Allegheny County President Judge Susan Evashavik DiLucente temporarily banned Jail Oversight Board members Bethany Hallam and Muhammad Ali Nasir (known as MAN-E) from making unannounced inspections at the jail because they were violating state law, the judge revealed during the board’s monthly meeting Wednesday.

The judge also serves as chair of the oversight board.

Ms. Hallam and many of her supporters at the meeting said the judge’s action was a gross overreach, but Judge DiLucente said state law is clear that any unannounced visits require a prompt report from the board members making the visit.

Judge DiLucente departed promptly and could not be reached for comment. But she and Ms. Hallam briefly argued during the meeting about whether state law or the board’s bylaws required those reports.

Advertise with us

“Nobody has ever changed the [state] statutes,” Judge DiLucente said. “I have only been on this board in 2024; I don’t know what’s happened in the past, but the law has always been the law — that has always been your requirement [to submit reports].”

Ms. Hallam replied that the board has allowed the jail administration to not follow bylaws passed by the oversight board, but that she would “be the bigger person” and comply with the judge’s orders.

This is not the first time a judge and board member has been critical of Ms. Hallam's unannounced visits without submitting reports. During multiple jail oversight board meetings last year, Common Pleas Judge Elliot Howsie, then chair of the board, told Ms. Hallam that she needed to submit reports, alluding to the state law. Judge Howsie, however, did not ban any visits.

Ms. Hallam and MAN-E, who, according to their social media posts, are in a relationship, submitted four inspection reports at Wednesday’s meeting — one each for March, April, May, and June — “in protest,” saying that state law does not require it. They summarized details from some of those reports during the meeting.

It’s unclear how long the ban on unannounced visits for Ms. Hallam or MAN-E lasted, but their last report was dated June 29.

Advertise with us

State law establishing jail oversight boards for counties dictates: “The board shall, at least twice each year, conduct an unannounced inspection of the prison's physical plant. During such inspections, the board shall interview a cross section of inmates, out of the presence of the warden and his agents, to determine the conditions within the prison and alternative housing facilities. After each inspection, the board shall prepare a written report setting forth its findings and determinations which shall be available for public inspection.”

Ms. Hallam and MAN-E’s reports described a litany of issues, including broken electronic tablets that inmates can’t use, health care concerns, and alleged abuses of force.

Board hears issues about correctional officer staffing

For months, members of the Jail Oversight Board have heard complaints about the environment for health care workers inside the jail. On Wednesday, they heard the same from correctional officers, through a survey that 194 officers completed.

When asked if they felt valued and respected as a correctional officer at the jail, more than 81% said they “disagreed” or “strongly disagreed.”

Nearly 90% “strongly disagreed” that each shift has enough correctional officers, and 84% “disagreed” or “strongly disagreed” that they have flexibility within their schedules to address personal or family needs.

Advertise with us

The survey was conducted by John Kenstowicz from  the Pennsylvania Interfaith Impact Network who has closely followed jail issues for years.

Based on the survey’s findings, Mr. Kenstowicz and others have called for jail officials to address forced overtime, adjust pay scales for new officers, and initiate training programs for officers based on potential scenarios in the jail.

Multiple correctional officers read comments from the survey at Wednesday’s meeting. Forced overtime is taking those workers away from their families and affecting their mental health, they said.

One wife of a correctional officer said her husband is away so much that she has to act as mother and father, essentially raising their children alone. All the overtime pay in the world, she said, doesn’t equal the time her kids lose with their father.

“I am the one living the life of a single mother, one who has been married for nine years,” she said.

Advertise with us

Toward the end of the meeting, board Vice Chair Rob Perkins asked how many people would be needed to reduce for forced overtime on correctional officers.

Interim Warden Shane T. Dady said that he didn’t want to get into specifics, as the correctional officers’ union was in contract negotiations. But he did say after follow-up questions that fewer inmates in the jail would mean fewer correctional officers would be needed.