“Rob is my nephew,” the witness explained on the stand Friday at the federal courthouse Downtown.

For years, Patricia Fine was “Aunt Tricia.” As Robert Bowers got older, though, she just became “Tricia” to him.

Ms. Fine is likely the last witness in a line of those called to testify as part of the defense in the sentence-selection phase of her nephew’s trial. Jurors have already convicted Bowers of all 63 federal charges against him in connection with the Oct. 27, 2018, shooting at a Squirrel Hill synagogue where three congregations worshipped: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light.

Bowers, 50, of Baldwin, was also already deemed eligible for the death penalty for his crimes. Jurors next week will begin deliberating whether he will receive life in prison or be sentenced to death. Closing arguments will likely begin Monday afternoon — a last pitch by prosecutors that the shooter should die for his crimes and a last pitch by defense attorneys for his life.

Advertise with us

Eleven people were killed in the shooting that Saturday morning: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, and Irving Younger.

Prosecutors for the government early last week presented more than two days of heartbreaking victim-impact testimony from survivors of the shooting and loved ones of the victims.

The defense team, led by San Diego-based attorney Judy Clarke, had so far relied on mental health experts to make its case — not just in the sentence-selection phase, but the eligibility phase as well.

That changed Friday when jurors heard their first testimony from Bowers’ family.

“He was more or less a loner, I would say,” said Clyde Munger, Ms. Fine’s husband and Bowers’ uncle.

Advertise with us

Mr. Munger testified from his wheelchair in front of the jury box after attempts to get the wheelchair into the witness box failed. Flustered, U.S. District Judge Robert J. Colville nearly forgot to swear in the witness. Jurors reminded him.

Mr. Munger has trouble hearing, so federal public defender Elisa Long had to speak loudly into the microphone. She occasionally spoke too loudly.

“No one’s had to tell me to be quieter,” said Ms. Long, who jurors often have to ask to speak up even with the microphone.

Mr. Munger said he’s known Bowers since his nephew was in his early 20s, some 25 years ago or more. The former long-haul trucker would park his rig on his aunt and uncle’s farm in McDonald when he was off for long stretches.

Bowers and his uncle would also go to the Golden Corral buffet together.

Advertise with us

“He liked that chocolate fountain,” Mr. Munger said. “I never went around the desserts. Too sweet. He loved that fountain.”

One of the last times they went, the fountain was gone.

“At the time, I didn’t realize it but looking back … he was very upset,” he said.

They never went back after that.

Mr. Munger said he’s gone to visit his nephew in the Butler County Prison, where Bowers has been held since shortly after the 2018 shooting.

Advertise with us

“He’s my nephew and I love him,” he said. “I wanted to see him.”

Bowers was closest with his aunt, though, Mr. Munger said.

“They were close,” he said holding his forefinger and middle finger tight together. “Peas in a pod.”

Ms. Fine said her mother, Bowers’ grandmother, was his closest relative growing up. “Would you have been a close second?” Ms. Clarke asked.

“You bet,” Ms. Fine said.

Advertise with us

Bowers’ aunt testified for about 40 minutes Friday before court recessed for the day. She will return to the stand Monday morning.

In her testimony, she talked about her sister, Bowers’ mother, Barbara Bolt. She said that Ms. Bolt was a sad, unhappy, secluded child growing up, and that never much changed.

“Everything was secretive,” she said. “It was like walking on eggshells and no matter how careful you were, you ended up in an omelet.”

From the moment her nephew was born in 1972 when she was 14, Ms. Fine said she was in love. She recalled the blue and white outfit he was dressed in when her sister brought the baby home a few days after he was born.

“He smelled like heaven,” she said. “I was smitten.”

Advertise with us

But he, too, proved to be a sad child. He and his mother cycled through apartments that Ms. Bolt would lose, and then they would come back home. Ms. Bolt divorced Randall Bowers, her child’s father, before her son was a year old. She moved briefly to Florida with a man she married within a few weeks of meeting.

Bowers never got happy or excited or even angry as a toddler, Ms. Fine said.

“He didn’t have joy,” she said.

That was a theme in Bowers’ childhood, forensic psychiatrist Dr. George Corvin had told the jury the day prior. He said over the course of 10 interviews with Bowers over the past several years, the defendant described a childhood in which he was essentially suicidal every day.

“He thought death was better than his situation,” he said.

Advertise with us

Dr. Corvin began his testimony Thursday afternoon, speaking extensively about his diagnosis of schizophrenia and the delusions he believes Bowers suffers from.

He returned to that theme Friday morning, describing how Bowers believed he was a soldier for God. Those delusions combined with what he read online and with current events around him all combined with his mental illness to lead to the shooting that killed 11 people nearly five years ago.

He said Bowers believes there is a literal war going on and there has been for thousands of years. It’s a war in which Satan has literally possessed all but 144,000 Jews and, through them, he wants to obliterate the white race and Christianity.

“It’s got nothing to do with whites, it’s got nothing to do with Blacks, and it’s got nothing to do with Jews,” Dr. Corvin said. “It’s Satan causing the end of Christianity so he can destroy the world.”

Dr. Corvin said the schizophrenia and the delusions it wrought made it impossible for Bowers to truly appreciate the wrongfulness of what he did. Bowers thinks he had to take lives to save lives, essentially.

Advertise with us

“He still envisions what he did as an unfortunate act of violence he did at the direction of God and that it will save lives,” Dr. Corvin told jurors Friday morning. “He believes he’s a tool for God.

“It sounds absurd,” he said. “Because it’s psychotic.”

U.S. Attorney Eric Olshan, in his nearly three-hour cross examination, tried to cast doubt on the doctor’s credibility because of issues with his report — a lack of citations and leaving out large portions of his notes from his nearly 39 hours with the defendant.

Specifically, he pointed to all of the notes Dr. Corvin had taken about the shooter’s thoughts and feelings about his crimes: Bowers was disappointed that his was still the deadliest U.S. attack on Judaism nearly five years later, and he wanted to go to trial so he could gauge whether his “mission” was a success.

Dr. Corvin said Bowers thinks prosecutors are doing a good job, and he’s happy with what they’ve been doing.

Advertise with us

“He’s happier with what they are doing than what you are doing,” Dr. Corvin told Ms. Clarke.

Ms. Fine will return to the stand Monday morning. She will likely be the last witness in the case, as prosecutors said they don’t currently intend to call any rebuttal witnesses. Jurors could begin deliberations as early as Monday afternoon.

Megan Guza: mguza@post-gazette.com