson is asking for back pay, saying that during her 1½ years in the position she “faithfully and diligently discharged the responsibility of her position.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.