Karen Duffola has been selected to serve as a full-time liaison to the Allegheny County Jail Oversight Board, a position that aims to provide more oversight of a facility that has faced public scrutiny in recent years because of inmate deaths.

The board, in a split vote during its Thursday meeting, selected Ms. Duffola, a former drug court coordinator for Allegheny County.

At-large County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam objected to the board voting for her because she was not named on the agenda.

The interview process and the decision to vote Thursday was not transparent, Ms. Hallam said.

Advertise with us

“The manner by which this was all conducted carries, at least, the perception of unethical behavior,” Ms. Hallam said as part of a lengthy statement concerning the vote.

Ryan Herbinko, a representative for county Controller Corey O’Connor — another board member — also was opposed, saying he was concerned that a proposed memorandum of understanding by the controller’s office, outlining what the liaison would be doing, would not be enforced.

But Judge Elliot Howsie, chair of the oversight board, said that Ms. Duffola had undergone a thorough review process and that she was highly qualified for the position, which has a salary of up to $85,000, according to board documents.

Judge Beth Lazzara, who made the initial motion to name Ms. Duffola, called the liaison a “fact-finding position” for which nearly 70 people applied.

“Because certain people did not get the requisite number of votes, certain people were upset about that,” Mr. Howsie said Thursday. “But the process was fair, it was thorough, it was comprehensive.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Hallam and Mr. Herbinko opposed. Gayle Moss, a citizen member, was absent from Thursday’s meeting.

Since April 2020, more than a dozen inmates have died, either at the jail or a nearby hospital.

Outside of the liaison position, county Executive Rich Fitzgerald announced last August that a third-party contractor was hired to conduct a “historical review” of deaths in the facility. Before that, the jail was tasked with doing its own internal review before turning over that information to the county police department.