A judge on Tuesday affirmed there is enough evidence for prosecutors to pursue a third-degree murder charge against the driver involved in a high-speed crash that killed a Dravosburg teenager last year.

William Soliday II is charged with homicide in connection with the Sept. 20 Dravosburg crash that killed 15-year-old Samantha Kalkbrenner, a student at nearby Serra Catholic High School. Police allege he hit speeds above 100 mph in the seconds before he hit the van.

Mr. Soliday’s attorney, Casey White, argued that his client’s alleged recklessness did not amount to malice — one of the key tenets of the legal definitions of murder in Pennsylvania.

In terms of third-degree murder, malice means that a defendant was acting so recklessly or with such negligence that they should have reasonably known their actions could result in death or serious injury.

Advertise with us

“When does reckless behavior become malice?” Mr. White asked.

But Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer said that, taking the prosecution’s evidence against Mr. Soliday in the light most favorable to the prosecutors, Mr. Soliday was essentially playing Russian roulette: His actions set the stage for a serious crash and it was all but certain that circumstances would eventually align.

Police allege Mr. Soliday and another man, Andrew Voigt, were racing as they sped across the Mansfield Bridge and Richland Avenue that morning. Mr. Soliday’s white Volkswagen GTI slammed into the side of a transport van carrying Serra Catholic students, flipping the van and ultimately killing the teenager.

Charges against the men, who both work at Bettis Atomic Power Laboratory in West Mifflin but maintain they don’t know each other, were filed in December. Witnesses said Mr. Voigt appeared to be trying to keep up with Mr. Soliday in the minutes before the crash.

When Mr. Soliday struck the van, Mr. Voigt kept driving.

Advertise with us

Mr. Voigt faces less serious charges than Mr. Soliday, including reckless endangerment, illegal racing and failing to stop and render aid. He is out on $150,000 bond. Mr. Soliday has twice been denied bail, and he has remained in the Allegheny County Jail since his arrest.

Mr. White and Deputy District Attorney Brian Catanzarite noted that in order for a driver to meet the third-degree murder threshold, the driver must have had enough time to appreciate that the recklessness of their behavior could cause death or serious injury — and then disregard it.

Mr. White focused his argument on the only time frame for which there is concrete data on Mr. Soliday’s speed.

The data recorder from the Volkswagen captured speed information in the five seconds leading up to the crash, according to information presented at the preliminary hearing. Mr. Soliday’s top speed during that time, according to investigators, was 107 mph, and he didn’t hit the brakes until a half-second before he slammed into the van.

But Mr. Catanzarite said it wasn’t just those five seconds leading up to the crash — the five seconds for which prosecutors have speed data — in which Mr. Soliday was acting with recklessness. Evidence from the preliminary hearing earlier this year indicated that Mr. Soliday was weaving between lanes, speeding around other vehicles, and he honked his horn at least once.

Advertise with us

Witnesses testified that he was driving “ridiculously fast.”

On top of that, Mr. Catanzarite said, Mr. Soliday knew the area. He knew that it was relatively residential, and he knew there would be traffic on the roads, especially at that hour of the morning. He knew that, Mr. Catanzarite said, because he drove that route to work at that time every day.

What it came down to, he said, was that Mr. Soliday had plenty of time as he was passing other vehicles and weaving through traffic to realize he was acting with recklessness — such recklessness that it would have been clear to him there was a high likelihood his actions could cause death or life-threatening injuries.

Mr. White had argued that in order for Mr. Soliday to “know” his recklessness could result in a death, he would have had to set out that morning with a death wish.

But the judge said there is more nuance to the idea of “knowing” in terms of these charges. He said it’s not that the defendant had to know he would kill someone, but rather he reflect on his actions, deduce the recklessness of them and then disregard how reckless the actions were.

“I could drive down the street and choose to take a gun … and shoot into a house,” Judge Beemer said, noting that while he couldn’t know for certain that he could kill someone, “the act of firing the gun makes it very likely death or serious injury could result.”