Attorneys for the man accused of killing a McKeesport police officer have asked a judge to bar a jury from considering the death penalty, citing the governor’s pledge not to sign any execution warrants and another Allegheny County case in which the judge refused to seat a death-qualified jury.
Johnathan Morris, 32, is charged with homicide, murder of a law enforcement officer, and a half-dozen other charges in connection with the Feb. 6, 2023 shooting that killed Officer Sean Sluganski and wounded his partner, Officer Chuck Thomas.
The District Attorney’s office is seeking the death penalty against Mr. Morris.
In a motion filed late last week, defense attorneys Carmen Robinson and Elbert Gray argued that Gov. Josh Shapiro’s promise to continue a moratorium on executions in the state would taint any verdict in a death penalty case. Jurors, attorneys wrote, have already been told by the governor that the penalty would be unenforced.
“A capital sentencing jury must recognize the gravity of its task and must proceed with the appropriate awareness of its responsibility,” defense attorneys wrote. “Knowing that the governor will override any death sentence imposed prevents a competent and legitimate decision under the Eighth Amendment as well as the Pennsylvania Constitution.”
Mr. Morris’ attorneys said there is no adequate instruction the judge could give that would protect their client’s rights because “any prospective juror must take the governor at his word.”
Read More
The District Attorney’s office, however, said that claim is inaccurate, asserting the judge could easily tell the jury that the governor’s moratorium on executions is temporary and “given the current state of the law, the jury should assume that any death sentences will eventually be carried out.”
Deputy District Attorney Brian Catanzarite wrote that the comparison between Gov. Shapiro’s comments on executions and an Eighth Amendment violation doesn’t hold up.
Court of Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer, who is presiding over Mr. Morris’ case, has not ruled on the motion.
The case runs parallel to that of another Allegheny County defendant, Deangelo Zieglar, whose case is currently working its way through the state Superior Court.
Zieglar, 27, was charged with homicide in January 2022, accused of gunning down his ex-girlfriend at a bus stop outside her Bellevue workplace.
Rachel Dowden had previously gotten a protection from abuse order against Zieglar, and she’d bought a handgun for protection. Police allege Zieglar stole that gun from Dowden’s South Side home in early January and used that same gun to kill her two weeks later. The District Attorney’s office announced its intent to seek the death penalty against Zieglar in April 2022.
Last year, Common Pleas Judge Anthony M. Mariani, the judge presiding over Zieglar’s case, announced he would not allow a jury in the case to be death penalty qualified. In cases in which the death penalty is a sentencing option, jurors must be “death qualified” — that is, jurors must attest that they could at least consider a death sentence if they believe it is warranted.
Judge Mariani pointed to Gov. Shapiro’s February 2023 pledge to sign a reprieve any time an execution warrant came across his desk.
Prosecutors appealed the judge’s ruling to the Superior Court, asking the court to rule on whether Judge Mariani abused his discretion or whether his refusal to permit a death-qualified jury amounts to a violation of the constitutional concept of separation of powers.
The judge wrote that his opinion was not based on “any particular view” regarding the death penalty, nor was it meant to offer a moral commentary on capital punishment.
“Requiring citizens to undergo the intensive and intrusive process of death qualification and sentencing deliberations, when the outcome has already been determined, is patently unreasonable and fundamentally unfair,” the judge wrote.
He continued: “Instructing jurors to ignore the public pronouncement of the highest-ranking executive officer in the Commonwealth, who has the ultimate authority to carry out the death penalty, is unrealistic, if not outright disingenuous.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.