Calvin Hall’s family members clutched each other, sobbing and shrieking, as a jury on Thursday returned a first-degree murder conviction against the man accused of killing the off-duty police officer in 2019.

Christian Bey, 34, sat quietly as jurors affirmed their conviction against him, opting for first-degree murder as opposed to the third-degree option they were also presented with.

Hall, 36, was off duty and visiting friends at a home on Monticello Street on July 14, 2019, where a block party was also happening.

The shooting happened around 12:30 a.m. and stemmed from an argument involving Hall and several partygoers. Witnesses testified that Hall was trying to defuse the situation and was shot as he walked away.

Advertise with us

Closing arguments in the case against Bey ended midafternoon Wednesday. Jurors — six men and six women — deliberated for about two hours before going home for the day. They deliberated for about four hours on Thursday and signaled they had reached a verdict around 2:40 p.m.

As the jury foreman read the verdict, two of Hall’s family members shrieked.

“Thank you, Lord,” one woman shouted, rising almost uncontrollably to her feet. She and another woman clutched each other, sobbing.

“He was a great person, a kind person. He loved his family,” his cousin, Lindsay Hall, said after the verdict. “He loved his job and taking care of people.

“It’s justice, but it still doesn’t bring him back,” she said.

Advertise with us

Bey’s family members remained quiet, as did Bey himself, sitting at the defense table. Defense attorney Carmen Robinson put a hand on his shoulder. She spoke quietly to him as he hung his head. Later, she comforted his family in the hallway.

“Hey, it’s OK, it’s OK,” she told them.

Ms. Robinson said after the verdict she maintained her belief that Bey’s arrest was a rush to judgement by a police department that was biased because the victim was one of their own.

She said Bey often felt like he wasn’t being treated fairly during court proceedings. Ms. Robinson agreed and said she would look back at the record of the trial after sentencing.

Bey’s conviction closed the book on a trial that took two tries and in which testimony took longer than either side anticipated.

Advertise with us

The first trial began March 14 but Judge Kevin G. Sasinoski declared a mistrial just two days later after a witness made passing mention of Bey’s prior criminal history. A defendant’s criminal history is generally kept from the jury so as not to prejudice them.

Bey’s attorneys asked for the mistrial, indicating “no curative instruction could remedy the situation.” Deputy District Attorney Stephanie Ramaley did not object.

Closing arguments followed a familiar theme, with Ms. Ramaley telling jurors to focus on the physical evidence, while Ms. Robinson pointed to what she believed were holes in the prosecution’s version of events.

She painted the scene the night of the shooting as a chaotic “family affair,” in which potentially “tons of people” and several guns were involved. She said police rushed the case, and said Hall was the one agitated and waving his gun at people.

Hall was found with an empty holster attached to his waist, and his weapons were found tucked into the backseat pouch of his car.

Advertise with us

Ms. Robinson pointed to body cam footage from that night in which several Pittsburgh police officers questioned how Hall’s guns ended up in the car. One officer mused that they might have been taken off of Hall after he was shot and moved to the car to protect his image.

“What doesn’t fit, we question,” she said.

She also criticized witnesses she said gave a generic description of the suspect, as well as the private consulting firm that performed DNA testing on the gun that killed Hall. She called into question the time stamps on surveillance videos, too.

Bey’s DNA was found to match DNA collected from the slide and trigger of the gun.

Ms. Ramaley told jurors that physical evidence like DNA doesn’t lie.

Advertise with us

“This case is about good police work,” she said. “These officers follow the evidence. Now it’s your turn.”

During deliberations Thursday morning, jurors came back with two questions regarding video and audio evidence presented during trial. They asked for a transcript, though the judge noted that the transcripts were not evidence and thus could not be taken back to the jury room. Jurors instead read the transcript in the courtroom while video and audio footage was replayed.

They broke for lunch around noon and returned the verdict about 2.5 hours later. A poll of the jurors by the judge’s staff confirmed a unanimous verdict.

Sentencing is set for July 10.