Ten days after a jury found the gunman in the 2018 Pittsburgh synagogue shooting guilty of all 63 federal charges he faced, the penalty phase began Monday in a two-part process that will almost certainly come down to the jurors’ decision as to whether he receives life in prison or the death penalty.

What to know about the penalty phase

• It will occur in two parts: determining eligibility for the death penalty and deciding on a sentence. 
• Robert Bowers was found guilty of all 63 federal murder and hate crimes charges he faced. 
• Renowned defense attorney Judy Clarke is expected to be a central figure during this phase.
• The death penalty has loomed over the trial from the outset, with the government unwilling to accept a plea deal.
• The jury — a panel of 12 jurors and six alternates — took weeks to select. 

Eleven congregants from three congregations — Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light — were killed Oct. 27, 2018: Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax and Irving Younger.

Jurors will be tasked with weighing aggravating circumstances — including the number of victims and the heinousness of the crime — to determine whether Robert Bowers is eligible for the death penalty. 

If and when jurors determine Bowers’ crimes make him eligible for the death penalty, they must then weigh those aggravating factors against any mitigating evidence offered by Bowers’ defense team. 

Advertise with us

Jurors started hearing opening arguments in the penalty phase shortly after 9:15 a.m. Monday after a week off following Bowers’ conviction June 16. The prosecution rested before 3 p.m., and proceedings will resume at 10 a.m. Tuesday. 

—————

3:03 p.m. 

Victims’ children testify about their parents’ physical limitations

The children of Melvin Wax, Daniel Stein and Rose Mallinger all took the stand Monday afternoon to testify about the physical limitations of their aging relatives.

Wax was completely deaf in one ear and had only 50% hearing in his other, his daughter, Jodi Kart, testified.

Advertise with us

The pair had been very close since her mother, Sandra, died in 2016, sometimes talking on the phone multiple times a day. Wax drove up until his death, though Ms. Kart said he was “definitely reaching that age where he should not have been.”

He could hardly hear loud sounds, let alone soft sounds like whispering, she said. In previous testimony, Carol Black talked of hiding in a storage closet with Wax and Barry Werber. Wax thought the shooting was over and peeked out of the closet door moments before he was shot, Ms. Black testified.

Ms. Kart said that leading up to his death, Wax became forgetful and had bouts of confusion.

Joseph Stein took the stand next, to testify to similar characteristics of his father, Daniel, who was also hard of hearing.

“It was obvious to me that a hearing aid was in the near future,” Joseph Stein son said Monday.

Advertise with us

Stanley Mallinger, Rose Mallinger’s oldest son, said he had lived with her for over 10 years before her death to help take care of her.

Rose Mallinger, at 97, was the oldest victim in the shooting.

Her son said she had health issues, such as arthritis and glaucoma, and that he often had to help her open bottles and jars.

Rose Mallinger also had a number of falls in her home, prompting the family to get her a walker to use in the house. She had to hold onto someone to walk, he told jurors.

After Stanley Mallinger finished his testimony, the prosecution rested, and court broke for the day. Proceedings will resume at 10 a.m. Tuesday.

Advertise with us

— Hallie Lauer

—————

2:10 p.m. 

SWAT officer describes seeing bullet holes at ‘nearly head level’ in the walls 

Jeffrey Garris, a SWAT team officer with the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police, took the stand on Monday.

Mr. Garris had been sitting at home eating breakfast with his son when the active shooter call came across. He had to drive to the North Side to get the SWAT equipment truck and then take it to the synagogue in Squirrel Hill.

Advertise with us

His driving that morning was “lawless,” he testified.

Mr. Garris was with one of the SWAT groups that entered a classroom where Bowers had holed-up inside. He saw Officer Tim Matson get shot in the head and was part of the operation to remove Mr. Matson from the ongoing gunfire.

“I thought maybe that was going to be the last time I was going to see Tim,” Mr. Garris said. “But he defied all odds and is still with us today.”

After Mr. Matson had been removed from the scene, Mr. Garris and his SWAT team continued to trade gunfire with Bowers before he ultimately surrendered after being hit.

In the days after the shooting, Mr. Garris returned to the scene and saw multiple gunshot holes in the walls behind where he team had tried to enter the classroom. Some of them were “nearly head-level,” Mr. Garris testified.

Advertise with us

He said he was surprised he wasn’t shot.

“With the amount of gunfire that occurred in and around me, I am just amazed that I was not hit and I question how more of us were not,” Mr. Garris said.

— Hallie Lauer

—————

11:57 a.m.

Advertise with us

Prosecution witnesses speak about their family members’ vulnerability

Mr. Rivetti explained during his opening remarks that part of proving Bowers is eligible for the death penalty is showing that some victims were considered vulnerable, either because of their age or physical or mental well-being.

The government called three witnesses Monday morning to testify to the physical and mental conditions of their family members.

Diane Rosenthal — sister of David and Cecil Rosenthal — was called first.

Affectionately known by other Tree of Life congregants as “the boys,” Cecil and David both had Fragile X Syndrome, a genetic disease that causes a range of development problems. Cecil and David were both developmentally delayed, Ms. Rosenthal said.

“They functioned really as preschool or younger than preschool children. I’d say they functioned at a 3- or 4-year old level,” Ms. Rosenthal said. “They couldn’t read or write. They couldn’t tell time. They really couldn’t process difficult situations.”

Advertise with us

They lived in a group home together, and both men had jobs. However, neither liked loud noises and often had a difficult time in stressful situations.

Both of them had physical ailments also that limited their mobility, Ms. Rosenthal said.

Worshipping at the Tree of Life synagogue was incredibly important to them, she said.

“They felt comfortable there. That was their safe place, that’s where they wanted to be.”

Next on the stand was Michelle Weiss, the daughter of Bernice and Sylvan Simon.

Advertise with us

The Simons were both in their 80s. The prosecution spent much of the questioning asking Ms. Weiss about her parent’s mobility issues.

Sylvan Simon had a bad back and received treatment for macular degeneration in one of his eyes. Bernice Simon walked with a cane. Each had trouble with their hips. Though they drove until the day of their death, they each had handicap stickers.

Howard Fienberg, Joyce Fienberg’s son, also testified to the physical ailments his mother had, though she seldom complained about it, he said.

She had numbness in her arms and “trouble gripping with her hands,” Mr. Fienberg said.

Joyce Fienberg, who was 75 when she was killed, couldn’t sit comfortably for long periods of time and often had slow reactions.

Advertise with us

The defense declined to cross-examine the first three witnesses.

— Hallie Lauer

————— 

10:48 a.m. 

Defense focuses on gunman’s ‘distorted thinking’

Defense attorney Michael Burt started his opening remarks by also outlining the three factors that the jury has to consider when debating the eligibility of the death penalty.

Advertise with us

He said that the disputed factor in this phase will rest on if the level of intent is sufficient to warrant the death penalty.

“Intent may be different than what you found during the first phase of the case,” Mr. Burt said, referencing the guilty verdict Bowers received on all 63 federal charges.

It seems that the majority of the evidence that will be presented by the defense will focus on Bowers’ mental health.

“Hopefully what we’re going to present at this phase in the case is going to shine a greater light on how his distorted thinking came about,” Mr. Burt said.

Mr. Burt said that the jurors will hear from a number of “highly qualified mental health professionals” who examined Bowers.

Advertise with us

Their examinations have revealed that the “structure and function” of Bowers’ brain “is impaired.” Mr. Burt said. “They’re going to tell you that the impairments in his brain caused the .. delusional beliefs that led directly to the terrible events of Oct. 27, 2018.”

Mr. Burt also said that test results from an EEG, which measures the electrical activity in the brain, were a “strong indicator” that Bowers has epilepsy which “can lead to and did lead to psychotic delusions.”

Mr. Burt summarized what other medical professionals will later testify to, including the findings of other scans and testing done on Bowers brain, some that shows results “consistent with someone who is schizophrenic.”

Some of these “psychotic conditions” may even date back to Bowers’ childhood, Mr. Burt said.

He asked the jurors to “keep an open mind” as the evidence is presented in this phase.

Advertise with us

— Hallie Lauer

—————

10:38 a.m. 

Defense attorney Judy Clarke is no stranger to representing some of the country’s most notorious criminals

Even before he was labeled a madman and hauled out of his one-room Montana cabin, few people had ever made a real connection with Ted Kaczynski.

He’d already begun cutting off his family by the time he was charged in a string of mail bombs that killed three and injured 23. He refused to see any of them after his arrest, considering it a betrayal that they helped turn him in to the FBI.

Advertise with us

Facing the death penalty despite the feds’ assurances to his family they’d not seek it, he was in prison with almost no connections, according to his younger brother, David Kaczynski.

“He really, really connected with Judy,” David Kaczynski said during an interview with the Post-Gazette earlier this year.

Judy Clarke, then in her 40s, was brought into the case early by public defender Quin Denvir. She was able to make a connection with the volatile man dubbed the Unabomber, who oscillated between reverence for and hatred toward his attorneys.

And that has become Ms. Clarke’s hallmark in the 30-plus years she’s been defending what some might call the most despicable of clients. She is not apt to lean into the name she’s made for herself, but it is inescapable when one is willing to give defense to the indefensible.

In Pittsburgh, she has spent the past four years quietly leading Bowers’ defense team. 

She is a woman who looms larger than life in the world of law, her name inextricably attached to the likes of the Unabomber, the Boston Marathon bomber, the Atlanta Olympics bomber and Jared Lee Loughner — the man who killed six and wounded 12, including former Rep. Gabrielle Giffords — among others.

In person, though — in the halls of Pittsburgh’s federal courthouse on Grant Street for the past two months — Ms. Clarke is less imposing.

She calls her client “Rob,” and she knows his family.

'May their memories always be a blessing': Jewish community comes together after gunman is convicted in synagogue massacre

When Bowers’ mother first came to her son’s proceedings earlier this month, Ms. Clarke knelt next to the woman’s wheelchair and put her arm around her. They spoke with a comfortable familiarity.

She greets reporters, attorneys and U.S. Marshals in the hallways and in the courtroom during breaks. When therapy or police canines trot the hall, she asks to pet them. She has mastered getting through courthouse security on the first try. (Others on the defense team are government employees and can bypass the strict U.S. Marshals and their touchy metal detectors. Ms. Clarke, not a federal employee, cannot.)

Since the highly publicized portions of the Bowers trial began in earnest in April, her standard outfit most days is a grey suit and black turtleneck. Two different scarves often make an appearance. One is neutral and earth tones; the other includes bright splashes of blue.

“She’s had to handle some of the most notorious, if people want to use that word — maybe reviled? — defendants, and she does it with full heart and conviction,” said Laurie Levenson, a Loyola Law School professor and longtime friend of Ms. Clarke.

— Megan Guza

—————

9:47 a.m. 

Magnitude of the crimes is ‘staggering,’ U.S. attorney says as penalty phase starts 

The penalty phase began shortly after 9:15 a.m. Monday as jurors will begin hearing arguments to determine whether Bowers is eligible for the death penalty. Then, they will consider if he will receive it.

Acting U.S. Attorney Troy Rivetti began opening arguments for the government by saying the “magnitude of the crimes committed by the defendant on Oct. 27, 2018, is staggering.”

Mr. Rivetti quoted defense attorney Judy Clarke’s opening statement from the guilt phase in calling Bowers’ actions “inexcusable” and “incomprehensible.”

“He murdered 11 innocent worshippers,” Mr. Rivetti said. “He killed victim after victim with his AR-15.”

Mr. Rivetti used part of his opening remarks to explain to the jurors what this phase of the trial will entail.

He told them to remember the evidence from the guilt phase but not to base their decision on the “reaction of horror.”

“The rule of law applies to all of us in the country, including this defendant,” Mr. Rivetti said, pointing at Bowers in the courtroom.

Jurors are tasked with determining whether Bowers is eligible for the death penalty, which has three qualifications the juror must consider: whether Bowers is over the age of 18, whether he acted with a sufficient level of intent and whether the government has proven at least one aggravating factor.

Because Bowers’ age is not in dispute, there are really only two factors to consider in this phase, Mr. Rivetti told the jurors.

There are four types of intent the government could try to prove: 

  • The defendant intentionally killed the victim named in the count
  • He intentionally inflicted serious bodily injury
  • He intentionally participated in an act resulting in death
  • He participated in an act of violence, knowing the act created grave risk of death.

“We only have to prove one. We will prove four,” Mr. Rivetti said.

— Hallie Lauer

—————

9:25 a.m. 

Jurors could face ‘real psychological distress,’ expert says

Since Day 1 of the trial, the jurors hearing the case have been confronted with the horrors of that day.

First came Bernice Simon’s 911 call. Jurors heard the scared and shaky 84-year-old begging the call-taker for help, asking them to hurry because her husband was bleeding and might be dead. They heard her say she’d never been so scared. Then they heard more shots in the background, screams, ragged breathing and silence as she was shot and killed.

Then they heard Tree of Life Rabbi Jeffrey Myers talk lovingly about the seven congregants he lost Oct. 27, 2018, in the worst attack on the Jewish faith on American soil. He told jurors about hiding in a small bathroom with no lock on the door for more than 40 minutes, and they heard his frantic 911 call. He told them he expected to die.

They saw crime scene photos — bloody scenes with bodies in unnatural positions, having fallen in the spot where they were cut down. The carnage spilled across at last three floors of the hulking stone synagogue at Shady and Wilkins avenues. No congregation that worshipped there — Tree of Life, Dor Hadash, New light — was untouched.

Then came the autopsy photos. 

Michelle Lonergan, a postdoctoral fellow at the University of Ottawa, researched the notion of secondary trauma in jurors who have experienced particularly grueling testimony and evidence.

She said existing studies showed around half of jurors surveyed after trials reported experiencing some level of trauma-related symptoms. A smaller number experience such symptoms for months.

“The threat of experiencing real psychological distress because of your experience as a juror … is real,” she said.

Federal courts in the past have done what they could to offer support and help to jurors confronted by death and destruction wrought by another.

After the trial of Boston Marathon bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, U.S. District Judge George A. O’Toole Jr. extended the jury service of each juror for 90 days. Their job was done, but the extension allowed them to receive free counseling through the court’s Employee Assistance Program.

Kathleen Berman, the Federal Occupational Health’s EAP manager, said at the time she’d always questioned the effect of trials on the jury.

“Who’s taking care of the jurors?” she said in 2015. “These are average, everyday people who have been called in for service. They would never want to listen to any of this horrific testimony, but it’s their job to do just that.”

— Megan Guza

—————

8:30 a.m. 

'Grateful to God': Reaction to the verdict was quick among Jewish leaders and elected officials

The verdict drew immediate reaction from leaders across the region and beyond.

State Rep. Dan Frankel, D-Squirrel Hill, thanked the jury — and survivors — in a tweet moments after the verdict was announced at the federal courthouse Downtown.

“Let us remember that the survivors reopened these wounds and participated in this process for us — for humanity — because there has to be a record,” Mr. Frankel wrote. “The work to hold back hateful ideologies and violence stands on history.”

At a news conference later, he said fighting those ideologies is like beating back a wildfire whose sparks appear again and again.

“So today, I thank our brave survivors for sharing their suffering so that we can protect against more suffering,” Mr. Frankel said.

Rabbi Jeffrey Myers of the Tree of Life Congregation, who survived the attack, also expressed gratitude.

“I am grateful to God for getting us to this day,” he said in a statement. “And I am thankful for the law enforcement who ran into danger to rescue me, and the U.S. attorney who stood up in court to defend my right to pray.

“Today I am focused on being with my congregation and praying, singing and clapping in praise of God as we do each Shabbat,” Rabbi Myers added. “In the face of the horror [that] our community has experienced, I can think of no better response than practicing my Jewish faith and leading worship.”

Tree of Life CEO Carole Zawatsky directed her comments toward survivors and the victims’ families.

“While the verdict will not bring back your loved ones who were so violently killed, my hope is that today provides some level of comfort and helps us to ease the pain, even if ever so slightly. May their memories always be a blessing,” Ms. Zawatsky said in a statement. 

— Adam Smeltz

—————

8 a.m. 

‘Now this case is starting’: What to expect from the sentencing phase

The court gave jurors a week-long break between delivering their verdict and the penalty phase beginning. That’s usually not the case, and U.S. District Judge Robert J. Colville runs the risk of jurors being exposed to media reports on the case in the interim, said Bruce Antkowiak, a former federal prosecutor and defense attorney who teaches at St. Vincent College in Latrobe

But the break could work in the defense team’s favor, as it puts more time between what comes next and the guilt phase of the trial — the phase in which jurors found their client guilty of dozens of horrific crimes.

“The defense wants to separate that,” he said. “They want to tell the jury, ‘Now this case is starting. Now we are really looking at whether or not this man should die.’”

That will start by recreating Bowers’ life. Mr. Antkowiak said he’s seen cases in which defense counsel will present high school records, grade school records, even circumstances a defendant’s mother faced during pregnancy.

Not much is known about the man convicted of the synagogue shooting. He made it through several years of high school in the Baldwin-Whitehall School District but did not graduate. His mother attended two days of trial testimony, and an aunt was present for most of the final week of the guilt phase and for the verdict on Friday.

Bowers was born in 1972, about six months after his mother, Barbara Jenkins, married his father, Randall G. Bowers. They divorced a year later. Online records found by the Post-Gazette in the immediate aftermath of the synagogue attack indicated that Randall Bowers was charged with rape in connection with an alleged attack on a 20-year-old from Squirrel Hill in April 1979.

According to press clippings from the time, Randall Bowers failed to appear in court that October. A warrant was issued, and he was found dead from an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound in a picnic area near the Tionesta Dam in Northwest Pennsylvania.

His mother had remarried four years before her first husband’s suicide. She filed for divorce in 2004, though her filings indicated she hadn’t lived with her second husband since 1976.

It’s not clear what relationship Bowers had with his mother, his apparent biological father or his mother’s second husband. It’s possible those details could be presented during sentencing.

Defense attorneys indicated in court filings after the verdict that they do intend to call witnesses during the sentencing phase, though they did not identify who those witnesses would be.

— Megan Guza