The fire that would eventually take Michelle Pivirotto's life happened on the only Friday night in four years she spent without her fiance, Joseph Fazio.

Pivirotto told Mr. Fazio on Jan. 13 that she was tired from working late. So, instead of spending that chilly night at her house on Fall Run Road, he fell asleep at home.

He woke to a phone call at 9:45 p.m. from Pivirotto's daughter, Katarina DeRamo. She was her mother's emergency contact and was notified that the smoke alarms sounded in the Shaler house, where her brother David DeRamo also resided with his wife, Courtney Frederick, and their daughters, Anastasia and Danika.

Mr. Fazio jumped into his car and arrived in less than 20 minutes. The home was engulfed in flames, he remembers, and Pivirotto was already en route to UPMC Mercy Hospital with her granddaughter, 2-year-old Danika, who died in the ambulance from her injuries.

Advertise with us

The fire was deemed accidental by the Allegheny County Fire Marshal's Office. No further information on the cause was released.

Mr. Fazio would later learn that rather than escaping, Pivirotto used a fire extinguisher to subdue the flames in the house and try to find Danika. That she risked her life for her family comes as no surprise to Mr. Fazio.

"She'd give anyone the shirt off her back," he said.

For 35 days, Mr. Fazio spent every waking hour in the hospital's burn unit, where “the love of his life” fought to stay alive. He said his nickname for her had always been "my Bella" because of her beauty. Now, more than 54% of her body was covered in burns.

After weeks of painful surgeries and failed skin grafts, Pivirotto died Feb. 18.

Advertise with us

Mr. Fazio said he's spent the year wondering what would have happened if he came over that night, just like he always did.

"I've been beating myself up over it," he said. "Maybe I could have made a difference."

That January night was only one in a string of deadly fires last winter that left grief and destruction in its wake. 

A toddler was killed and numerous others, including several firefighters, were injured in a nighttime fire at this house — shown the next day in this picture taken Saturday, Jan. 14, 2023 — on the 700 block of Fall Run Road in Shaler. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

A few weeks prior, on Dec. 13, an early morning blaze tore through a home on Miller Way in Sewickley, killing two young children — 9-year-old Lyric Keys and her younger brother Wylde Lightner, 6.

The cause of the fire remains under investigation by the Allegheny County Fire Marshal.

Advertise with us

A day later, Rev. Hannah Loughman stood in front of dozens of firefighters, community members, and friends of the family and offered a prayer for the two children at the United Methodist Church in Sewickley, where the family are members.

As the anniversary of the incident passes, Rev. Loughman said the children have hardly left the minds of the Sewickley community. Notes and poems dedicated to Lyric and Wylde can be found at community gardens and plastered on walls and poles throughout town.

"It incorporates the two children beautifully," she said. 

The emotion of that violent day still lingers, too. The short street is only about 100 yards from end to end, and it's been retraumatizing for neighbors to see the site of the destruction daily.

Rev. Loughman said a few months ago, she was asked to visit a residential building next to where the house fire occurred and talk about Lyric and Wylde in a memorial service.

Advertise with us

"They were struggling with the house still standing and seeing the condition that it was in," she said. "They needed a memorial service and some space and time to continue to grieve that."

Recently, the house was demolished, which Rev. Loughman thinks it will help neighbors heal from that night, and give them a chance to turn away from the ghastly scene.

"But also, that reminds me of [their mother] Shelby," she said. "That's something she could never turn away from."

Just three days after the Sewickley blaze, two children and 19-year-old Dijon Hutchinson perished in an overnight fire in the 3400 block of McClure Avenue in Pittsburgh's Brighton Heights neighborhood. 

Firefighters respond to a fire on McClure Avenue in December 2022. (Pittsburgh Public Safety)

Two adults and eight more children were evacuated from the flames.

Advertise with us

The children who died were registering for classes, with one scheduled to start school that upcoming Monday. Authorities never released their identities.

The cause of that fire has not been released.

In Pennsylvania, 104 home fire fatalities have been recorded so far this year, according to the Federal Emergency Management Agency. 

The month of December typically sees a lot of home fires, with Christmas Eve and Christmas Day among the leading days of the year for those blazes, data from the National Fire Protection Association shows.

Susan McKelvey, a communications manager at the NFPA, said a combination of factors increases the risk of fires during winter months — heating, flammable decorations, and lighting.

Advertise with us

But what makes December the most dangerous, she said, is mainly the holiday parties and family gatherings.

"When you're doing a lot of entertaining, and there's a lot of distraction around, it's easy to lose sight of what's on the stove or the oven," Ms. McKelvey said. 

Cooking is the largest factor in home fires year-round.

"People need to pay a lot of attention when cooking, particularly if you have guests in your home," she said. 

She said Christmas trees are also cause for concern this time of year. NFPA data shows there are 150 home fires involving Christmas trees each year. 

Advertise with us

Fire fatalities are also higher in Christmas tree fires than in other types of fires, Ms. McKelvey said. 

"They're these large, combustible items you bring into your homes," she said. "A fresh tree that dried out is a severe fire within a short window."

Rev. Loughman said that after the Sewickley fire, there was a push for fire safety throughout the town.

"The fire departments in the area got into people's homes to make sure everybody had access to a fire alarm, a working smoke detector," she said.

"They would set them up and do it for free to prevent something like this [from happening again]."

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh Bureau of Fire Chief Darryl Jones said his team often responds to fires caused by alternative heating methods, like space heaters, in the winter.

When it comes to fire safety, his most significant words of advice are to follow manufacturers' instructions. People taking shortcuts in cooking, heating installations, and decorations — often lead to fires. 

"I'm a firm believer that all fires can be prevented," he said. 

Chief Jones said that while he doesn't typically see an uptick in fires this time of year, the fires his team does respond to during the holiday season are the most unforgettable ones.

"Someone losing their life on Christmas Day or losing everything they have on that particular day sticks with a firefighter," Chief Jones said.

Advertise with us

"You will remember that."

Mr. Fazio will remember the fire that took Danika and Pivirotto, "his Bella," away from him.

Biking the trails of Pittsburgh, attending antique car shows, and singing at concerts in the park, Mr. Fazio and his fiance "did everything together," and often took Danika with them. 

"It's just a nightmare," he said.

Laura Esposito: lesposito@post-gazette.com