As two teams of Secret Service counter-snipers scanned the outer perimeter of Donald Trump’s rally on July 13, they had a crucial blind spot: a stand of large trees that shielded the portion of the roof the gunman used to crawl into place.

Photos taken by the Post-Gazette from both the shooter’s perspective and that of the counter-sniper teams clearly show the obstruction and raise new questions about why no law enforcement officers were stationed on a rooftop that was not in full view of the government’s sharpshooters.

Those and other vulnerabilities throughout the Butler farm grounds that allowed Thomas Matthew Crooks to crawl unimpeded onto the metal roof were clear to security experts in the immediate aftermath of the assassination attempt, and they were clear Monday to a bipartisan group of lawmakers who were among the first outsiders to stand where Crooks tried to kill the former president.

“One thing is for sure — it’s way too close,” said Rep. Michael McCaul, a Texas Republican. “I’ve been up on that rooftop looking at where the president was relative to the roof. It’s so close for a sniper.”

Advertise with us

Mr. McCaul was among 11 members of the House Committee on Homeland Security to tour the Butler Farm Show grounds before rain moved in Monday, nine days after Crooks opened fire on the Trump campaign rally, killing one spectator and wounding two others as well as the candidate.

Republican Rep. Mike Kelly, whose district includes Butler, joined committee members on the tour. He said the committee needs to assure citizens that “this is never going to happen again.”

“The American people have the right to know, and we have the responsibility to get answers for them,” he said.

Among the unanswered questions: Why were counter-snipers so poorly positioned in relation to the AGR building where Crooks took aim — a one-story building that was actually one in a series of interconnected structures just outside the rally’s so-called hard perimeter.

From the perspective of the counter-sniper team that was closest to the gunman, two trees almost completely block the view of nearly a third of the roof that Crooks used as a firing position to take aim at the former president, the aerial photos show.

Advertise with us
This vantage point shows what Secret Service snipers saw when looking toward the roof where a gunman shot from to try kill former President Donald Trump. (Tim Robbibaro / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Farther away, the second team of counter-snipers was similarly blocked from seeing about a quarter of the low roof, although a Post-Gazette analysis of the images show those snipers had the clearer shot at Crooks once he started firing.

In the moments before the gunman crested the roofline, however, its gentle slope could have allowed him to crawl up to the peak unseen, the images show.

How Crooks was able to move into a firing position with a clear shot of the former president has been a key question in the aftermath of the deadly assault, one echoed by committee members who surveyed the scene — including from that vantage point.

“You don’t have to be a security expert to see the massive number of vulnerabilities,” said Rep. Josh Brecheen, a Mississippi Republican who said there were at least 30 buildings within 500 yards of where the former president was speaking last week.

“We, as members of Congress, have drones above us right now,” he said, gesturing toward the several drones hovering above the farm grounds. “Why were there not drones being able to spot not only the vulnerability of the building where the shooter was, but the 30 different potential locations where our president could have been taken out from?

Advertise with us

“We need answers to know why in the world so many vulnerabilities in the outer perimeter were allowed to exist,” he said.

This drone photo shows the perspective of the gunman who tried to kill Donald Trump during a rally at the Butler Farm Show grounds. (Tim Robbibaro / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Those questions are only deepened by the images that show the scene through the snipers’ eyes — blind spots and all, said Anthony Cangelosi, a former Secret Service agent who was part of the advance teams that secured presidential campaign stops during the 2004 election.

"The failure to have someone on that roof is epic. I've been looking for excuses why they would not have someone on the roof," said Mr. Cangelosi, who was not on the tour but reviewed the Post-Gazette’s photos independently. “The objective for any detail is to ensure the integrity of that roof.”

Much has been made of that particular roof, its slope, and the lack of law enforcement coverage. Some law enforcement officials, including U.S. Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle, have said the slope made the roof unsafe for authorities.

“I was on that roof,” said Rep. Carlos Gimenez, R-Fla. “I’m 70 years old. There’s nothing unsafe about that roof.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Cangelosi, too, questioned the veracity of the director’s explanation.

“I'm not buying the sloped-roof [excuse], but if you want to give them the benefit of the doubt, then what was done to counter the vulnerability? And right now, the answers have been so lukewarm and wishy-washy,” he said.

The fact that the sniper team that was farthest from the shooter appears to have had the only clear shot at Crooks could’ve further delayed any return fire, he said. They had to monitor the area in the opposite direction of the gunman, and would’ve had a worse view of him than the closer team — if the closer team had been able to see him.

“It's not an easy thing to take a shot as a counter-sniper,” Mr. Cangelosi said. “You want to be absolutely sure that that person poses an imminent threat to life. An individual on the roof, alone, is not enough. … You don’t just shoot the person unless you see a weapon.”

The security failure, which Ms. Cheatle told Congress Monday was the agency's worst in decades, extended beyond the candidate, Mr. Cangelosi said. The agency's job is to keep attendees safe, too, he said.

Advertise with us

“Whoever they were for — whether they're for President Trump or President Biden or Robert Kennedy — they're participating in democracy, in the democratic process,” Mr. Cangelosi said. “If they no longer feel safe to do so, that's a loss for us as a nation.”

Mike Wereschagin: mwereschagin@post-gazette.com; @wrschgn

Megan Guza: mguza@post-gazette.com; @meganguzaPG