A federal judge has sided with the University of Pittsburgh and UPMC in the case of a Pitt cardiologist who accused his employers of discrimination and retaliation because of an article on affirmative action he published in a medical journal in 2020.

Dr. Norman Wang filed the lawsuit in late 2020, months after he was removed from his post as the director of UPMC’s Clinical Electrophysiological Fellowship Program.

The doctor’s article, “Diversity, Inclusion, and Equity: Evolution of Race and Ethnicity Considerations for the Cardiology Workforce in the United States of American from 1969 to 2019,” was published in the Journal of the American Heart Association in March 2020.

According to the lawsuit, the piece, which Dr. Wang paid to publish, “asserted that the medical profession had not been successful in reaching its goals of increasing the percentage of underrepresented races and ethnicities in the medical profession generally, and cardiology in particular.”

Advertise with us

Four months later, the lawsuit alleged, “certain faculty physicians and executives” at UPMC, Pitt, and employee group University of Pittsburgh Physicians learned of the journal article “and objected to his conclusions.”

Days later, Dr. Kathryn Berlacher, director of the cardiovascular fellowship program, and Dr. Samir Saba, the chief of cardiology and Dr. Wang’s supervisor, relieved the cardiologist of his directorship.

Dr. Berlacher and Dr. Saba were both outspoken in their criticism of Dr. Wang’s article, alleging it relied on “misquotes” and “blatant scientific falsehoods,” according to the lawsuit. Later, Dr. Berlacher posted on social media using the @PittCardiology handle: “@PittCardiology stands for diversity equity and inclusion across the board. This article uses misquotes, false interpretations and racist thinking to defend a single person’s conclusion.” The post denigrated the journal for publishing the piece.

Later, from her own account, Dr. Berlacher wrote: “@PittCardiology I’m looking at you. What do we stand for? What do you think of this OPINION piece that misinterprets data and misquotes people?”

At the urging of Dr. Saba and others, the Journal of the American Heart Association eventually retracted the piece.

Advertise with us

Dr. Wang had argued that Dr. Saba and Dr. Berlacher were acting as university employees — that is, as state actors — when they removed the cardiologist from his directorship, thus violating his First Amendment rights. The judge, however, said they were acting as private employees on behalf of UPMC and UPP.

The judge ultimately dismissed all of Dr. Wang’s claims against the defendants, which included allegations of retaliation, discrimination, and violations of the First Amendment.