The federal death penalty trial against accused synagogue shooter Robert Bowers, which began in earnest last week with jury selection, didn’t necessarily have to take place.
Mr. Bowers, through his defense team, has offered to plead guilty in exchange for life in prison. His latest offer indicated he also would waive all rights to any appeals.

Bruce Antkowiak, a former federal prosecutor and defense lawyer now teaching at St. Vincent, said the process by which the Department of Justice decides whether or not to seek the death penalty isn’t a simple one.
Once a U.S. Attorney decides to try to certify a case as a death penalty one, it’s is referred to a panel within the Justice Department. Ultimately, it’s a decision made personally by the U.S. Attorney General. In this case, former-Attorney General William Barr would have been that person.
Mr. Bowers is charged in the 2018 mass shooting at a Squirrel Hill synagogue. The synagogue housed three congregations: Tree of Life, Dor Hadash and New Light. The Oct. 27, 2018, shooting killed 11 worshippers across those three congregations. They were Richard Gottfried, Joyce Fienberg, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax and Irving Younger.
Mr. Antkowiak said federal prosecutors are not supposed to look at the death penalty as a bargaining chip to wrangle a guilty plea from a defendant.
“The decision to go for the death penalty should be one made by a prosecutor with a singular focus on whether or not this really is what is necessary to do justice in this case,” he said.
Once that decision is made, it’s likely to stick.
“Having made that decision, as long as your case in your mind is still provable… if the case is still the strong case you believed it to be in the outset, then you really should go ahead with this decision,” Mr. Antkowiak said.
However, federal prosecutors generally have “unfettered discretion” when it comes to the death penalty.
“They could easily, right now, decide, ‘We’ve thought about it, we’ve reconsidered, we’ve looked at the additional evidence that defense has provided by way of discovery, and we have now decided that it is not in the best interest of the United States to seek the death penalty here,’” Mr. Antkowiak said. “They could still do that. They can still do that up until the day that the case goes to trial.”
Many immediate family members of those killed in the shooting have expressed their desire to see Mr. Bowers executed. Some, along with other members of the congregations, have repeatedly asked the Justice Department to agree to a plea deal.
Richard Dieter, executive director of the nonprofit Death Penalty Information Center, said it’s important to note that while the justice system is often centered around victims, they don’t determine what punishment should be meted out.
“It’s an offense against the community, it’s an offense against the state, the country,” he said.
So why not a plea deal? It does eliminate the financial and human cost of a drawn-out and, often, traumatic trial.
“What it takes away is the theater,” Mr. Dieter said. “Not just the sentencing phase, but the guilty phase, where the case would be laid out.”
There could still be a chance for victim-impact statements, he said.
“Even though there is a simpler way that this could have been dealt with, it would lack the, perhaps, the impact,” Mr. Dieter said.

The death penalty decision
Experts were uncertain about whether the fact that the case began under the Trump administration has anything to do with the decision to seek — and continue to seek — the death penalty.
Mr. Dieter said that current Attorney General Merrick Garland hasn’t shown quite the opposition to the death penalty that his boss President Joe Biden has, though Mr. Garland did call for a moratorium on federal executions.
“It’s not an absolute sort of thing,” he said. “On looking into it, there are aspects that perhaps call for this.”
On the other hand, he pointed out, the government did not seek the death penalty against a shooter who opened fire in a Walmart in El Paso, Texas. The shooter said he specifically targeted Hispanic people.
“I do think… that the timing seems to be a factor, and by that I mean for cases that have some roots in the prior administration, there’s more chance of continuing that,” Mr. Dieter said.
There are currently 43 people on federal death row across the county, Mr. Dieter said, and the government — even under an administration that has expressed opposition to the death penalty — is “fighting to defend those death sentences.”
He said there could be an effort to respect prior decisions, but the Department of Justice has withdrawn its intent to seek the death penalty in other cases that predate the Biden administration.
The financial toll
It won’t be until after the trial’s end — after the guilt phase and, if necessary, the sentencing phase — that a clear picture will emerge of just how much it cost taxpayers. There will likely be a financial cost at every level — local, state and federal.
The price tags in other high-profile cases have soared into the millions.
The U.S. government spent almost $5 million to court-martial and convict Maj. Nidal Hasanl in the aftermath of his deadly rampage at Fort Hood in 2009. More than $1 million of that was spent on transporting witnesses, experts, attorneys and jurors. Almost as much was spent on accommodations for those participants who were sequestered, according to NBC5 in Texas.
U.S. District Judge Robert Colville, who is presiding over the trial for Mr. Bowers, has said he doesn’t think it will be necessary to sequester the jury once it’s chosen. The jury will also be made up of local residents. Lawyers for Mr. Bowers did not seek to bring in a jury from outside Western Pennsylvania.
Any witness lists that might have been filed in the case as the guilt phase nears have been filed under seal, so it’s unclear how many witnesses and experts might be brought in from outside the area who will require transportation and lodging.
It’s also not clear whether the jury will be taken to visit the site of the shooting. And it’s unclear how much it costs to transport Mr. Bowers to Downtown Pittsburgh from Butler County, where he’s being held.
In Florida, during the sentencing proceedings for Parkland school shooter Nikolas Cruz, the Sun Sentinel estimated it cost up to $90,000 per month just to pay prosecutors and public defenders. Add in the cost of the judge’s salary, and that total soared to more than $1 million from the time Cruz pleaded guilty to when sentencing got underway.
In the case of the 2012 movie theater shooting Aurora, Colo., the trial cost at least $3 million, according to the Denver Post. The federal government covered about $1.6 million of that, the newspaper reported. When the Post included salaries for judges, prosecutors, deputies and other employees, the cost rose to more than $7 million.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.