The family of a Washington County infant — whose father faces homicide charges in connection with the boy’s 2022 death — sued the district attorney and other officials last week, alleging the infant’s remains decomposed to nearly nothing because the DA refused to release them to the funeral home for seven months.

Sawyer Clarke was 2 months old when he was fatally injured in his Peters home May 24, 2022. The District Attorney’s Office alleges the infant’s death was the result of physical abuse by his father, Jordan Clarke. Defense attorneys and the civil lawsuit maintain the injuries were accidental and caused by Clarke falling while carrying Sawyer.

The lawsuit names District Attorney Jason Walsh, Coroner Tim Warco and Common Pleas Judge John DiSalle. Allegations include intentional infliction of emotional distress and wanton mistreatment of Sawyer’s remains.

An autopsy was done May 25, and the infant’s body was turned over to a Peters funeral home the next day. Mr. Walsh, according to the lawsuit, ordered the funeral home to halt any burial or cremation despite having “no legal justification whatsoever.”

Advertise with us

An attorney for the coroner declined comment. Mr. Walsh and Judge DiSalle could not immediately be reached.

Mr. Walsh filed homicide charges against Clarke in June 2022, despite, the lawsuit notes, not having a cause or manner of death for the infant. The DA announced he would seek the death penalty two months later.

During that time — from May to September 2022 — Sawyer’s body remained stored at the funeral home and “continued to decompose, horribly,” attorney Noah Geary wrote in the lawsuit.

In September, Mr. Walsh allegedly ordered the coroner’s office to take custody of the infant’s remains — an order the lawsuit claims was signed off on by Judge DiSalle in a hearing that Clarke and his defense attorney weren’t privy to. The order directed the coroner’s office to retain custody of Sawyer’s remains “until the disposition of the criminal case.”

From September to mid-December 2022, according to the lawsuit, Mr. Warco thrice asked if he could release Sawyer’s body to the funeral home. Each time, the DA told him no.

Advertise with us

In mid-December 2022 — seven months after the infant died — his remains were released for burial. By that point, the lawsuit alleged, the infant’s remains had decomposed to nearly nothing.

The lawsuit alleged that Judge DiSalle’s order was “ludicrous” in that homicide cases on their own can last for years, and death penalty cases can drag on for decades.

“[The resulting] decomposition would be and was grotesque, outrageous, inhumane and cause [the family] of Sawyer Clarke extreme and severe emotional distress,” Mr. Geary wrote.

Further allegations

Beyond holding the infant’s body, the lawsuit also accuses Mr. Walsh of circumventing the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office in “an unethical effort to control what the ultimate opinion/conclusion would be on the manner of death.”

While the infant’s injuries happened in Washington County, he died at an Allegheny County hospital. Within an hour of Sawyer’s death, the lawsuit claims, Mr. Walsh’s office was attempting to have the infant’s body turned over to the Washington County coroner’s office.

Advertise with us

The autopsy was ultimately done by the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office, which ruled the cause of death as a brain bleed and the manner of death as undetermined.

Mr. Walsh, unhappy with that ruling, directed Mr. Warco to file “an invalid, bogus death certificate” that attributed Sawyer’s death to “shaken baby syndrome,” according to the lawsuit. The state records officer rejected the alleged bogus death certificate, attorneys wrote.