TOLEDO, Ohio — Lake Erie charter captain Eric Hirzel is among the fishers, charter captains and guides who are hoping a recent tournament scandal changes the way walleye competitions are monitored.

Until then, many of them, including Mr. Hirzel himself, have and will continue to stand down from participating in tournaments because of pervasive suspicions about cheating.

“When you put purses out there that are that big, unfortunately, otherwise intelligent people are going to do stupid things. I got out of it because I didn't think we were playing on a level playing field. I have a pretty good idea this has been going on for quite a while,” said Mr. Hirzel, of Port Clinton, Ohio.

“I'm pretty sure they will do things differently going forward and make it a real test of who is the best fisherman instead of who is the best at cheating.”

Advertise with us

Jacob Runyan, of the Cleveland suburb of Broadview Heights, and his fishing partner, Chase Cominsky, of Hermitage, Pa., were disqualified from the championship event of the Lake Erie Walleye Trail tournament on Friday when the fish they turned in as their catch were found to have lead weights inside of them.

Walleye cheating scandal

The findings are subject to reviews by both the Ohio Division of Wildlife and the Cuyahoga County prosecutor's office in Cleveland.

Mr. Runyan has declined to comment, and Mr. Cominsky has not responded to requests.

Toledo angler Joe Whitten and his fishing partner, Jim Preissner, of Wisconsin, also have experienced past concerns over cheating and believe they may have been personally affected.

Mr. Runyan and Mr. Cominsky have claimed wins in several previous events, including the Rossford Walleye Roundup in April. They were disqualified from the high-stakes Lake Erie Fall Brawl in 2021 after one of them apparently failed the mandatory post-tournament polygraph test, but Mr. Runyon had filed suit to restore their finish and the more than $125,000 in first-place winnings.

Advertise with us

“I was on the stage for the final weigh-in at this past spring's Rossford tournament, standing right next to them, and I knew something wasn't right,” said Mr. Whitten, a veteran of more than 50 professional fishing tournaments. “They didn't hold up their fish for everyone to see, they didn't show anyone their fish and they didn't donate them. There were multiple signs that something was going on.”

Following the weigh-in, most of the anglers in the tournament donated their walleye to local soup kitchens. Mr. Runyon and Mr. Cominsky did not.

“I've been doing this for 20-some years, and I can't think of a single time when the winners didn't hold up their fish — until these guys came along,” Mr. Whitten said. “After that, I decided that I'm done fishing these tournaments until they fix this.”

Mr. Whitten and his teammate finished second in that Rossford event. Mr. Runyon and Mr. Cominsky took home a check for $10,000 in the tournament, while Mr. Whitten and Mr. Preissner received $3,000 for second place.

Before the alleged cheating was exposed Friday in Cleveland, Mr. Runyon and Mr. Cominsky were poised to gain close to $30,000 in the weekend Lake Erie Walleye Train championship event. Mr. Runyon had also claimed the top prize in last year's Walleye Slam tournament with a 12.79-pound fish that measured 29 inches. The second- and third-place fish in that event were longer but weighed almost a pound less.

Advertise with us

Mr. Runyon previously said he and Mr. Cominsky split the more than $150,000 winnings from the Walleye Slam. Combined, the 2021 Brawl and the 2021 Slam put up an estimated $800,000 total in prizes and cash. This year, the prize funds have increased, with the top two places in the Brawl alone worth a combined $250,000.

Toledo walleye guide and charter captain Ross Robertson, who has fished tournaments in the past, said the tournaments and the participants need to do a better job of self-policing in the future.

“There are people that 100% knew that something was going on,” Mr. Robertson said. “People need to say something.”

Jason Fischer — who purchased the Fall Brawl following last year's tournament and now runs that event, as well as the Lake Erie Walleye Trail — issued a statement that included an apologetic commitment to running a tighter ship.

"I'm still at loss for words and for that, I apologize,” his statement said. “I will take time and figure out how I can solidify the integrity of our sport here on Erie. I genuinely care about running an honest tournament, and Lake Erie anglers deserve it."

Advertise with us

Rossford Mayor Neil MacKinnon said there had been concerns about possible cheating at this past spring's tournament, but an investigation by the Rossford Police Department and the Wood County Prosecutor's Office resulted in no charges being filed.

Mr. MacKinnon suggested that making the donation of the fish mandatory and including a closer inspection of the catch in the fish-cleaning process would help minimize the opportunities to cheat.

“It is just disappointing that this has happened because it creates a drag on the sport,” he said. “As far as our tournament goes, the fish are gone, and I would imagine so is the prize money, so it's all closed at this point.”

Brad Dunkle, a full-time fishing guide and the owner of Wildwood Anglers in Sylvania, said he hates to see so many people hurt by the scandal..

“Morality and ethics are really the measures of a person so this is distressing,” he said.

Advertise with us

More than the lost winnings, Mr. Whitten laments the possible missed opportunity for his fishing partner, Mr. Preissner.

“What bothers me the most is that Jimmy is 80 years old now. What [was stolen from him], we’ll never get that back.”

The Block News Alliance consists of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette; The Blade of Toledo, Ohio; and television station WDRB in Louisville, Ky. Matt Markey is a reporter for The Blade. Contact him at: mmarkey@theblade.com.