Those are gunshots.
That’s probably the first thought I can remember after the shooting started. I can’t remember how many. I couldn’t say whether I flinched.
But I knew the direction that they came from. Standing on the front row of the press riser — perched 5 feet or so off the ground, above the crowd and directly in front of where Donald Trump had just been standing — I had a closeup, 3D view Saturday of the events that unfolded at the Butler Farm Show grounds.
The first few seconds are a blur. I can’t say I heard the screams I later heard on late-night rebroadcasts of the shooting, which left the former president and two other people wounded and another man dead.
But on that media perch, the target of the shots became clear. Maybe that’s why ducking didn’t occur to me.
The crowd on the side of the stage nearest to the gunman started to disperse. I couldn’t tell whether the shots came from one of those people, from ground level or just over the fence behind them.
Read More
Just as fast as the shots started, they stopped. It all happened so fast, it may not have fully registered with many in attendance. Some probably thought the gunfire was fireworks; others may have believed the pops came from a video on the large monitors set up for Trump’s speech.
I thought about counter-protesters at other events. I thought that maybe some in the crowd had subdued the gunman.
As I turned toward the origin of that commotion, I thought Trump had been whisked away. By that point, Secret Service agents and other law enforcement had moved to cover him behind the podium, out of sight.
The moments that followed were like sitting on a couch, watching a movie. Aside from the part of the crowd that had bolted at the first sound of gunfire, many people stood their ground, dialed in to where Trump had been, phones and cameras in hand.
What was probably just seconds of confusion felt longer. And then, the Secret Service agents popped up from behind the podium, surrounding a bloody Trump and removing him from the stage.
The world now has that image seared into its collective conscience: The wave, the fist in the air, the blood coming from his ear.
The 24 hours that have passed since then have left me alternating between being dazed, shocked and angry.
But there have also been moments of hope after witnessing a community already on the rebound from Saturday’s tragedy.
And then there’s the uncertainty — what’s going to happen in the next few weeks and months as the country moves forward and elects a president?
The moments that followed the president’s rise from the floor of the farm show stage took me through all of those emotions.
The brief chants of “U.S.A., U.S.A” after the former president was hustled away took me back to a time when the country was united, such as after 9/11 or the “Miracle on Ice” U.S. hockey win at the 1980 Winter Olympics.
Some of that hope of unity was quickly dashed.
The doors on the former president’s motorcade had barely closed when some in the remaining audience, between the podium and the press area, turned and shouted expletives, with raised middle fingers, at the news crews.
“This is your fault.” “Expletive you.”
It took me back to the reality of partisanship, hostility, risk.
As a news photographer, I make those assessments at every football game, every political event, every large gathering.
“What could happen?” I ask myself. On Saturday it did.
Law enforcement dispersed the crowd shortly thereafter. Their efforts Saturday were commendable. I’m just a camera guy on a riser. Those men and women face it head-on.
The rest of the evening turned to some level of stunned disbelief and, for those of us in the media, a rush to find an internet signal so we could file our photographs and our stories.
After staying with a friend in the Butler area Saturday night, I clocked back in at 8:15 a.m. Sunday.
People went to church and got their morning coffee at GetGo and Sheetz like nothing had happened. The area around the Butler Farm Show grounds stayed restricted as shooting investigators continued their work.
What I saw Sunday was people getting back to normalcy. I spoke to a man who said he had hope that the nation could come back together. He hung an American flag on a construction sign outside of a Sheetz near the show grounds. While he acknowledged he was a Trump supporter, he said he disagreed with some of the former president’s past rhetoric and wondered about what’s next.
I heard Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro denounce political violence at a press conference and call for cooler heads. I heard him honor the Trump rally attendee who was killed, reportedly while protecting his family from the bullets.
I heard positive messages from politicians denouncing violence. Butler Mayor Bob Dandoy, a Democrat, described a predominantly conservative Butler County as a place where, for many, political affiliations don’t matter. It’s just about the community and your neighbors.
He admitted there is political disagreement, but it doesn’t rise to the abject hatred that fills our TV screens each day.
It made me hope that we can move toward the picture Mr. Dandoy painted of his Butler County, a place filled with hope, resilience and still moving forward.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.