Accused synagogue shooter Robert Bowers must undergo a psychiatric exam by experts hired by prosecutors, the judge in the case ruled late Monday, ending a months-long battle between two sides that have made few if any compromises over four years of trial prep.
For months, prosecutors have sought to perform their own examination of Mr. Bowers, who is set to stand trial later this month in the 2018 shooting. Defense lawyers have refused to make Mr. Bowers available unless prosecutors agreed to certain parameters. Prosecutors, too, have stuck to their own set of conditions.

U.S. District Judge Robert Colville made the decision for them in his late-Monday ruling.
“Government mental health experts shall be permitted to examine the defendant as necessary and probative to rebut or confirm defense experts’ anticipated mental health testimony,” the judge wrote.
The judge’s ruling included a rebuke: “Despite being afforded a more than adequate opportunity to agree on even the most basic terms of a potential government-conducted examination of [Mr. Bowers], the parties failed to reach any meaningful agreement.”
Jury selection in the case entered its third week on Monday. The trial is set to being in late May.
In late February, Mr. Bowers gave the required notice that he would introduce mental illness-related evidence during the trial. A few weeks later, prosecutors requested they be allowed to perform their own exam.
In a March 20 court filing, attorneys for Mr. Bowers revealed they would introduce evidence during the sentencing phase indicating Mr. Bowers has schizophrenia, epilepsy and “structural and function impairments of the brain.”
Under the judge’s new ruling, the exam will be limited in scope, meaning the prosecution’s experts can only gather evidence insofar as it rebuts or confirms those diagnoses. That includes questioning about the shooting itself, his conduct before and after, and “any other matter as is necessary”
No lawyers from either side can sit in on the exam, which can be recorded if Mr. Bowers consents to it.
Mr. Bowers, 50, faces 63 charges in the Oct. 27, 2018 killing of 11 people at a Squirrel Hill synagogue housing three different congregations: Dor Hadash, New Light and Tree of Life. Eleven worshippers were killed: Gottfried, Joyce Fienberg, Rose Malinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax and Irving Younger.
Judge Colville ruled the exam can take place over multiple days, including weekends, but can’t go on for more than 4 1/2 days at six hours a day. All interviews and exams will be at the facility where Mr. Bowers is being held. Judge Colville chastised prosecutors in his ruling for insisting the exam take place in the federal courthouse in Downtown Pittsburgh — that is, the place of business of the people seeking a guilty verdict and death sentence for Mr. Bowers.
Defense lawyers have consistently objected to that location, particularly as prosecutors have sought to keep the defense out of the room while the exam happens.
The judge said the prosecution’s “refusal to compromise on this simple issue to be, quite simply, unsupportable.”
He noted, though, that “neither side is without fault” in dragging out the issue.
The defense team has said it turned over all of its medical-related findings and examinations in a separate filing that sought to take the death penalty off the table. Defense lawyers said that negated the need for prosecutors to examine Mr. Bowers.
“[T]his position is also, quite simply, unsupportable,” Judge Colville wrote.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.