Jurors in the civil case brought by Jordan Brown ruled in favor of the four troopers who investigated and charged him with fatally shooting his father’s pregnant, sleeping fiancee when he was 11 years old.
The eight jurors came back with a unanimous verdict shortly before 2 p.m. Thursday, finding there was no fabrication of evidence or malicious prosecution in the case against Mr. Brown, who is now 26. The jurors deliberated for a total of nine hours, beginning Wednesday afternoon.
The trial before U.S. District Court Judge W. Scott Hardy began on Dec. 4.
"We're very happy that the troopers have been vindicated," said Nicole Boland, an attorney representing troopers — Janice Wilson, Jeffrey Martin, Troy Steinheiser and Robert McGraw, who died in 2022.
Kenzie Houk, 26, was found on Feb. 20, 2009, in the Lawrence County farmhouse she lived in with Mr. Brown, his father, Chris Brown, and Houk’s two daughters, ages 4 and 7. She was lying in bed and had been killed by a gunshot blast to the back of her head. Her unborn baby boy also died.
After clearing Chris Brown and other suspects, Jordan Brown was arrested and charged with Houk’s murder.
Read More
Jordan Brown was ultimately adjudicated delinquent of Houk’s murder in 2012. The state Supreme Court overturned his conviction in 2018, citing insufficient evidence. He had already been out of custody for two years at that point.
The lawsuit claimed the troopers fabricated evidence and ultimately “stole his entire childhood.”
Jordan Brown was seeking damages to account for what his attorney Alec Wright called “emotional and mental harm including fear, humiliation, and mental anguish.”
Following the verdict, Mr. Wright said he was disappointed.
"I promised Jordan when we undertook this battle that we would succeed," he said.
Jennifer Kraner, Houk's sister, said it was difficult for the family to listen to days of testimony about what happened in 2009.
"This has been awful to have to relive this. I'm very pleased with the outcome, I thank God," Ms. Kraner said.
During the trial, Mr. Wright told jurors that based on the evidence presented, investigators rushed to judgment in arresting Jordan Brown. He questioned the reliability of testimony from Houk’s daughter, who was only 7 when her mother was killed and was awake for 17 hours when police interviewed her.
Mr. Wright also told jurors that state troopers failed to hone in on who he called the most likely suspect in the case: Houk’s former boyfriend, who had previously threatened her and against whom she had several restraining orders.
Ms. Boland, the attorney representing the troopers, told the jurors the case was not about whether the investigation was conducted perfectly, but rather whether there was enough probable cause to arrest and charge Jordan Brown. She said the troopers didn’t want to arrest the 11-year-old, but all of the evidence pointed to him.
For the troopers' defense team, the outcome was what they wanted, and appropriate, but nothing to celebrate.
"It's an incredibly sad case. What's lost in all this was a mother was taken from her children and a family lost their daughter," attorney Brendan O'Malley told Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV, adding, "We are happy the troopers were vindicated, and their investigation was vindicated."
—Jacob Geanous contributed to this report




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.