The victims of multiple incidents of ethnic intimidation and harassment on the North Side have reached a tentative deal with the person allegedly involved in one of those incidents.

Mario Ashkar, 36, was arrested in early May and charged with ethnic intimidation, criminal mischief, theft by unlawful taking and disorderly conduct for ripping down an Israeli flag and throwing it in the trash outside of a home.

In the criminal complaint, officers wrote that with a noticeable rise in antisemtic acts nationwide, “this act was clearly done to intimidate, harass and annoy the victim.”

Monday afternoon, Ashkar and the victims, who have asked to remain anonymous out of fear of further escalated attacks, agreed to a deal that is contingent upon a judge’s approval. 

Advertise with us

Both sides have agreed that Ashkar would complete the Accelerated Rehabilitative Disposition program, which is a Pennsylvania program for first-time offenders with no or limited criminal records. Additionally, Ashkar would have to complete 20 hours of community service at a Jewish nonprofit organization and be on probation for one year with the ability to end early for good behavior.

One of the victims has also asked that she and Ashkar sit down for a conversation, mediated by a third-party — an uncommon ask from victims.

“This was an issue of hate,” she said Monday afternoon outside the city’s Municipal Court Building. “The only way we fight hate is communication.”

One of the victims, who is Jewish, has said multiple times that she believed they were being targeted because of their faith. She had initially put a small garden version of the Israeli flag in a flower pot outside her home “because I would like the hostages to come home.”

She asked for a conversation with Ashkar as a way to initiate what she hoped would be productive communication. Even if both parties walk away still disagreeing, at least they had a chance to communicate their differences, she said. 

Advertise with us

“Jail doesn’t change anyone’s mind ... doesn’t create empathy,” she said, but she’s hoping this conversation will at least “humanize” both sides of this situation. 

Ashkar also wrote a letter of apology to the victims.

A judge still has to approve the agreement at a formal arraignment, which is currently scheduled for the end of September.

Ashkar declined to comment on the agreement through attorney Adam Bishop. 

The female victim said there were other incidents in the spring that targeted her home.

Advertise with us

Multiple times another person, who police are still looking for, left papers in her mailbox or glued to her front door that showed graphic images from the Israeli-Hamas war. One incident included the phrase “for blood and soil” in large letters on the sidewalk in front of her home.

The term “blood and soil” is a Nazi slogan intended to evoke the idea of a “pure race,” according to the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum. “Blood” referred to the concept of a pure “Aryan” race and “soil invoked a mystical vision of the special relationship between the Germanic people and their land,” according to the museum. 

Ashkar’s arrest has prompted internal investigations within the city of Pittsburgh. The day of Ashkar’s arrest in May, city Controller Rachael Heisler sent a letter to City Council members explaining that Ashkar had been a contract employee of the city’s and was being improperly paid via the payment card program. 

Ashkar had been hired by the city’s Department of Parks and Recreation to help assist in facilitating the farmers markets. 

The payments to Ashkar, which were sent via a PayPal account, violated city policy. City Council members and with Ms. Heisler said they would be looking further into the matter. 

Advertise with us

Mayor Ed Gainey, referred the situation to the Office of Municipal Investigations rather than complying with records requests from Ms. Heisler.

About a month before Ms. Heisler brought the policy violations to light, an employee within the Department of Parks and Recreation raised concerns about “overuse” of the p-cards to pay Ashkar, according to documents obtained by the Post-Gazette. 

In other documents, Parks and Rec Director Katherine Vargas took the blame for the misuse of the p-cards.

While OMI investigates the matter further, Ms. Heisler’s office has begun an audit of the parks department's use of p-cards and members of City Council, who have the final approval of payments, are considering revisions to their approval process.