Prosecutors won’t seek the death penalty against a triple-homicide suspect set to go to trial next week, citing an “untimely” defense motion to bar the penalty and the judge’s refusal to postpone the trial.
Ronald Steave is accused of killing Tatiana Hill and Nandi Fitzgerald, both 28, and Fitzgerald’s 12-year-old son, Denzel ‘Buddy’ Nowlin Jr., on New Year’s Eve in 2021. The three were found shot to death in a home on Hamilton Avenue in Pittsburgh’s Homewood neighborhood.
Defense attorneys recently alleged Steave is intellectually disabled, which, under a 2002 U.S. Supreme Court decision, would make him ineligible for the death penalty.
Deputy District Attorney Brian Catanzarite had asked Common Pleas Judge Edward J. Borkowski to postpone the trial so prosecutors could obtain all the relevant records and retain their own expert to evaluate Steave. Jury selection was supposed to begin Monday with testimony beginning Oct. 31.
Defense attorneys, too, sought to delay the proceedings, but Judge Borkowski declined to do so during a brief hearing Monday morning. He said the jury, if they convict Steave, could decide whether he’s eligible for the death penalty during the sentencing phase.
“The court has been clear all along — this is the trial date,” the judge said. “This case is going to trial.”
Read More
The DA’s office referred to the tight time frame in rescinding the death penalty.
“The trial court has denied the postponement request [by the defense] and the corresponding request by the prosecution for additional time to obtain defendant’s records for review by a [prosecution] expert,” the notice said, citing the prosecution’s “ethical duty to proceed as a minister of justice.”
Investigators have said Steave’s car was near the home the night of the killings and, when they located the car in McKeesport, they found shell casings matching those found at the Homewood scene. Photos on Fitzgerald’s phone showed herself, Hill, and Steave together that night.
Steave was taken into custody in March 2022, and the DA’s office announced it would seek the death penalty two months later.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.