The director of a Castle Shannon childcare center allegedly spent more than $800,000 in company money on personal expenses over the course of a year, including funneling more than $400,000 through her own personal PayPal account, according to charges announced Tuesday by the Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office.

Sammi Jo Whittaker, 36, is also accused of forging more than 250 checks to herself for personal expenses using money stolen from the Creative Minds Learning Center where she’d worked for more than a decade.

The fraud and embezzlement allegedly happened over roughly the past two years, according to the criminal complaint filed against her.

Emilie Stock, the owner of the Mt. Lebanon Boulevard learning center, became suspicious of the center’s finances — which were handled exclusively by Ms. Whittaker — in March.

Advertise with us

From there, investigators unraveled hundreds of thousands of dollars’ worth of theft and fraud using the company’s PNC checking account and PNC credit card.

Police said Ms. Whittaker was hired as a teacher in 2012. She was promoted to director in 2016. From 2016 through 2020, police said, Ms. Stock remained at least somewhat active in the center’s finances. At the onset of the pandemic in 2020, Ms. Whittaker took over sole responsibility for handling the finances.

Ms. Stock told investigators that Ms. Whittaker continued to keep her abreast of the finances until sometime around 2021 when her transparency regarding the company’s spending began to wane.

After she discovered Ms. Whittaker hadn’t filed the center’s 2021 taxes, Ms. Stock began looking into the finances herself. She initially discovered about $200,000 worth of unaccounted for transactions on the company credit card — a card that was only supposed to be used as overdraft protection for the company bank account, according to the criminal complaint.

Confronted by Ms. Stock, Ms. Whittaker said the credit card could have inadvertently been linked to her own personal accounts, according to the complaint. She failed to produce the receipts Ms. Stock asked for and began avoiding the owner.

Advertise with us

Ms. Whittaker told investigators she handled all of the financial “stuff” for the learning center and “basically did everything” related to the finances, according to the complaint. She claimed she often paid out of pocket for supplies and used the company accounts to reimburse herself. She also said that sometimes she could not get paid for lack of company funds and “had to get paid in different ways.”

She was fired in late March 2023 after Ms. Stock discovered the wide-ranging discrepancies in the finances, according to the complaint. Since then, Ms. Whittaker has allegedly continued to forge Ms. Stock’s name on checks, including as recently as June 9 for a cash advance.

Other personal payments Ms. Whittaker allegedly used company money for included payments to a veterinary clinic, to Drusky Entertainment, Amazon, 7-Eleven, CoGos, and Dick’s Sporting Goods, according to the complaint.

All told, she allegedly used the company credit card to make 2,450 payments totaling $539,424. She allegedly used the bank account to make more than 300 payments — including some via forged check — worth nearly $275,000.

Ms. Whittaker faces more than a dozen charges ranging from theft and forgery to receiving stolen property and dealing in the proceeds of illegal activity. She was arrested Tuesday and released on $10,000 unsecured bond.

A preliminary hearing is scheduled for Oct. 17. Court records did not list an attorney for Ms. Whittaker as of late Tuesday afternoon.