Pennsylvania’s Judicial Conduct Board has dismissed a complaint filed against District Judge Xander Orenstein last year, ruling that nothing in the series of questionable bail decisions cited by the state legislator who filed the complaint constituted misconduct.

“Bad judgment is not a crime, unfortunately,” said Rep. Valerie Gaydos, who filed the complaint against the judge in October.

In a letter dated Feb. 14, Melissa Norton, chief counsel for the state’s Judicial Conduct Board, wrote that the board’s inquiry into the complaint “does not support a finding of probable cause of any judicial misconduct.”

The decision, Ms. Norton wrote, is final, and there is no process to appeal.

Advertise with us

The judge could not immediately be reached for comment.

Judge Orenstein, whose magisterial district includes parts of Lawrenceville, Bloomfield and Polish Hill, first came under scrutiny in 2023 after releasing a New York man caught with more than $1 million worth of suspected fentanyl at the Greyhound Bus station in Downtown Pittsburgh. Yan Carlos Pichardo Cepeda was charged with two felony counts of possession with intent to deliver and released on a nonmonetary bond.

Cepeda fled the area and was eventually arrested after a traffic stop in New York seven months later. Investigators later determined the suspected fentanyl was just a cutting agent — a substance used to bulk up the volume of fentanyl.

In April, Judge Orenstein was barred from hearing criminal arraignments after a second felony suspect the judge released without bail skipped town. In that case Hermas Craddock was accused of leading police on a high-speed chase through Aspinwall, Sharpsburg and parts of Pittsburgh. Authorities said Craddock reached speeds up to 80 mph and nearly struck two troopers in a parking lot.

Police later arrested Craddock at his uncle’s home in East Liberty along with multiple guns the uncle said did not belong to him. Craddock faced more than five dozen charges and, while most were traffic violations, seven were felonies. Judge Orenstein arraigned Craddock and released him on nonmonetary bond. He failed to show for a hearing the following week. He was ultimately arrested in Florida.

Advertise with us

Sheriff Kevin Kraus, whose office is often tasked with finding fugitives and bringing them back to Allegheny County, said at the time that Judge Orenstein’s decisions “caused hardships on law enforcement and, even more importantly, the community.”

Frustrations came to a head in the days after 44-year-old Benjamin Brallier was killed along the Montour Trail Oct. 21. Mr. Brallier, a state police Liquor Enforcement officer, was off duty and jogging when he was allegedly attacked by 25-year-old Anthony Quesen.

Sixteen months earlier, Quesen, who also goes by the name Antonia Kaseim, had been arrested after allegedly assaulting a man in Point State Park and taking his watch. Quesen was charged under the Antonia Kaseim alias with robbery, simple assault, reckless endangerment and evading arrest. On the day of the arrest, Quesen was arraigned and released on nonmonetary bond by Judge Orenstein.

It was Mr. Brallier’s murder that pushed Ms. Gaydos, R-Sewickley, to file a complaint against the judge. In it, she cited the judge’s “repeated and deliberate failure to impose reasonable bail conditions on severe violent offenders.”

Ms. Gaydos said Thursday she was dismayed by the decision, which she said essentially came down to the definition of judicial misconduct.

Advertise with us

“It’s a breach of duty, but are they criminal? That’s what it really comes down to,” she said. “It’s not criminal, it’s bad judgment.”

The revelations surrounding Quesen’s previous release sparked calls for Judge Orenstein’s impeachment among some legislators. House Republican Whip Tim O’Neal said the judge “a danger to citizens,” and state Sen. Devlin Robinson called Quesen’s release a pattern of “ineptitude and malfeasance.” Rep. Anita Kulk, a Democrat, called for an investigation and for the judge to resign.

Ms. Gaydos said she opted to file a complaint with the Judicial Conduct Board because it was a faster route than seeking impeachment. Articles of impeachment have to be introduced in the House, go through committee and then pass the House floor before the same process has to play out in the Senate. The governor then has to approve the measure.