The slow-motion tragedy played out in a few images Friday in Pittsburgh Municipal Court.
In one, school van driver Richard Maleski, traveling on Third Street in Dravosburg, looks left down Richland Avenue and begins to pull into the intersection. In the next image, he braces for impact.
The four photos after that turn blurry as the van is spun in the air and tips onto its side. The four teenagers onboard are tossed like ragdolls. Three were throw out the windows, including 15-year-old Samantha Lee Kalkbrenner, a student at Serra Catholic High School who lived in Dravosburg.
In reality, the horror played out in less than a minute.
The images, pulled from the van’s dashboard camera, showed the view inside and outside the van in the moments before, during and after William Soliday’s Volkswagen Jetta smashed into its side Sept. 20. The crash killed Samantha and left the other students and Mr. Maleski seriously injured.
“Where are the girls?” Mr. Maleski can be heard asking as he tries to free himself from the wreckage.
Read More
The camera also captured something else: Andrew Voigt’s black Jeep, the only vehicle in view during the seconds immediately after the crash. Footage shows the Jeep speeding past and out of view.
In an emotional four-hour preliminary hearing in front of District Judge Katherine Lovelace, Deputy District Attorney Brian Catanzarite argued that both men should be tried for their alleged roles in the fiery crash.
Dozens of Samantha’s friends and family members filled the courtroom. They shuddered at the impact shown in the videos. Adults and teenagers alike sobbed throughout the hearing.
Judge Lovelace ultimately held all charges against Mr. Soliday, of North Huntingdon, for trial, including homicide, aggravated assault, reckless endangerment and many more, including racing. He sobbed behind the courtroom partition before he was led back to the Allegheny County Jail, where he has been held without bail because of the homicide charge.
Authorities believe the men were racing as they sped through McKeesport, across the Mansfield Bridge and onto Richland Avenue shortly before 7:30 a.m. Sept. 20.
Data from the Jetta’s electronic data recorder showed the vehicle was traveling more than 105 mph in the seconds before the crash. Allegheny County Police Detective Alexander Durrani testified the data showed the brakes weren’t applied until a half-second before impact. The Jetta was still moving about 90 mph as it crashed into the van.
Casey White, defense attorney for Mr. Soliday, argued against the homicide charge. He said that would require his client to have had intent and malice.
“He applied the brakes. He tried to stop the accident,” Mr. White said. “This was an unfortunate, horrible, tragic accident.”
Mr. Voigt, of Penn Hills, was represented by attorneys David Shrager and Kevin Chernosky. Mr. Chernosky said his client wasn’t involved in a race let alone the crash.
Judge Lovelace agreed, in part.
She dismissed the most serious charge against Mr. Voigt — accidents involving death or injury. It was the only felony he faced. She also dismissed a charge of failing to stop and render aid at a crash scene.
He’s remained free on bond since his initial arrest in December, and still faces counts of reckless endangerment, racing and other moving violations.
“I think a lot of times people confuse correlation with causation,” Mr. Shrager said after the hearing. “It’s a common logic error. Because two things happened at the same time doesn’t mean one caused the other.”
Attorneys for both men vehemently denied their clients were racing.
“There is not a scintilla of evidence to show those two ever had an agreement,” Mr. Shrager said, arguing that a race requires an agreement. “If I walked out this door and you started chasing after me or something, that doesn’t mean it’s a race.”
Mr. White, too, said there was no race; rather, he believes Mr. Voigt could have been chasing his client.
“The evidence suggests that a majority of the time [Mr. Voigt] was behind Mr. Soliday,” he said. “If you’re going to make any inferences about what exactly took place … you can clearly see, in theory, my client could have been being chased by Mr. Voigt. For what reason, we don’t know, but there’s no evidence to suggest they were racing.”
‘I saw what I saw’
Michael Sisko was driving his pickup truck toward the bridge that morning too. He said he saw the Jetta pass him, followed by the Jeep, the latter moving so fast that its back tires wobbled. The Jetta was barely ahead of the Jeep, he said. As quickly as they went around him, he said, they were gone.
“It was like they were racing,” Mr. Sisko testified.
They disappeared around the bend of the Mansfield Bridge. A short time later — Mr. Sisko admitted that he was also speeding but not so much that he could keep pace with the Jetta and Jeep — he came upon the crash.
His voice cracked and he had to pause as he described seeing “a kid staggering across the road covered in blood.”
One student was trapped beneath the van. It was Samantha, but Mr. Sisko said he didn’t know at the time whether it was a boy or a girl. He said he tried to help rock the van to get it off her.
Mr. White asked whether Mr. Sisko ever saw the drivers signal each other or make any gestures. He said he didn’t. Did he think they were in a competition?
“How would I know that?” Mr. Sisko said. “Do I think they were in a racing competition? One hundred percent.”
An argument of semantics ensued after Mr. Sisko used the term “chasing” to describe the Jeep driver’s actions.
“I was there, I saw what I saw — it was a race,” he said. “I’m not going to go back and forth with you. It was a race.”
Two other witnesses also described seeing the Jetta speed past them on the bridge, and both came upon the crash scene moments later.
Stacey Alderman said she was at the traffic light at the intersection of Fifth Avenue and Rebecca Street in McKeesport when she heard a horn behind her. She assumed it was because the vehicle at the front of the line took a few seconds to pull forward after the light turned green.
“It was a loud, angry, impatient horn blare,” she said. “I had just taken my foot off the brake when the white Volkswagen sped around me.”
Moments later she found herself stabilizing a teenage girl’s neck while ambulances arrived.
Greg McCauley turned from Rebecca Street onto Fifth Avenue about the time Ms. Alderman was at the traffic light. He said he saw both the Jeep and the Jetta. One almost hit him as they drove around a bend.
He said it seemed as though “the Jeep was chasing down the Jetta.” Mr. White objected to the categorization.
Mr. Catanzarite, the deputy district attorney, also played video footage captured by another car that was driving down Richland Avenue when the crash occurred. It showed the van suddenly lurch into the air, spinning partway around and then tipping over. Students can be seen being flung from the van.
Detectives used license plate readers to identify Mr. Voigt as the owner of the Jeep. They said evidence showed he turned off of Richland Avenue a short distance away the crash scene, went home, scraped a decal off of the back window of the Jeep, then took a different car to work at Bettis Labs in West Mifflin.
In an interview with county police Detective Blake Maloney, Mr. Voigt said he saw the crash and did pull over a short distance away. Detective Maloney said the man told him he “lost control of his bowels” and vomited on himself. He didn’t call 911, he said, because he figured enough other people already had. He went home, cleaned up, and took the decal off his Jeep because “it was a bad look.”
The decal, detectives said, showed a tank running over stick figures with a message along the lines of “no one cares about your stick figure family.”
Both men will be formally arraigned Feb. 26.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.