Monday marks the start  of the penalty phase for the convicted Pittsburgh synagogue shooter, a two-part process that will almost certainly come down to the jurors’ decision as to whether Robert Bowers receives life in prison or the death penalty.

U.S. District Judge Robert J. Colville gave jurors — 12 deliberating and five alternates — a week off after their delivery of the verdict on June 16.

They found Bowers, 50, guilty on all 63 federal charges levied against him in the Oct. 27, 2018 attack on a Squirrel Hill synagogue.

Three congregations worshipped there: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light. The massacre killed 11 congregants: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, Irving Younger

Advertise with us

For the penalty, or sentencing, phase, jurors first will weigh aggravating circumstances to determine whether Bowers is eligible for the death penalty.

Those aggravating circumstances “are pretty much of a fait accompli” — that is, they are a forgone conclusion, said Bruce Antkowiak, a former federal prosecutor and defense attorney who teaches at St. Vincent College in Latrobe. Those circumstances include the number of victims and the heinousness of the crime — “things that are essentially already proven by the facts of the case,” he said.

If and when jurors determine Bowers’ crimes make him eligible for the death penalty, they must then weigh those aggravating factors against any mitigating evidence offered by Bowers’ defense team. Law does not guide that weighing process; rather, it is up to the jurors.

People walk past the courthouse Downtown during jury deliberation on the Bowers case Thursday June 15, 2023. Lead defense attorney Judy Clarke gave the defense’s opening statements when the trial began May 30, but federal public defender Elisa A. Long offered the closing. This was likely a calculated tactic, Mr. Antkowiak said. “You want to create in the jury’s mind that complete separation,” he said. “You don’t want the jury that just rejected your argument to have to consider your next argument. “Judy Clarke will close for the penalty phase, there’s no question about that,” he predicted. Should jurors find Bowers is eligible to be considered for the death penalty, they will then hear victim-impact evidence from prosecutors and mitigating evidence from the defense. That mitigating evidence will like include recreating Bowers’ life. Mr. Antkowiak said he’s seen cases in which defense counsel will present high school records, grade school records, even circumstances a defendant’s mother faced during pregnancy. Defense attorneys over the past week have filed a flurry of motions, some seeking to limit what prosecutors can discuss during this second phase of the trial. A day after the verdict, defense attorneys filed a motion asking Judge Colville for an order “prohibiting the government from making certain improper penalty-phase arguments,” preemptively calling the motion “neither vague nor hypothetical.” This Dec. 2, 2018, file photo shows a menorah at a memorial outside the Tree of Life Synagogue, where Robert Bowers killed worshippers in an Oct. 27 shooting, as people prepare for a celebration service at sundown on the first night of Hanukkah in the Squirrel Hill neighborhood of Pittsburgh. The 110-page filing listed 27 topics or categories of arguments defense attorneys believe prosecutors should not be able to touch upon during the penalty phase. They range from “asking the jurors to send a message” and “adverting to the victims’ families’ desire for a death sentence” to “demonizing the defendant” and adverting to the victims’ family’s desire for a death sentence.” In prosecutors’ response, the U.S. Attorney’s office referred to the 27 categories as broad and generic, calling the entire motion premature and unnecessary. “It asks the court to provide an advisory opinion on issues which may not actually arise,” prosecutors wrote. “Certain broad categories the defendant identifies arguably encompass proper statements by counsel,” they continued, “and the defendant should not be permitted to preemptively script the United States’ arguments.” Attorneys for Bowers also asked the certain defense witnesses be allowed to testify via video feed as opposed to in person, citing “certain defense witnesses with significant health and mobility problems, and one with unavoidable professional obligations out of state.” Prosecutors, in turn, argued that Bowers had not offered any details justifying the need for videoconferencing. “He does not explain who the witnesses are, what the alleged medical conditions or professional obligations are, whether they are temporary or permanent, or how or why those medical conditions or professional obligations make the witness unavailable to appear at trial,” they wrote. Defense attorneys also asked the court to bar prosecutors from essentially re-presenting evidence used in the guilt phase of the trial. Using evidence already presented to the jury is needless repetition, the defense argued, and “serves little probative purpose and only serves to inflame the jury.” That motion was filed Tuesday. Judge Colville had set a deadline for such motions for June 17. He dismissed the motion, calling it untimely, vague, and overbroad. He did, however, note that he expects prosecutors “will not needlessly present cumulative evidence, particularly graphic or emotionally impactful evidence.” He told defense attorneys they could object in the moment if they believed such evidence was being offered. Many other motions filed over the past week have been under seal, as many of the nearly 1,400 filings have been since 2018. (AP Photo / Gene J. Puskar, File)