The minutes ticked by slowly last Sunday afternoon as the Rev. Glenn Germany and one of the deacons at his North Braddock church kept a would-be shooter pinned to the ground as they waited for police to arrive.
Five minutes, then 10, then 15.
At 1:31 p.m., more than 20 minutes after Bernard Junior Polite allegedly pointed a semi-automatic handgun at the pastor and pulled the trigger, Pennsylvania State Police troopers arrived at the Jesus’ Dwelling Place Church on Lobinger Street.
Within a minute of the failed shooting — during which it’s not clear why the gun didn’t fire — Deacon Clarence McCallister had tackled Mr. Polite to the ground in front of the pulpit. Rev. Germany wrestled the gun out of the man’s grasp.
Then, they waited.
“It was quite a long time,” Rev. Germany said. “It could have been worse, by far.”
Read More
The church, a dark brick building with a squared steeple, is less than a mile from the Eastern Regional Mon Valley Police Department, the newly formed police agency that covers that area.
The police department is a merger of several small neighboring municipal agencies, and its formation is perhaps a case study in the staffing challenges facing modern policing: The pool of police applicants has shrunk nationwide while the cost of competitive pay to reel in those applicants has only gone up.
The merger of North Braddock, Rankin and East Pittsburgh departments to form the ERMVPD is still in its infancy. The department and its six full-time officers began patrols April 1, and a ceremonial swearing-in took place April 30.
On Sunday, none of those six officers was on duty.
Response to the 911 call that reported the attack at Rev. Germany’s church ultimately fell to state police, who dispatched an officer about 1:11 p.m., according to Trooper Kalee Barnhart, the public information officer for PSP’s Troop B.
The troopers assigned to the call were dispatched from barracks in Coraopolis, about 22 miles from the church at the corner of Lobinger and Fourth streets.
“Anything could have happened,” said William Helton, who was operating the church’s sound system when Mr. Polite pulled the handgun on the pastor, a shocking sight caught on the livestream of the sermon. “Somebody could have got killed … it took too long.”
The shortage of law enforcement officers is not new, nor is it unique to small departments. In Pittsburgh, a full complement of police officers is 900. The number currently patrolling the city has dropped well into the 700s.
Across the country, the number of new officers being hired began falling in 2020 while resignations and retirements rose. The result was a staffing crisis that might only now be seeing the beginnings of leveling off, said Chuck Wexler, executive director of the Police Executive Research Forum.
The independent research organization has in recent years begun to survey agencies of all sizes across the country, comparing the number of officers they employed at the time to where they were the year prior. For years, the same scene played out across the board: lower overall staffing levels year after year beginning in 2020.
The latest survey results, which were published late last month and took stock of the profession in 2023, offered a glimmer of hope, Mr. Wexler said.
The survey of 214 law enforcement agencies from the U.S. and Canada showed that, overall, staffing levels are slowly starting to inch back toward what they were before the COVID-19 pandemic and before the civil unrest and police reform reckoning following the murder of George Floyd in May 2020.
The total number of sworn officers at the departments surveyed grew for the first time since January 2020. Small and medium departments — those with 1 to 49 employees and 50 to 249, respectively — saw the biggest increases, reaching staffing levels above where they’d been in 2020.
“There are some hopeful signs for small- and medium-sized departments,” he said. “Larger departments are still facing more challenges.”
While the survey responses showed a bump in staffing levels at large departments of 250 people or more, staffing levels still remained far below what they were in 2020.
Overall resignations dropped, but they still increased at small departments. The drop at medium and large departments was enough to outweigh the increase at small departments
Meanwhile, retirements dropped at departments regardless of size.
‘We are always covered’
Mr. Polite, 26, was ultimately arrested by state troopers without any further incident. He was charged with attempted homicide and, two days later, homicide, after his cousin was found dead in the home they shared in North Braddock.
Mr. Polite had told investigators after his initial arrest that “God told me to do it.” He said he’d planned to shoot Rev. Germany and wait to be arrested “so he could go to jail and clear his mind,” police wrote in the complaint. He’d been living with his cousin, Derek Polite, at a home on Stokes Avenue.
Family members learned of the incident from the media that same night and, fearing for Derek Polite’s wellbeing, checked on him at the Stokes Avenue home. Family found Derek Polite dead on the home’s staircase from a single gunshot wound. Investigators said the bullet that killed Derek Polite matched those recovered from the gun Mr. Polite tried to fire at Rev. Germany.
The incident inside Jesus’ Dwelling Place ended likely as well as it could considering the gunman attempted to fire from point-blank range. The pastor called it divine intervention.
“I forgave him the minute he did what he did, believe it or not, because the minute that we had the upper hand, we decided that no harm would be done to him. We’re going to protect him more than anything,” Rev. Germany said. “We just calmed him and held him until the police came.”
Leaders chalked the lack of officers up to growing pains within the new department.
Derrick Turner, chief of the new regional department, said he is still working to hire six more officers but is facing the same staffing shortages plaguing departments across the country.
“Despite the challenges faced nationwide with regard to police recruiting we remain committed to attracting and retaining those police candidates with a guardian mindset, as our communities deserve nothing less,” he said in a statement.
Operations within the new department will only get better, North Braddock Mayor Cletus Lee told the Post-Gazette.
“Everything is going to be improved, there’s no question about it,” he said, noting he has “all the confidence in the world” in Chief Turner.
“I know he’s going to make the surrounding communities a very safe and viable place for people to come move [to] and live,” he said.
But former North Braddock chief Isaac Daniele said any delay — be it in response or working out the kinks in the new department’s operations — puts the community at risk.
“I just don’t understand how they can’t make it work,” he said, indicating he’d been against the merger and regionalization from the start. “It’s obvious [the new department] is having a hard time getting off the ground.”
Mr. Daniele resigned last year when borough council declined to renew his contract ahead of the merger, which had been in the works for years. By the time the borough approved the police consolidation plan in 2023, the department was down to less than a half-dozen officers plus an acting chief who stepped in after Mr. Daniele resigned, according to Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV.
He called it “extremely dangerous” to have no local officers on duty at any given time, particularly in what he called a violent community.
District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr., too, voiced his concerns but said he’d reserve judgment until he and others could deconstruct the incident: How it happened, why it happened, how people responded and when they responded. But if the response time really was 20 minutes, he said — and data from PSP indicates that it is — that’s far too long.
“I’m not going to criticize any police agency — at least not yet,” he said. “But to ask the state police to draw people from the Pittsburgh barracks or Charleroi barracks is absurd. It’s not good planning.”
Merging departments, which is how the ERMVP was formed, is one way that smaller police agencies can mitigate their staffing woes, Mr. Wexler said.
“The reality is American policing is different form policing in a lot of countries,” he said. “We have over 17,000 different police agencies, and 80% of them are less than 50 officers.”
The idea never really took off, he said, even in the mid- to late-2000s when budget crises prompted layoffs at many departments.
“You would think that with these kinds of staffing challenges that regionalization or consolidation would be very attractive,” he said, “and yet it never has been.”
The discussions among North Braddock and surrounding municipalities began in earnest in late 2018 when East Pittsburgh dissolved its police department, a move that came about six months after one of its officers shot and killed an unarmed teenage boy.
The talks initially included the three municipalities that make up the ERMVP plus Braddock and Whitaker. Those plans fell through in 2020, but East Pittsburgh, Rankin and North Braddock began hammering out the details of a regional police charter in 2022. Each municipality approved the charter last summer.
The growing pains and lack of officers is not limited to new or regionalized departments.
In Verona, the borough’s police department consists of two full-time officers and three part-time officers. That’s not enough manpower to be considered fully staffed, borough manager Stefanie Woolford told Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV.
Like North Braddock and its neighboring communities, Verona relies on state police when no local officers are on duty. That’s what happened on April 14 when a home invasion was reported on Maple Street and, later, an assault was reported near Cribbs Field.
Both are within blocks of the police department on East Railroad Avenue, but Ms. Woolford told the TV station no local police were on duty that day.
“The state police were on that day,” she said.
And like North Braddock, state troopers were dispatched to the Verona incidents from the Troop B barracks in Coraopolis.
“We are always covered. It may not be the way we would like to be covered, but we are covered,” Ms. Woolford told KDKA. “There are cops 24 hours a day, seven days a week.”
Attracting officers to the borough of 2,800 isn’t easy, she said.
"Verona is a very small community with a very small tax base. So, we probably don't pay as well as the bigger departments,” Ms. Woolford said, noting that officials are working to increase the benefits of working for a small department to “make Verona more appetizing.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.