An Indiana County woman has been sentenced to life in prison without parole for the kidnapping and murder of Hayden Garreffa, 19, in 2022, Indiana County District Attorney Robert Manzi announced Wednesday.

Taylyn Edwards, 20, of Johnstown, was charged with first-degree murder and was additionally sentenced to no less than five years and no more than 10 years in a state correctional facility for kidnapping charges.

She previously pleaded guilty but mentally ill, according to a release from the Indiana County DA’s office, though her plea does not have an impact on the grading of the charges against her or the type of sentencing she received. County President Judge Thomas M. Bianco presided over the case.

The sentencing follows the death of Garreffa, who was found on Oct. 20, 2022, in a remote wooded area in Brush Valley, according to police. He’d been reported missing two days prior. Officials ruled his death a homicide from the start, noting that the teenager was beaten and then stabbed multiple times in his head, neck and upper body.

Advertise with us

Police charged seven others in connection to the incident: Desean Garcia Alvarez; Isaac Joel Buchkoski; Mia Shai Catalfano; Thomas Alan Rivera; Summer Isabella Settlemyer; Harmony Rhyne Hayward; and Jesse Lee Wadsworth. All are from Johnstown save for Mr. Alvarez, whose address is listed as Hammond, Ind.

The seven had been charged for kidnapping, but the charges were later adjusted to add criminal homicide. All of the accused were denied bail.

In Wednesday’s announcement, Mr. Manzi said that the remaining seven co-defendants’ cases are still active.

Ciara McEneany: cmceneany@post-gazette.com