Cassandra Gross remains missing more than four years after she disappeared.

Despite that fact, homicide charges were filed late last month in Westmoreland County against her former boyfriend and long-time person of interest in her disappearance, Thomas Stanko.

Stanko, 52, is charged with killing the 52-year-old Gross of Unity, though an expert on so-called “no-body” homicide cases said the absence of Gross’ body could leave myriad questions unanswered — and present unique challenges to prosecutors.

“The biggest challenge in a no-body murder is you don’t have the best piece of evidence in the murder, and that best piece of evidence is the body,” said Tad DiBiase, a former U.S. attorney who spent 12 years prosecuting homicide cases.

Advertise with us

Most of the time, he said, a body answers the most important questions: How someone was killed, where they were killed and, oftentimes, when they were killed.

“When you don’t have the body at all, you realistically have no chance of finding out any of that information,” Mr. DiBiase said.

The criminal complaint filed against Stanko sheds little light on the investigation, nor does it indicate what prompted the decision to file charges now.

Gross last spoke with her mother about 3:30 p.m. April 7, 2018 — not long after she had lunch with a friend at the Parkwood Inn in Greensburg.

She didn’t show up for dinner with her mother the next night as planned, and her car was found that same day, set ablaze near a railroad bed in Unity. Her diabetic and partially blind dog, Baxter, was found wandering nearby.

Advertise with us

Gross did not show up for work April 9, and she was reported missing that morning.

When initially questioned, Stanko told police he hadn’t seen Gross since April 6 and hadn’t spoken with her since the afternoon of April 7, according to a criminal complaint. Police noted that records show the two exchanged calls and text messages through that entire day and discussed getting together that evening.

Later, police said, they found some of Gross’ belongings burned in a barrel at Stanko’s home: the stems of Coach-brand glasses matching those she’d purchased a month prior, a Michael Kors clothing tag, and a broken medication bottle that police said was “indistinguishable from the insulin bottles prescribed for Gross’s dog.”

A separate search of Stanko’s home April 12, 2018, turned up a bag of makeup, an applicator brush, makeup pads and an April 9 Walmart receipt for emergency burn pads, ScarAway silicone gel and Maybelline foundation.

Investigators noted that Stanko had visible facial injuries on April 12, according to the complaint. DNA found on the makeup applicators did not rule out Stanko as the source of the DNA.

Advertise with us

One day later, Stanko ran from police when they sought to arrest him on a separate matter. As Stanko ran, according to the complaint, he ripped open a yellow grocery bag he was carrying and flapped his arms “as if to empty the ripped bag of its contents.” Investigators recovered more than 40 “small apparently burnt items of unknown origin.”

Police also discovered that Stanko had named his elderly mother as power of attorney for him on April 12, 2018. According to the complaint, he’d been named as her power of attorney five years earlier.

Gross was declared dead less than a year after she disappeared. The declaration came Jan. 22, 2019, and noted “the facts indicate she was a victim of a homicide.”

Numerous searches and excavations took place in and around Unity in the years since Gross vanished. Dogs and helicopters searched properties belonging to Stanko in the days right after his former girlfriend was last seen.

In June 2018, crews searched Unity Cemetery and the surrounding property with cadaver dogs. The 234-acre cemetery is not far from the home of Stanko’s mother. Police had previously searched on and around his mother’s property. Police re-upped the cemetery search the following month.

Advertise with us

Two years later, in May 2020, police searched Stanko’s mother’s property again, with state police noting they’d “received information that gave us reason to search the property.” Excavators were brought in, and troopers said the next day that while they hadn’t found human remains, they did find “a few items that are interesting to us.”

Investigators never did elaborate on those items, and they don’t seem to be alluded to in the criminal complaint against Stanko.

Almost two years ago, attorneys in the case said homicide charges were expected and would be filed “when the time [was] right.”

The right time came Oct. 27, though police and prosecutors remained vague when asked to elaborate on the timing.

“I think it is a completion of our final investigatory objectives and the consultation with the District Attorney’s office and us all sitting down and reviewing the facts and coming to the same conclusion that now is the appropriate time to file these charges,” said Lt. Christopher J. Terrana, commander of State Police Troop A’s criminal investigation unit.

Advertise with us

He continued: “I don’t know if there was any time previously that would have been the appropriate action.”

Unless a discovery is made, authorities will head to Stanko’s Nov. 14 preliminary hearing without foolproof evidence that Gross is dead other than that 2019 declaration and the fact she hasn’t been seen in more than four years.

Mr. DiBiase, who refers to himself on social media as “the No Body guy,” broke down just how much evidence a body can offer.

“In 99% of murder cases, the body tells you how the person was killed — were they stabbed, were they poisoned, were they shot,” he said. “It tells you where they were killed, because if you find a body inside a house and there’s blood all over, you kind of assume, ‘Hey, this is where it happened.’”

Advances in forensic technology mean that a body can usually tell investigators when the person was killed, too, particularly if it is found within six months to a year after death.

Advertise with us

If you have no body and no obvious scene, Mr. DiBiase said,“You don’t have any idea when the murder happened, where the murder happened or how the murder happened.

“You’re starting off, as a detective or prosecutor, with a huge disadvantage. You don’t even know where a crime occurred or whether a crime occurred other than someone is missing.”

Securing a conviction without a body is not impossible.

Mr. DiBiase, who consults on such cases, keeps a running record of no-body prosecutions and the outcomes when they go to trial. Looking at cases as far back as the 1800s, he has found 542 no-body trials through Nov. 1, 2020. Of those, he estimates the conviction rate is about 86%. Seventy-one cases ended in dismissal, mistrial, acquittal or a reversal upon appeal.

The cases he tracks range from coast to coast and beyond — in 1990, for example, Raphello Harris was convicted of first-degree murder in the death of his ex-wife, Judith Harris. She vanished after flying from the West Indies to St. Thomas, Virgin Islands, to visit friends and her son.

Advertise with us

Abraham Lincoln was the defense attorney in a case in which William Trailor was one of three brothers on trial for murder in 1841 before the alleged victim turned up alive and well.

A recent case is that of Kristin Smart. She disappeared in 1996 while attending California Polytechnic Institute in San Luis Obispo. Her body was never found, but charges filed 25 years later against Paul Flores resulted in a conviction last month. Sentencing for Flores is set for next month.

There have been at least a dozen no-body cases taken to trial in Pennsylvania, and convictions have stood in all but one instance — a conviction in Eastern Pennsylvania was overturned because of prosecutorial misconduct.

Locally, Bryan Sedlak was convicted in 2009 in the disappearance and murder of another man four years earlier. At the time Sedlak, of Homestead, was found guilty, Patrick Kenney’s body still hadn’t been found. After a jury convicted him, Sedlak led investigators to the body.

Mr. DiBiase said prosecutors presented with no-body cases often take only the strongest to trial. Building strong cases has become easier, he said, with the explosion of technology. Credit cards, cellphones and security cameras mean most people leave behind a digital trail, and sometimes an abrupt stop in that trail is enough evidence.

Advertise with us

“You can more quickly say, ‘They’re not just missing, they’re dead, because I haven’t gotten a text from them, or they haven’t posted on Instagram, or they look at TIkTok every night and I know from having their phone they haven’t looked at it in days,’” he said.

Things like cellphone records can give police clues as to where a potential victim — or suspect — was at any given time.

In the case of Elizabeth Wiesenfeld, of Whitehall, it was a text message that struck her daughter, Kathleen Graham,  as strange. Shortly after 11 a.m. April 30, 2019, she received a text from Wiesenfeld saying she’d met someone and was leaving town. Surveillance footage, signs of a struggle, fingerprints and a license plate reader led to the arrest of her handyman, Douglas Berry, seven months before her body was found.

That’s the type of evidence that can lead to an arrest even when the most obvious evidence that someone is dead — a body — is missing.

“Detectives and prosecutors are looking for these types of tracks,” he said. “Those types of things are just so much easier to prove. It used to be where you could travel pretty much anonymously without leaving much of a trail behind. That’s not the case anymore.”