Convicted and condemned Pittsburgh synagogue shooter Robert Bowers has appealed his conviction and death sentence and asked a judge for a new trial, alleging prosecutors improperly excluded potential jurors who were Black, Hispanic and Jewish.

The appeal, which seeks a judgement of acquittal and a new trial, also argues there was insufficient evidence to prove the shooter’s hatred of the victims was “because they were religious or secular or were engaged in religious practices.”

Bowers was found guilty in June of all 63 federal charges against him in connection with the Oct. 27, 2018, shooting at the Squirrel Hill synagogue. In July, the jury unanimously decided Bowers was eligible for the death penalty and, on Aug. 3, they unanimously decided he should receive it.

Eleven people were killed in the shooting: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Dan Stein, Melvin Wax, and Irving Younger. Two congregants and four police officers were wounded by gunfire.

Advertise with us

Half of the 39-page appeal focused on jurors that the U.S. Attorneys prosecuting the case struck, or dismissed, during the jury selection process called voir dire.

During the process, potential jurors are questioned extensively about their views on the death penalty, life in prison, and the case in general. They’d previously filled out questionnaires answering similar questions and offering thoughts on various scenarios related to the case the possible sentences.

In the first round of questioning, attorneys on either side can move to strike a juror for cause — that is, because they’ve shown they could not be unbiased. Jurors can also be excused if they indicate serving on the jury would be an undue hardship. The judge, in this case, U.S. District Judge Robert J. Colville, has the final say whether to accept the strikes for cause, particularly when one side is in favor and the other opposes.

After a pool of jurors is set, attorneys can then question them again with the goal of seating a jury of 18 — 12 jurors and six alternates.

Each side in the case has a limited number of what are called peremptory strikes. With these strikes, attorneys can move to exclude a juror for any unstated reason, though they cannot base it on race.

Advertise with us

As this was happening in the Bowers case in late May, defense attorneys made what’s known as a Batson challenge. Such a challenge is made if attorneys suspect lawyers on the other side have used a peremptory strike to improperly exclude a juror based on race.

In Bowers’ case, his attorneys challenged the prosecution’s dismissal of four Black jurors, one Hispanic juror, and one Jewish juror. That challenge ultimately went nowhere at the time. Defense attorneys had requested a historical record of each member of the prosecution team’s peremptory strikes over the last decade. The judge rejected that motion.

“The defense … sought sufficient time to review the massive jury selection record to demonstrate that the government’s stated reasons for the strikes was pretextual,” attorneys wrote in the appeal. “However, the court allowed the defense only the 90-minute lunch break.”

Using excerpts of transcripts from the voir dire proceedings, defense attorneys alleged that prosecutors questioned the four Black jurors and one Hispanic juror far more extensively than white jurors.

Defense attorneys pointed to that as evidence of “a disparate pattern that was likely intended to probe for a reason to strike the jurors of color.”

Advertise with us

Prosecutors asked white jurors who ultimately served on the jury an average of eight questions, which covered an average of four transcript pages, Bowers’ attorneys wrote.

One potential juror of color was asked 20 questions covering eight transcript of pages, attorneys said, and another’s questioning covered more than 20 pages.

“When questioning white jurors, the government remained focused on their capacity and willingness to vote for a death sentence, preferring closed-ended yes-or-no questions,” defense attorneys wrote. “When it questioned jurors of color, it probed other areas of their profiles, pressing them on whether there was something in those areas that would create a conflict with their serving on the jury.”

The appeal also claimed prosecutors failed to adequately prove the intent behind the hate crime charges against Bowers.

“The government was required to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that ‘it was [Bowers] conscious desire or purpose to obstruct’ each victim in the enjoyment of that victim’s free exercise of religious belief,” Bowers’ attorneys wrote. “Based on the evidence presented at trial during the guilt phase, no rational juror could have found this specific-intent element.”

Advertise with us

Bowers targeted the synagogue where the congregations Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light worshipped after connecting Dor Hadash with an immigrant and refugee resettlement organization called the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society, or HIAS.

The appeal seems to hinge somewhat on the semantics surrounding HIAS’ role in the shooting and what that means.

“Even if the evidence established that [Bowers] intended to deter the synagogue’s congregations or outside groups or individuals from support the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society or facilitating refugee resettlement generally,” attorneys wrote, “that would not support the convictions.”

There is no evidence that support of HIAS or refugee resettlement in general, Bowers’ attorneys wrote, “constituted the free exercise of religious beliefs.”

The appeal continued: “So too if [Bowers] attacked the victims because of a hatred of Jews, since there was insufficient evidence that any such hatred was directed at them because they were religious or secular or were engaged in religious practices.”