The family of a woman hit and killed on the West End Bridge earlier this year is suing the bar that served her that night as well as the Pittsburgh police officers they say let the intoxicated woman walk into the January night without a safe way home.

Faye McCoy, 44, died early Jan. 27 when she was hit by a vehicle and thrown off of the bridge. She was found around 8 a.m. below the bridge on North Point Drive. Police believe she was hit sometime around 3 a.m.

No arrests have been made in connection with McCoy’s death. Police at the time described the vehicle as a small blue or black sedan with silver wheels, possibly a Honda or a Hyundai.

The lawsuit filed this week names the city, the owner of Art’s Tavern, and Officers Zacariah Norman, Emily Shields, and Michael Sokolowski. City officials did not immediately respond to requests for comment. A representative for Art’s Tavern could not be reached Friday afternoon.

Advertise with us

Public safety spokeswoman Cara Cruz said that while police officials could not comment on the litigation, “the Collision Investigation Unit’s investigation into Ms. McCoy’s death remains active and ongoing.”

Not long before she was struck, McCoy had been in the car with her friend, identified in the lawsuit as Nakila Crawford-Creighton. It was McCoy’s vehicle, but Ms. Crawford-Creighton was driving. The pair had been at several bars over the course of the night, including Art’s Tavern in the Strip District. Art’s Tavern played a role in McCoy’s death, according to the lawsuit, because McCoy continued to be served despite the fact she was “beyond the point at which she was visibly intoxicated.”

Shortly before 3 a.m., Ms. Crawford-Creighton crashed into a median in the West End Circle, an intersection the lawsuit claims is “the most dangerous intersection in Allegheny County,” in part because of “a traffic circle, multiple lights, and shifting lanes.”

Police responded to the crash and arrested Ms. Crawford-Creighton on suspicion of driving under the influence. The lawsuit claims that McCoy was briefly taken into custody when she failed to heed police orders but was released once her friend was in custody.

The lawsuit alleges that officers called a tow truck to take McCoy’s car and took Ms. Crawford-Creighton into custody, leaving McCoy in a state such that “it would not be safe for her to leave the location by foot.”

Advertise with us

The officers should have recognized that McCoy was so intoxicated “she was unfit to safely care for herself,” not dressed for the weather, and about to walk away through a dark, desolate, dangerous intersection.

The lawsuit cites Pittsburgh police policy: “If the person is released, police shall ensure that the person is released at a safe location and is not otherwise placed at risk as a result of the incident. If necessary, police should provide transportation for the released person to a safe location.”

“Ultimately,” the lawsuit contends, “Ms. McCoy, a scantily dressed, intoxicated single woman, during the early morning hours of a cold dark day in January, was released by the [responding officers] and expected to fend for herself and navigate an area of the city of Pittsburgh that has been regarded as the ‘most dangerous intersection in Allegheny County.’”

The Citizen Police Review Board opened an investigation into the incident in the aftermath. Executive Director Elizabeth Pittinger, during the CPRB meeting days after McCoy’s death, questioned whether a social worker from the Office of Community Health and Safety could have changed the outcome.

The city’s co-responder program, which pairs social workers with police on calls related to things like mental health or substance abuse, only covers parts of the city.

Advertise with us

Ms. Pittinger alluded to reports that officers at the scene tried to offer McCoy a ride but she was unwilling to go with police. Someone with a social work background might have “de-escalated [McCoy’s] anxiety about police and perhaps accomplished getting a ride for [her].”

“We don’t know, we’ll never know,” she said. “But the resource was not available to [officers].”

According to the criminal complaint against Ms. Crawford-Creighton, she and McCoy argued briefly in front of responding officers about how they would get home. Police alleged Ms. Crawford-Creighton became combative with the officers, and she had to be forced into custody.

Ms. Crawford-Creighton’s non-jury trial on charges of driving under the influence, public drunkenness, resisting arrest, disorderly conduct and other traffic violations is scheduled for later this month.