The treasurer of a Fox Chapel youth sports association allegedly spent nearly $150,000 of the association’s money at stores like Wine & Spirits and TJ Maxx, at concert venues and pet supply stores, and withdrew nearly $50,000 at ATMs, according to charges filed Thursday.
Carla O’Brien, 46, of Indiana Township, is charged with theft, receiving stolen property, and access device fraud for the alleged theft of $147,400 over roughly five years — save for the $3,500 she repaid in cash when she admitted she’d stolen money from the account.
“We are hopeful to have this matter resolved sooner rather than later,” Ms. O’Brien’s attorney, Phil DiLucente, said in a statement Friday.
Ms. O’Brien was elected treasurer of the Fox Chapel Area Baseball Softball Association in early 2019, a position from which she was voted out in July 2024, according to the criminal complaint against her. The president of the association told detectives that Ms. O’Brien put off meeting with the newly elected officers for months.
After two months, the new officers decided they couldn’t wait any longer and told Ms. O’Brien they’d be going to the bank to sort out the accounts themselves on Sept. 18, according to the complaint. That morning, Ms. O’Brien allegedly called one of the other association members “hysterically crying,” telling her, “I messed up big time,” “I took money,” and “I was in a rough spot.” Ms. O’Brien allegedly said she started taking money around the time she and her husband were in a car crash and unable to work.
The association president went to Ms. O’Brien’s home that morning where she allegedly told him, “I did it,” and “I stole the money,” according to the complaint. She estimated she’d taken around $20,000 to $30,000 that she said she used to pay off secret credit cards she kept from her husband, who she called “very restrictive with their money.”
As the association president left her home, Ms. O’Brien gave him just under $3,500 in cash, which she said was the money remaining from the association’s PNC Bank accounts, investigators wrote.
Investigators said Ms. O’Brien began using the association’s bank accounts for personal use shortly after she was elected in 2019. Purchases were made at stores ranging from Giant Eagle and Sam’s Club to Sephora and Nike. Other money was spent at restaurants, concert venues and pharmacies, while some went toward credit card and insurance payments.
Including the money she paid back, Ms. O’Brien is accused of taking just under $144,000. She was charged and released on her own recognizance. A preliminary hearing is scheduled for April 23.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.