Attorneys on both sides agree that Terrence Washington shot and killed Makeida Thompson, the mother of his child, late in the morning Nov. 10, 2020.

“This is not a ‘whodunit’ or what we would call a circumstantial case,” Deputy District Attorney Ryan Kiray told jurors in his opening statement Tuesday morning.

He said Washington, then 36, was angry that Ms. Thompson had gotten a protection from abuse order against him and said she would push for child support and for custody of their 1-year-old son, TJ. And so, Mr. Kiray alleged, he leveled a pistol at the back of Ms. Thompson’s head — in front of his grandmother who was holding the infant — and fired seven shots.

Defense attorney Thomas. N. Farrell agreed — “this is not a ‘whodunit,’” he repeated — but told jurors that Mr. Kiray “left out a few little facts.”

Advertise with us

“My client thought he was going to die that day,” he said, telling jurors that Ms. Thompson had threatened to kill Washington and “manipulated the system and created a PFA.”

The testimony in front of Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Beth Lazzara marked the start of Washington’s homicide trial. Mr. Kiray said he will ultimately ask the jurors to find Washington guilty of first-degree murder. Mr. Farrell said they’ll be presented with lesser options — like self-defense, or voluntary manslaughter.

Much of the morning testimony came from Washington’s mother, Tirzha Moore, and his grandmother, Darlene Washington.

Ms. Moore said she was surprised when her son walked into her East Liberty home that morning — he wasn’t much for popping in, she said — but she was happy to see he had the baby with him. She said she got up to fawn over the baby for a minute before her mother, Ms. Washington, came downstairs and Ms. Moore turned back to her work.

She said as surprised as she was to see her son walk in, she was even more surprised to see Ms. Thompson a few minutes later. As far as she knew, Ms. Moore said, her son and Ms. Thompson had ended their relationship.

Advertise with us

She said Ms. Thompson seemed apprehensive, and so she tried to give her a kind “hello” before Ms. Thompson walked into the living room. She said she heard Ms. Thompson and her mother talking about the baby, and she heard a cartoon on the television. She’d just gotten up to take her oatmeal off the stove when she heard loud sounds — “ear-piercing,” she called them.

She dropped to the floor, she said.

Ms. Washington painted a picture of events that were just as sudden.

She had come downstairs when she heard her grandson and the baby come in. She had told Washington recently that he should bring the baby around more, and when he showed up that morning, she thought he was making good on that request. When Ms. Thompson arrived a few minutes later, she said, she sat down on the couch, exchanging but a few words with the father of her child.

Ms. Washington said she was sitting on a swivel office chair in the living room with the baby on her lap. She had been talking about TJ with Ms. Thompson while fiddling with the television to find a children’s show. She did, and she continued to talk with Ms. Thompson while she swiveled in the chair and bounced the baby in her lap.

Advertise with us

“When I turned around, he was shooting her,” she said.

Ms. Washington told police in the immediate aftermath that she had heard her grandson say something along the lines of, “That’s what you get for messing with me.” She said that now, more than four years later, she couldn’t recall those words but knows she told the truth to investigators at the time.

Ms. Washington said she ran upstairs with the baby, and Ms. Moore said she didn’t look up from where she had dropped to the ground until the shooting stopped. She saw her son run past and out the door. He was ultimately arrested days later in Seattle.

Asked what she saw when she walked into the living room, she repeated softly: “It was horrible.”

Ms. Thompson was slumped over on the couch. She said she saw the woman move just slightly — she said she believed it was Ms. Thompson taking her last breath.

Advertise with us

“It was horrible,” she repeated.

She said her first thought was that Ms. Thompson had been the one shooting — she said she knew the juvenile probation officer always carried her gun in a holster, although she acknowledged she didn’t see Ms. Thompson with a gun that morning. Ms. Washington, too, said she never saw a gun on Ms. Thompson as the two chatted.

The recording of Ms. Moore’s 911 call paints a portrait of chaos and terror. Little of what she says can be deciphered among the anguished wailing.

She told jurors she was in shock, then quietly: “She deserves to be here to raise her kids.”

Both Ms. Moore and Ms. Washington testified that they heard no argument between Washington and Ms. Thompson before the shots were fired. They said they didn’t see any aggression on Ms. Thompson’s part.

Advertise with us

Mr. Farrell pointed out that if his client had planned to kill Ms. Thompson, he picked the wrong place since he knew his mother and grandmother were both God-fearing women who would be truthful even if the truth wasn’t in his favor.

Afternoon testimony came from a series of first responders who told jurors what they saw when they arrived at the home.

Mr. Farrell made much of the fact that there were numerous police officers walking around the home as well as at least one neighbor, implying that the scene could have been disturbed before it was photographed.

He also pointed to the fact that, at some point, one of the paramedics unplugged the television to make it easier to communicate with others on the scene. Mr. Farrell said that was an indication the television was loud — too loud — and Ms. Washington and Ms. Moore might not have heard the confrontation between Ms. Thompson and Washington that made the latter fear for his life.

Testimony will resume Wednesday morning.