As the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police moved quickly and very publicly last week to reduce the number of officers on duty during certain overnight hours, the questions started. Council members, union officials, residents and businesses wondered what drove the decision and what it will mean for city safety and for the police force.
Chief Larry Scirotto points directly to the numbers.
Significantly fewer major 911 calls — referred to as “priority calls” by the bureau — come during the 3 a.m. to 7 a.m. timeframe, which is when the number of officers on duty in Pittsburgh has been reduced, data provided to the Post-Gazette shows.
Those numbers drove Chief Scirotto to reconsider how his department’s resources are allocated. Whether the decision is successful for the department and its officers, as well as the city and its residents, remains to be determined.
The difference in overnight staffing, the chief said, is really rather negligible.
“Average night, we’d have seven officers out on the road in each zone, so [we had] like 42 officers, generally,” Chief Scirotto told the Post-Gazette in an interview late last week.
Read More
“We cut 12. People think I cut 112.”
Concerns, however, remain. City councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith said the changes have the potential to become “a recipe ripe for disaster.”
“My community is not happy,” said Ms. Kail-Smith, whose district includes much of the West End. “They want to see how it’s going to play out.”
Bob Swartzwelder, president of the union representing Pittsburgh police, said the idea that only a dozen or so officers were cut from the overnight shift is disingenuous. He claimed that in terms of patrol officers, there are only 14 or 15 on duty now between 3 a.m. and 7 a.m.
“They’re running out of manpower very, very quickly, and they’re getting very taxed,” he said.
Mr. Swartzwelder said that in terms of overall officer numbers — including specialized units — there might be 25 to 30 working during that overnight timeframe. But, he said, those specialized units are tied up doing specialized work.
“I think the strategy at this point is a hope and a prayer that they can base everyone on data,” he said. “It may pan out to be correct. It may be disastrous.”
Ongoing shortage of officers
Pittsburgh police were dispatched to 50,811 so-called priority calls in 2023. Of those, 4,207 came between 3 a.m. and 7 a.m. The other 46,604 came during the other 20 hours.
The chief said about a third of patrol officers worked overnight when nearly two-thirds of the call volume comes between 2 p.m. and 2 a.m. “So we’re running one shift ragged, under-resourcing it, and over-resourcing another,” he said. “That was why I thought this exercise was so important.”
Last year, only about 8% of all priority calls were dispatched between 3 a.m. and 7 a.m., he said. Data the bureau provided bears that out.
Priority calls are considered incidents that are in progress, including shots fired, panic alarms, domestic violence, suicide threats, crashes with injuries or entrapment, robberies, and burglar alarms.
The 2023 numbers showing 50,811 priority calls don’t include lower-level calls — the kind that will likely be rerouted under the new structure.

Ms. Kail-Smith said her constituents are nervous about the changes, which include doing away with desk sergeants during that 3 a.m. to 7 a.m. timeframe. They are the officers who work the desk in the zone stations overnight. The chief said not many people have a need to come to one of the stations during those hours — maybe once or twice a year, he estimated.
“They understand there’s a police shortage,” Ms. Kail-Smith said of her communities, “but they want to know what we’re doing to increase those numbers.”
The bureau’s employment numbers sat at about 740 officers last week, down from the 835 who were working at the start of 2023 and even further down from a full complement of 900.
The ongoing shortfall led city officials to lower the number of officers budgeted for in the 2024 — 850 instead of the traditional 900. The city hasn’t seen a full complement in years as resignations and retirements continue to far outpace new recruits.
A class of about two dozen recruits will graduate this week. Just under 200 are eligible to retire this year.
Ms. Kail-Smith said she, too, is nervous and not just about the changes. Advertising the strategy alerts not just “the well-meaning citizens … but also criminals,” she said.
David DeFazio, a defense attorney and University of Pittsburgh professor, said, "Somebody who is committing a deliberate crime might make a choice of when to commit the crime now."
"But,” he added, “the passage of time and the incoming data can [help] make modifications if need be."

‘There will be exceptions’
Chief Scirotto, who was hired to lead the bureau last year, is also changing the types of calls his officers respond to. He said the telephone-reporting unit will handle calls like parking complaints, lost cell phones and wallets, and crimes that aren’t actively happening.
It’s the difference between coming home to find that somebody stole your lawnmower and somebody actively stealing your lawnmower from you, he said.
The former requires a report. The latter will see an officer dispatched.
As with anything, there will be exceptions, like the person whose driveway is blocked who needs to get to a medical appointment or the person who has only a 911-enabled cell phone but can’t otherwise make calls.
“What we’re trying not to do is create rules for exceptions, but there will be exceptions,” the chief said. “And when there are, we’ll meet the needs of our community.”
Elizabeth Pittinger, director of the city’s Citizen Police Review Board, told her board members last week that only time would tell if the changes are for the better.
“The problem with that is the police are not initiating the calls — those are people,” she said. “Those are people calling 911 and asking for some kind of help. So how that translates into an efficient and effective use of enforcement power in contrast to the caretaking toll that police have — that’s going to take a while to determine.”
Chief Scirotto contends that these changes will mean officers will actually be more engaged in their communities.
He gave what he said is a real-time example that he listened to play out over police radio. Four cars in Zone 2 were taken out of service for parking complaints Downtown, including one car from Lawrenceville and another from the Hill District.
It might take half an hour for a car from Lawrenceville to get Downtown, another 10 to 15 minutes to take care of the complaint, and then another 30 minutes to get back to Lawrenceville.
“You won’t be community engaged in a way that I expect — focusing on quality of life, being a community partner — if you’re running back and forth out of your sector to these calls,” he said.
Ms. Pittinger plans to keep a close eye on how the effort plays out.
“It was a creative way to deal with figuring out how you’re going to keep the city safe. And this is a way that it might work,” she said. “It might. We’ll see.”
Balance matters
The changes, launched last week, meant shifting officers from an eight-hour, five-day-a-week schedule to 10-hour days, four days a week. That’s not just to accommodate the change in staffing levels, but it also marks what Chief Scirotto said is a better focus on officer wellness.
He said officers will get three consecutive days off, and everyone will have at least one weekend day included in the three.
Feedback to that move has been a mixed bag, he said, but he downplayed the negative reactions. “The naysayers, they’re also oftentimes the guys that if you gave them a million dollars, they’d be mad they have to pay taxes,” he said.
He said he’s trying not to ask officers to do anything he wouldn’t have felt safe doing as an officer and detective.
Mr. Swartzwelder, president of the police union, doesn’t see it that way.
He sees the move as a disastrous one. He called the afternoon/night shift — 4 p.m. to 2:30 a.m. — horrendous.
“It’s just going to ruin lives,” Mr. Swartzwelder said. “It’s going to ruin family lives and ruin any type of interpersonal relationships officers might have. It’s not good, it’s not healthy.”
Four 10-hour shifts might work in other cities, he said, but not in one as large as Pittsburgh.
“You just have too much going on,” he said. “You need that rotating shift or you’re just going to burn officers out.”
Ms. Pittinger said she, too, has heard some officers voice their displeasure at the change.
“They’re grumbling because they’re tired already,” she said. “They’re worried about how they’re going to cover major events in the city. The 10 hours is grueling. They’re not so sure they really want that, but that’s what they have now.”
Karen Amendola, chief behavioral scientist for the National Policing Institute in Arlington, Va., said Pittsburgh’s move to four 10-hour days is one that not many departments have embraced. She said the change, to her, shows the chief “understands that internal wellness is just as important as how officers interact in the field.”
In 2011, Ms. Amendola looked at the effects that different shifts had on officers in two departments: Detroit and Arlington, Texas. The study looked at eight-hour shifts, 10-hour shifts, and 12-hour shifts. She said officers on 10-hour shifts ended up getting more sleep and working less overtime.
"The 10-hour shifts have proved to be a great alternative," she said.
Other studies, she said, have shown early morning shifts take a heavier toll on officers’ physical and mental well-being, so she applauded the reduction in overnight staffing.
"Sitting at a desk waiting for calls to come in is a waste of resources — it's not serving a community purpose to have them [in the zone stations]," she said.
Amid a nationwide staffing shortage of officers, Ms. Amendola believes changes like this can encourage people to pursue policing.
"Many young people are looking for ways to have a better work-life balance, have more choices, to honor their mental health," she said. "Balance does matter."
Staff writer Hallie Lauer contributed to this report.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.