Day after day for more than a month in 2021, Mandie Rose Reusch bombarded her estranged boyfriend with graphic, vile messages, police said.
She told him on May 5, 2021, that he’d never again see the daughter they had together: “I hope for [her] sake that you do kill yourself. She would be better off not knowing you,” Westmoreland County investigators wrote in a criminal complaint against Ms. Reusch.
Just over two years after the streams of vitriol began — and just over two years after Ms. Reusch’s estranged boyfriend killed himself — Pennsylvania State Police have filed charges.
Ms. Reusch, 35, is charged with harassment and aiding suicide. Charges were filed in Westmoreland County last week, and Ms. Reusch spent two days in jail before she posted $150,000 bond.
“[He] may still be here today if those messages did not influence and encourage him to take his own life,” District Attorney Nicole Ziccarelli said in a statement.
The charges are the culmination of a two-year investigation between her office and state police, she said.
Ms. Reusch’s attorney, Phil DiLucente, told Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV that “other not-so-nice things [were] exchanged both ways, said to one another.”
“My God, if we’re going to start prosecuting people for sending harsh texts to one another versus it being verbally communicated, then we are on a different path on our legal system,” Mr. DiLucente told the TV station.
The messages, sent via the WhatsApp messaging platform, began while Ms. Reusch’s “on again, off again” boyfriend was away at military training, according to the complaint. For days she allegedly encouraged the 37-year-old to “kill yourself, I mean it.”
She referenced the man’s deceased dog and touted her “new boyfriend,” who she said was moving in with her and who their daughter would now refer to as “daddy.”
“You’ll never see her again. Ever,” the messages allegedly read, according to the complaint. She said that she would shred a book that contained photos of the dog. “That dog [expletive] hated you and ran away every chance she could.”
“I hope you burn in hell and my daughter will dance on your grave with her real dad,” Ms. Reusch allegedly wrote. “Never talk to us again. Die slow and suffer.”
In that same string of abuse, Ms. Reusch also wrote, “I really do think we would all be better off if you were dead,” according to the complaint. She said she destroyed thousands of dollars’ worth of belongings her estranged boyfriend had left at their home.
Though the string leading up to the man’s suicide is the focal point of the charges, the criminal complaint references some messages dating back to 2020.
“I hope you die,” she wrote in December 2020, according to police “[Our daughter] will be better off.”
About 2:15 p.m. on June 18, 2021, the victim texted a friend to say his phone would be in his apartment and the door would be unlocked.
“I hate me sending this I hope you don’t read it for a while [sic],” he wrote. “Make sure she pays for it all.”
The friend went to the man’s apartment but got no answer, according to the complaint. Police in Westmoreland County arrived and found him dead inside from an apparent suicide. Investigators found a letter that began with, “Maybe she was right.”
In the minutes before the ominous text to a friend, the man allegedly sent Ms. Reusch copies of the earlier messages between the two in which she urged him to kill himself. “That’s going up now,” he said and posted the messages to his Facebook page, according to the complaint.
Minutes before that, he’d told another friend, “It’s bad, it’s really bad right now,” “My money will make her right,” and “I can’t do this anymore. She needs punished. The courts are too slow.”
Ms. Ziccarelli said “the level of bullying, harassment and threats rose to a criminal level in this particular case.”
Mr. DiLucente told KDKA things can get heated when there is a child involved.
“We just have very emotional words conveyed to one another,” he said, saying that prosecutors are using a state statute rarely used before.
In September 2021, then-Gov. Tom Wolf signed legislation stiffening penalties for those convicted of aiding a suicide, allowing for enhanced sentencing when the victim is under 18 or has specific developmental disorders.
A note in that legislation indicated that roughly 12 people were convicted of aiding suicide per year from 2016 to 2019.
That legislation was spearheaded by a York County couple whose daughter in 2019 took her own life after she got step-by-step guidance on how to poison herself from an online forum, according to PennLive.
Mr. DiLucente, in remarks to the Daily Mail, rejected comparisons to the 2014 case of Michelle Carter. Carter was 17 in the summer of 2014 when she encouraged her 18-year-old boyfriend Conrad Roy to end his life.
A trial that ended in an involuntary manslaughter conviction revealed text messages in which Carter told her high school boyfriend to “just do it, babe.” Messages showed the teen spent days convincing Roy to kill himself.
Roy was found dead in his truck in Fairhaven, Mass., in July 2014. He’d died of carbon monoxide poisoning, and investigators found a gas-operated water pump in the backseat, according to NBC10.
According to text messages Carter sent to another friend, she’d told Roy in a phone call to “get back in” his carbon monoxide-filed truck, the Boston TV station reported. Carter was found guilty in 2017.
Mr. DiLucente told the Daily Mail that Carter was “actually telling him, reinforcing him to do it, planning it, the methods and the means.
“You don’t have any of that here,” he said. “What you have is an emotional relationship between two persons involving their child.”
A preliminary hearing is scheduled for June 27.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.