More than a month after Allegheny County’s Jail Oversight Board voted to create a new full-time liaison, it’s unclear if that vote is still valid.

Karen Duffola, a former drug court coordinator for the county, was voted in to fill the liaison position in May but hasn’t begun work. The jail board was set to ratify a previous vote confirming that decision during a June meeting — before attendees of the meeting started to sing, causing board chair Judge Elliot Howsie and other members to leave before the agenda item came up.

The development is the latest in a series of ongoing drama for the board, which is tasked with oversight of the county’s jail in Downtown Pittsburgh. Opponents have attended meetings and railed against members and jail administration in public comment. Since April 2020, more than a dozen inmates have died, either at the jail or a nearby hospital.

Ms. Duffola declined to comment. Judge Howsie also declined to comment.

Advertise with us

Two jail board members did not vote for Ms. Duffola to fill that position: County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam — the council’s representative on the board — and Ryan Herbinko, who has been sitting on the board as a designee of County Controller Corey O’Connor.

Ms. Hallam objected during the May meeting and said that the vote violated the state’s Sunshine Act, because a vote for the liaison position was not listed on the public agenda. Rachel Radke, a close observer of the meetings, has made that same argument in a recently filed lawsuit, which is in the county’s Court of Common Pleas. That suit lists Judge Howsie and board member Judge Beth Lazzara as defendants in their official capacities. It also lists the board itself as a defendant. Ms. Lazzara could not be reached for comment.

Ms. Radke could not be reached for comment. But Mr. Herbinko, who has sat in on recent meetings, said the fact that June’s meeting was cut short — before the vote to ratify the liaison vote — means the validity of the May vote to appoint Ms. Duffola as the liaison is likely uncertain. He referred all other questions about the matter to Judge Howsie.

“Things have been in limbo, we’re in a giant holding pattern,” Mr. Herbinko said.

Brad Korinski, former chief counsel to the County Controller’s office said he is planning on filing a separate lawsuit in mandamus — essentially asking the court to issue an order instructing the Jail Oversight Board to follow the state statute, which governs all jail oversight boards in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

Mr. Korinski has argued in recent meetings during public comment that because County Executive Rich Fitzgerald has sent a designee — Stephen Pilarski, senior deputy county manager — to attend meetings in his stead, the board is violating the state statute. Mr. Korinski acknowledged that Mr. O’Connor has sent a representative in his stead, too.

But he said the state legislature has written the law so that other members of the board — including the county council president — have the ability to send someone else, because it is explicitly written into the statute.

“The words of statutes have to be given meaning ... on its face, the county executive should be there,” Mr. Korinski said.

There are other concerns regarding the state statute, Mr. Korinski said, including that jail officials are not providing documents to the board, whether they be medical records or others, he said. Warden Orlando Harper has argued in meetings that those records are protected from public disclosure under HIPPA law and other restrictions.

But Mr. Korinski said he still has concerns about how the board is conducting its meetings, especially when considering the state statute — one he said that is likely easy for the average citizen to understand.

Advertise with us

“There is no other board in Allegheny County, and dare I say Pennsylvania, that just so thoroughly and completely disregards the law,” Mr. Korinski said.

What’s next for the board?

Whether or not Ms. Duffola begins work as the jail board liaison, the County Controller’s office has drafted a memorandum of understanding between the Jail Oversight Board and Allegheny County Bureau of Corrections, listing the position’s responsibilities.

The Post-Gazette obtained a copy of the agreement via an open records request. Running less than 20 pages, it lays out the duties of the liaison — a full-time position making up to $85,000 a year.

The idea for the role had been discussed by the board for years, and Mr. Korinski said he came up with the idea about four to five years ago when he was in the controller’s office. The interview process for candidates took multiple months before Ms. Duffola was selected in May.

Advertise with us

The liaison is tasked with interviewing people within the jail, collecting information, and submitting a report to the jail oversight board each month, at least five business days before their monthly meeting.

“If the board discusses issues raised by the liaison’s monthly reports during meetings, it shall provide the jail and warden’s office an adequate opportunity to respond in writing and/or verbally during monthly meetings,” the agreement reads.

“If the report is to be made public via board vote, all steps shall be taken by the board to redact information subject to privacy and applicable law (e.g., personal identifying information or information covered by attorney-client privilege and the attorney work product doctrine).”

The agreement also has a section about the handling of confidential information within the jail: “Notwithstanding access to jail information, records, and documents, the Jail shall not be required to disclose information subject to attorney-client privilege, the attorney work-product doctrine, or disclosures of which would otherwise be inconsistent with applicable state or federal law.”

It also states that, given a jail oversight board vote in October 2022, that the liaison position will be housed in the Allegheny County Sheriff’s Office. That office will give the liaison the administrative resources they need to complete their work, according to the agreement.

Advertise with us

It’s unclear how binding the agreement is, and what lays ahead for the board in the coming months. But skeptics of the body, including Mr. Korinski, said that meetings have not been productive, and that it isn't fulfilling its duties.

“What’s on the agenda is largely window dressing,” Mr. Korinski said.

Steve Bohnel: sbohnel@post-gazette.com