Raw sewage flowing down the street. Days without water. Raccoons and skunks dwelling in apartments.
At a hearing Friday morning for one owner of the troubled MonView Heights apartment complex, West Mifflin Police Chief Gregory McCulloch testified those were just some of the deplorable conditions residents were forced to endure.
"It's very much a hazard," Chief McCulloch said.
Friday was the first of an hours-long preliminary hearing for MonView Heights co-owner Moshe Silber. Last month, Silber, Frederick Schulman, and Jonathon Liani — all of whom have addresses near the New York-New Jersey state line — were charged with diverting taxpayer and rent money meant to make the property safe and inhabitable to other business entities linked to the owners themselves.
All three men were accused of theft, receiving stolen property, conspiracy, risking a catastrophe, making a public nuisance, and dealing in the proceeds of illegal activity.
Schulman’s charges were waived to court, and charges against Mr. Liani were withdrawn after his Friday testimony against Silber.
Read More
Mr. Liani testified that he served as a "backroom accountant" for Silber — who appeared in court virtually from a correctional facility in New Jersey as he awaits sentencing on federal fraud charges — from 2019 to 2024, but had not committed any crimes.
He testified that his name only appeared on signed documents due to the accounting services he and his company typically provide. He testified he ultimately cut ties with Silber due to "outstanding balances.” He said Silber owed him $250,000.
Chief McCulloch described what he said were horrors he and his officers regularly encountered at the housing complex, usually at points where most units were occupied.
He testified that issues started cropping up in March 2023, one month after MonView was sold to Mon View Apts LLC. It was at that time that the security team for the complex decided to cut ties, a move Chief McCulloch attributed to a lack of payment.
It wasn’t long before trash started to build up, broken windows were boarded up, the playground fell into disrepair and the entire complex quickly deteriorated.
Chief McCulloch said raw sewage overflowed and leaked into the parking lot, next to a school bus stop.
"If you walked [to the bus], you were walking through raw sewage," he said.
Chief McCulloch said close to half of the tenants moved out, and the owners didn’t address or fix any of the issues.
"The property deteriorated rapidly," he said. "It's only gotten worse."
Tina Miller, Silber's attorney, pushed back on Chief McCulloch's claims that everything was "rosy" at MonView Heights before its new ownership.
She said pictures used as evidence of the conditions at MonView were taken when her client had "no involvement whatsoever" with the property.
Homeville Volunteer Fire Company Chief Ronald Lowe also testified and called the complex a safety hazard. He said results from an October 2024 water flow test showed there wasn't enough pressure in the apartment's fire hydrants to put out any significant fires and that smoke detectors don't work in many apartment units.
Chief Lowe said he told multiple property managers about these issues, but they weren’t resolved.
"If there was an actual fire, we would be delayed and life safety would be delayed," he said.
MonView Heights was sold by the Allegheny Housing Rehabilitation Corporation to Mon View Apts LLC on Feb. 23, 2023. On the same day, according to the criminal complaint against the men, AHRCO sold at least a dozen properties to the same ownership group. The ownership group formed an LLC for each property.
District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. took aim at MonView Heights last year after months' worth of failed inspections and other issues led him to cite the complex as a public nuisance. At the time, nearly a third of the 326 apartments weren't fit for occupancy, investigators said.
Mr. Zappala said last year that determining the actual ownership of the property was not easy, as the LLC that owns the apartments linked back to another LLC. He declined to name the owners at the time, saying he hoped the situation wouldn't snowball into charging those people as well.
He said the three men owning the MonView LLC are linked to 11 other regional nuisance properties.
A next hearing date for Silber's has not yet been scheduled.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.