After a yearslong inquiry into Philadelphia-based property manager AION Management, the U.S. Department of Justice has filed a complaint alleging the company has violated the Fair Housing Act.
The DOJ is arguing that the company’s denial of assigned parking spaces for prospective residents — including at two apartment complexes located in Pittsburgh — constitutes discrimination on the basis of disability.
The agency filed suit on July 7 on behalf of the National Fair Housing Alliance, Housing Equality Center of Pennsylvania and Fair Housing Partnership of Greater Pittsburgh, who filed the initial complaint to the Department of Housing and Urban Development in 2021.
Seeking an injunction to prevent the company from further alleged discrimination — as well as monetary damages for the three groups acting as plaintiff — the DOJ claims AION’s practices were “willful and intentional, and in reckless disregard for the law,” according to the lawsuit.
“As we have this new type of housing provider enter the market, they’re either misunderstanding or have blatant disregard for the civil rights protections that advocates have fought and bled for in previous decades — ones that had been considered a standard and a given,” said Megan. Hammond, executive director of the Fair Housing Partnership of Greater Pittsburgh.
Ms. Hammond said she was contacted in fall of 2019 by a resident of the Alden South Hills, an AION-owned property in Baldwin Borough.
According to court documents, the resident — who uses a wheelchair due to a physical disability — told the Fair Housing Partnership that she was forced to move out of her building after her request for flooring that would accommodate her wheelchair was denied.
This initial complaint led the three organizations to launch their own investigation into AION’s reasonable accommodations process.
Over the course of 2020, “testers” toured seven AION-owned properties, including two in Allegheny County, and asked if management would allow tenants with a disability-based need for an assigned parking space to receive one.
In each of the test cases, AION refused to provide an assigned parking space, in many cases telling the testers that handicap spots are first come, first serve.
“It means the difference between the ability to access your house with some degree of ease and dignity, versus really having to jump through hoops every time you want to come and go,” said Joe Wardenski, a New York-based attorney working with the initial plaintiffs.
Following their investigation, the groups filed a formal complaint with the Department of Housing and Urban Development, which conducted their own probe before issuing federal discrimination charges against AION on Feb. 24.
Weeks later, AION elected to have the claims resolved in federal court rather than an administrative proceeding, at which point HUD authorized the DOJ to initiate its own civil action by July.
Founded in 2017, AION Management’s real estate portfolio includes six apartment complexes in the Pittsburgh area, along with properties in eastern Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, Maryland, Virginia, Indiana and Ohio. Representatives from AION did not respond to multiple requests for comment.
The case is being heard in federal district court in Delaware, where the company has an address, according to court records. Mr. Wardenski, the initial plaintiffs’ lawyer, said AION has until September to file an answer or motion to dismiss.
Michael Korsh: mkorsh@post-gazette.com, @michael_korsh





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.