A white supremacist who spewed threats and hate toward the Jewish community, witnesses and jurors throughout the Pittsburgh synagogue shooting trial will remain in federal prison while he awaits trial, a judge ruled Wednesday.

U.S. Magistrate Judge James Mazzone called Hardy Carroll Lloyd a threat to the community and a flight risk in his decision to hold the West Virginia man in prison.

Lloyd, 45, was taken into federal custody Aug. 9 after months of antisemitic and racist emails and social media and blog posts. The proliferation of hate coincided with the federal trial of synagogue shooter Robert Bowers, who was sentenced to death this month for the massacre of 11 Jewish worshippers in Pittsburgh in 2018.

The judge noted in his decision that the evidence that Lloyd remains a threat is “clear and convincing.”

Advertise with us

Indeed, many of Lloyd’s online screeds included direct calls for “lone wolves” to target and kill members of Pittsburgh’s Jewish community. Racist and antisemitic stickers that popped up across Pittsburgh from late April throughout the trial’s conclusion in August were attributed to Lloyd. Investigators said he either put them up himself or directed someone else to do so.

Jury selection in the case against Bowers began April 24, and testimony began May 30. Bowers was convicted of all 63 charges against him on June 16. A jury imposed the death penalty after a day of deliberations on Aug. 2.

In early June Lloyd posted photos of synagogue survivors and witnesses in the case to his website, which declares Lloyd the reverend of the Church of Ben Klassen. The hate group is named for the late Florida congressman and open white supremacist.

The judge referenced Lloyd’s long history of violating the terms of supervised release imposed in previous cases, saying that history of violations “indicates [Lloyd] does not follow supervision rules as required.” He also noted Lloyd “believes he has been kidnapped through these proceedings.”

Lloyd’s federal court saga in Pittsburgh began in 2009 when he was indicted on a charge of carrying firearms without a license. Those firearms, according to court records, included at least three pistols, two shotguns, two rifles and two revolvers.

Advertise with us

He ultimately pleaded guilty to the one-count indictment in 2010 and was sentenced that August to 30 months in federal prison followed by three years of supervised release.

In October 2015, the government asked that Lloyd’s supervised release be modified to dictate that he not have a computer or cell phone with internet access. The request was based on blog posts by Lloyd that, among other things, called for the murder of parents who circumcise their children.

The judge signed off on that modification.

In August 2016, a judge revoked Lloyd’s release after he was charged with harassment by Pittsburgh police. Court filings indicate Lloyd wrote a threatening blog post calling for the victim’s personal information because the victim was “a bigot promoting anti-white hate.”

Lloyd was ordered to spend 14 months in prison to be followed by 22 months of supervised release.

Advertise with us

He’d been living in West Virginia during his latest fixation on the Bowers trial. He’s charged with obstructing justice, witness tampering and transmitting threats through interstate and foreign commerce. A trial is scheduled for Oct. 31.

Similar cycles played out in 2017 and 2019: Lloyd was released, violated the terms of that release with bigoted and antisemitic internet posts, and sentenced to more time in federal prison and more supervised release. In 2019, he was sentenced to two years in federal prison. He was released in late 2020.