Eight people, including one child, are accused of having a hand in the kidnapping and stabbing of an Indiana County teenager found dead in the woods over the weekend, police said Tuesday.

Hayden Garreffa, 19, was found dead about 4 a.m. Saturday in a remote wooded area in Brush Valley, according to police. He’d been reported missing two days prior.

Officials announced Monday they’d found Mr. Garreffa, and they ruled his death a homicide from the start. State police Trooper Cliff Greenfield expounded in a media briefing Tuesday, noting that the teenager was beaten and then stabbed multiple times in his head, neck and upper body.

Seven adults and a 14-year-old girl are in custody and have been charged with first-degree kidnapping — a felony. The 14-year-old, whom authorities did not identify, is being held in a juvenile detention center.

Advertise with us

Court records for the adults show all were denied bail, with District Judge Susanne V. Steffee noting in the denial that “[additional] charges will be filed [and] defendant is a flight risk.”

The adults charged are: Desean Garcia Alvarez, 19; Isaac Joel Buchkoski, 21; Mia Shai Catalfano, 18; Taylyn Nashell Edwards, 18; Thomas Alan Rivera, 20; Summer Isabella Settlemyer, 18; and Jesse Lee Wadsworth, 18. All are from Johnstown save for Mr. Alvarez, whose address is listed as Hammond, Ind.

All face one count of kidnapping to facilitate a felony; Mr. Buchkoski and Ms. Settlemyer are also charged with conspiracy to commit kidnapping.

District Attorney Robert F. Manzi Jr. said the investigation will continue for some time.

“In a crime of this nature in which all of your witnesses or majority of witnesses are involved in the crime, there is a great deal of evidence we have to comb through,” he said, noting that investigators must determine “the level of culpability of each defendant.”

Advertise with us

“You will be seeing homicide charges,” Mr. Manzi said.

Mr. Manzi and Trooper Greenfield declined to discuss a motive behind the kidnapping and homicide, but the criminal complaint notes that investigators learned Mr. Buchkoski “bore ill will toward the victim due to a prior incident involving the accused’s girlfriend.”

A witness told police the incident started around 11 a.m. Thursday when four people, including Mr. Buchkoski, who is Mr. Garreffa’s cousin, arrived at the home in Dilltown where Mr. Garreffa was staying.

According to the criminal complaint, a witness said there was an argument, and Mr. Buchkoski and the others ultimately left.

Around 2 p.m., Mr. Buchkoski and “several other individuals” came back to the home and allegedly lured Mr. Garreffa outside, according to investigators, who said Mr. Garreffa was then prompted into a red Chrysler van.

Advertise with us

The witness told police that as Mr. Buchkoski was walking out of the home, he told the witness, “You won’t have to worry about [Mr. Garreffa] again, because he will be dead before the end of the day,” according to the complaint.

The witness called Mr. Garreffa’s grandmother, who called police. According to the complaint, she noted that her grandson had autism and would have never left without his phone or medication, both of which were left behind.

The county coroner estimated that Mr. Garreffa was dead a half-hour later.

Investigators said Mr. Garreffa was driven to a remote location near Oneida Mine Road, about two miles from his home, where he was taken out of the van, beaten and ultimately stabbed. He was dragged a short distance and left in tall weeds near an access road, police said.

Those involved allegedly left in the same red van and eventually drove to Johnstown, where most were ultimately arrested, police said.