Superior Court judges appeared skeptical Tuesday during brief arguments in a case in which an Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas judge has refused to seat a death penalty jury, citing Gov. Josh Shapiro’s de facto moratorium on capital punishment.

The District Attorney’s Office believes the judge in the case, Judge Anthony Mariani, abused his discretion in ruling last year that he would not seat a death penalty jury to hear the case against Deangelo Zieglar. The DA’s office appealed that order to the state Superior Court, where it’s been pending since last year.

Zieglar is facing homicide charges in connection with the 2022 slaying of his ex-partner, Rachel Dowden, outside her Bellevue workplace. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty.

Judge Mariani cited the governor’s pledge to not sign any death warrants, saying it would be “patently unreasonable and fundamentally unfair” to put jurors through the process necessary to decide a death penalty case “when the outcome has already been determined.”

Advertise with us

Public defender Brandon Ging told the judges that the case before them is unprecedented.

“This isn’t unprecedented,” Judge Jill Beck interjected. “We’ve had a moratorium for the past eight years, and we’ve had death penalty cases before. Why is this different?”

Mr. Ging continued: “The law does say that … the commonwealth does have full discretion whether or not to seek the death penalty, but the judge also has an obligation to make sure that jury — whether it’s the guilt phase or the sentencing phase — will be fair and impartial.”

Judge Mariani, he said, looked at the social landscape and “arrived at the reasonable conclusion” that that was not possible.

President Judge Anne E. Lazarus noted that criminal cases can spend years winding through appeals courts, and by the time Zieglar’s is settled, Gov. Shaprio may not be in office.

Advertise with us

“The fact that Gov. Shapiro refuses to sign a death warrant doesn’t matter,” she said. “Even though Gov. Shapiro’s predecessor did the same thing, it’s still temporary because the legislature hasn’t ruled on this.”

She also questioned why a simple curative instruction could be given to the jury, for example, “We understand that the governor has imposed a moratorium but we are legally bound to ask you if you could impose it if it was available.”

President Judge Emeritus Jack Panella pointed to Bob Casey Sr.’s tenure as governor from 1987 to 1995, noting that he did not sign any death warrants during his terms. His successor, Tom Ridge, though, “couldn’t sign them fast enough.” The judge asked if Gov. Shapiro’s refusal would preclude future governors from doing the opposite.

“Not unless the legislature changes the law,” prosecutor Amy Constantine said.

Judge Mariani based his arguments in part on a 1986 death penalty case in which the defendant was twice ordered to receive a new sentencing hearing. The state Supreme Court ruled in the second instances that the judge in the case had erred when he gave these instructions to the jury:

Advertise with us

“Somewhere down the line, if you do impose the death penalty, the case will be reviewed thoroughly. And after thorough review the death penalty may be carried out.”

The state Supreme Court ruled that the curative instructions given by the judge after those remarks was not enough, and the case was remanded for a new penalty hearing.

Attorneys for the commonwealth have relied heavily on a similar case in Oregon. That state also has a moratorium on the death penalty, and in 2019 David Taylor was convicted of murder and sentenced to death. He appealed on several grounds, including raising the question of whether the state’s moratorium affected the jury’s ability to truly consider the death penalty. The conviction and sentence in that case were upheld.

But, Mr. Ging argued, there’s more to it than that: A year later, Oregon’s governor commuted all death penalty sentences in the state to life sentences. He said Gov. Shapiro could do the same.

“I think it would be somewhat naïve at this point in them, given the landscape we’re dealing with, for any jury to assume that their death sentence would be carried out,” he said. “I actually think the opposite is true.”

There is no timetable for the judges’ ruling.