A North Versailles man allegedly shot and killed his younger brother during a fight in his Della Drive apartment, according to charges filed in the case.
Allegheny County Police initially said they would consult with the District Attorney’s office to determine whether Andrew Zevola should face charges in the Oct. 26 death of his brother, Sheldon Zevola. One count of homicide was filed a short time later.
Two witnesses who were in Andrew Zevola’s apartment at the time of the shooting said Sheldon Zevola arrived at the apartment that afternoon angry because his girlfriend had run over his foot in the parking lot, according to the criminal complaint.
A male witness said Sheldon Zevola left the apartment but soon returned, still “very upset,” and he began arguing with Andrew Zevola. The witness said he tried to get between them but was knocked to the ground. Andrew Zevola retrieved a gun at some point and fired at his brother, who was across the room at that point.
The male witness said the brothers started physically fighting again, according to the complaint. He said he heard two gunshots followed by Andrew Zevola saying, “I told you I was going to shoot you,” investigators wrote.
Andrew Zevola, who was ultimately charged in the shooting, said his brother came to the apartment and got into a fight with his girlfriend, according to the complaint. He tried to get Andrew Zevola’s cell phone from him, but he was on the phone with his girlfriend and refused. He said his brother then took the male witness’s cell phone and left the apartment.
A fight started via text message, he said, with Sheldon Zevola accusing him of “caring more about his girlfriend than his own brother,” according to the complaint. The text messages turned to insults, and Sheldon Zevola came back to the apartment and the brothers began fighting.
Andrew Zevola said he picked up his handgun at some point, and his brother lunged for the gun, investigators wrote. He said they fought over the gun, and Sheldon Zevola ended up on top of his brother, allegedly punching him in the face and reaching for the gun.
A shot went off but didn’t hit anyone, Andrew Zevola told police. The brothers continued to fight over the gun, with Andrew Zevola in control of the trigger and his brother with his hand on the slide, according to the complaint. Andrew Zevola ultimately fired one shot that struck his brother in the torso.
He said he pushed his wounded brother off of him and took the gun to the dining room, removing the magazine and live round as he did, according to the complaint. A female witness in the home called 911.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.