The federal agency that has been protecting American presidents for more than a century is suddenly an investigative target of its own in the aftermath of an assassination attempt by a 20-year-old who nearly gunned down former President Donald Trump.
The U.S. Secret Service is now the focus of at least three federal probes and countless questions about the security breaches in Butler County that allowed Thomas Matthew Crooks to fire multiple rounds from an elevated position at the Republican candidate — shots that grazed him, wounded two and killed a father shielding his family from the gunfire.
“At the Secret Service, you have a zero-fail mission,” said Jason Russell, a former agent who protected presidents and vice presidents throughout two campaign cycles. “If you fail, it can change the course of history.”
The shooting has upended the U.S. presidential race just as Republican delegates gathered in Milwaukee to nominate the man who came within millimeters of being killed at the Butler Farm Show grounds on Saturday.
On Monday, the Senate Homeland Security and Government Affairs Committee launched an inquiry into the agency’s failures while another probe was ordered Sunday by President Joe Biden. On Friday, Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle will testify before the House Government Oversight Committee in what could turn into a contentious hearing.
Law enforcement officials and experts in protecting dignitaries have expressed outrage that Crooks was able to climb onto a roof less than 150 yards from the stage where Trump was speaking, with a clear line of sight to the candidate.
Read More
"Elevated surfaces — those are your priority for assassination positions," said Chris Grollnek, founder of the Active Shooter Prevention Project in Texas. "It doesn't matter if they are local police or the Secret Service. Two people should have been on those elevations."
Local and state police agencies had been called in to help secure the event, but Butler County District Attorney Richard Goldinger said the Secret Service had ultimate responsibility for security of the event, which drew thousands of Trump supporters to the farm show grounds.
“I don’t want to be in a spat with them,” Mr. Goldinger said. “But at the same time, they’re in charge, so they have to make sure all the Is are dotted and the Ts are crossed.”
Local law enforcement agencies provided four sniper teams and four quick-response teams, he said.
“They were there to assist,” he said, noting that the hierarchy was “the Secret Service was running the show,” state police were next in line, and local police provided support.
That’s a common, necessary practice for the Secret Service, whose locally based agents maintain close ties with nearby police agencies and call on them to fill gaps in security at campaign stops and other major events involving public officials under their protection.
In the run-up to an event, the Secret Service agent in charge meets with local command officers to help put the protections in place, said Mr. Russell, who protected the candidates during George W. Bush’s reelection in 2004 and Barack Obama’s campaign in 2008.
“You're trying to use officers mostly in the outer perimeters to supplement the Secret Service, which is generally the inner perimeter. So you're giving them specific duties,” Mr. Russell said.
It’s not unusual for local law enforcement officers to outnumber Secret Service agents by five to one or more, he said.
Within hours of the bloodied former president being rushed offstage by agents and shepherded into an SUV, experts began poring over the scene and spotting potential failure points that could have allowed Crooks to have a clean shot.
In the weeks to follow, investigators are expected to study the elevations for any blind spots that may have prevented snipers from seeing the gunman until just before he opened fire.
Mr. Russell speculated that the building where the Secret Service snipers were positioned was the same height as the one where Crooks took aim.
Because the roofs are pitched, the agents may not have been able to spot the shooter.
“My speculation is he was probably on the slope of the roof that they couldn't see,” he said. “And once he heard President Trump talking, he crawled up to the peak, popped his gun over the peak, drew a sight picture, and fired. And that could happen within a few seconds.”
That makes securing access to every building all the more important, Mr. Grollnek said.
Though the building was outside the fenced-off area with the highest security, Secret Service was still responsible for an area of at least 1,000 yards beyond the point where the former president was speaking, Mr. Grollnek said.
The rooftop from which Crooks shot was well within that range, but in an area being patrolled by local law enforcement. Rally-goers had spotted Crooks and alerted officers, two of whom were told to “go check this guy out,” Butler County Sheriff Michael Slupe told KDKA Radio on Monday.
“This was a municipal police officer and they were responding to a suspicious person — ‘Hey, just go ID this guy, OK?’” he said.
He said the officer did “exactly what they are trained to do,” which was maneuver along the building to an area where the officer could be lifted up to the roof. As the officer’s head cleared the edge of the roof, Crooks turned toward him with his rifle, Mr. Slupe said.
“What are you going to do, climb up there and get shot?” the sheriff said. “No, get down [and] radio what’s going on.”
But some witnesses have said they told police the man on the roof was armed. If that was the case, the officer should’ve scaled the building with his gun drawn, Mr. Grollnek said.
"You're going to tell me someone is going to walk up a ladder to look for a man with a gun and [the officer] is without [his own] gun?" Mr. Grollnek said.
The reliance on local law enforcement becomes even more critical in election years, when manpower becomes a constant challenge for the Secret Service, Mr. Russel said.
Trump’s visit came at an especially busy time for the agency.
The NATO Summit, which drew top leaders of America’s closest allies to Washington, D.C., had wrapped up just two days earlier. Halfway across the country, the massive undertaking of securing the Republican National Convention in Wisconsin was already well underway, requiring even more agents.
And on the day of the rally itself, still more of the Secret Service’s resources were tied up protecting First Lady Jill Biden’s visit to Pittsburgh and Vice President Kamala Harris’ trip to Philadelphia.
“The Secret Service is really being stretched pretty thin right now,” Mr. Russell said. “There's a lot to do and not enough people to do it with.”
Whether the agency was able to deploy enough people to staff the event with its own agents and local police is one of the key questions that need to be answered, U.S. Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Pa., said in an interview.
“Did we have enough manpower? Did we have enough surveillance? Why didn’t we see this guy?” Mr. Kelly said as he prepared to head to Milwaukee for the GOP convention.
Mr. Kelly was sitting in the front row at the Butler rally Saturday when the shots rang out.
“I said, ‘My God, the president’s been shot,’” Mr. Kelly said. After the gunfire died down, he heard a surreal mix of noises: “people crying, people screaming, people shouting, ‘USA.’”
As the roles of both Secret Service and local law enforcement are scrutinized over the next several weeks, Mr. Grollnek said that blame will more than likely be cast on both the federal agency and regional departments for the breakdowns that took place.
But ultimately, the agency guarding the former president is responsible, he said.
"It's the Secret Service's watch,” said Mr. Grollnek. “When you are in charge, you are in charge of everything — good or bad."



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.