Two anglers caught cheating in a fishing tournament last year are in an Ohio county jail following sentencing in Cleveland Thursday.
Jacob Runyan, 43, of Ashtabula, Ohio, and Chase Cominsky, 36, of Hermitage, Mercer County, were ordered to spend 10 days in jail, pay thousands of dollars in fines, remain under probation restrictions for 12 months and give up their fishing licenses for three years. Cominsky also was forced to forfeit his bass boat and trailer worth $100,000 because they were allegedly used in the cheating incident.
Their failed attempt to circumvent the rules at the Lake Erie Walleye Trail Championship in Cleveland Sept. 30, 2022, was witnessed by millions worldwide when a cellphone video taken at the weigh-in went viral. The video shows the suspicious tournament director slicing open the pair’s five unusually fat fish as nine lead weights wrapped in walleye filets drop out.
Runyan and Cominsky were immediately ejected from the tournament and officers from the Ohio Department of Natural Resources confiscated the fish as evidence.
That wasn’t the first time the tournament teammates were accused of cheating. In their first walleye tournament, Runyan and Cominsky finished in 13th place. The next year they took top honors and began a winning streak that continued through dozens of Midwest fishing tournaments, claiming more than $250,000 in cash and prizes while weighing-in walleye that were suspiciously heavier than competitors' catches of the same length.
In 2021, their winning five-fish limit was disqualified from a high-stakes Lake Erie tournament after one of the men failed a mandatory post-tournament polygraph test. At the time of last year’s controversy, Runyan was suing that event to restore their finish and more than $125,000 in first-place winnings.
Read More
Court records show that in the spring of 2022, Runyan and Cominsky were investigated after being accused of cheating in a different walleye tournament. The prosecutor concluded that there was not enough evidence to file charges.
Following September’s cheating attempt, police and wildlife agencies in Ohio and Pennsylvania investigated the men’s homes. Officers from the Ohio Department of Natural Resources found a hidden compartment in Cominsky’s boat that smelled like rotting fish. In October the men were indicted by a Cuyahoga County grand jury on a number of charges, including three felonies. Despite initially pleading not guilty, Runyan and Cominsky agreed to a deal in March and changed their plea to guilty of cheating and unlawful ownership of wild animals.
Cleveland.com reported that on Thursday, Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court Judge Steven Gall cited childhood memories of fishing with his father and taking his son fishing before delivering his sentence.
Once Runyan and Cominsky complete their county jail terms, each will serve 1½ years on probation and pay a $2,500 fine. Half of their fines will be waived if they each make a $1,250 donation to a nonprofit organization that promotes fishing with children. If the men violate their probation, they could face an additional 30-day county jail sentence.
The fishing cheats apologized to their families and the fishing community before being handcuffed in the courtroom and taken to jail, said Cleveland.com. It is unlikely they will be welcome to enter additional fishing tournaments.
The high-profile incident has impacted the future of tournament fishing. Cleveland Metroparks has banned the Lake Erie Walleye Trail Champions tournament from its properties because of the harsh media reporting linked to its park. In competitive fishing circles, concern is mounting that with top tournaments now paying millions in prizes, the temptation to cheat is growing. Winners are often polygraphed and some events are considering new scanning protocols including the use of metal detectors and cameras watching the anglers’ every move.
John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.