Lawyers on Tuesday argued before members of Pennsylvania’s Superior Court whether a jury was improperly influenced before it convicted a Beaver County man of murder.
The argument concerned Sheldon Jeter Jr., 24, of Aliquippa. He was convicted last year in the killing of Tyric Pugh, 30, with whom he lived. Jeter was sentenced to life in prison, the mandatory minimum sentence for first-degree murder.
But his attorneys now argue that there were two allegations that should have been investigated by the trial court to determine whether they showed evidence of improper influence over the jury.
The first was a conversation between two women spectators to the trial, who were talking in the courtroom about the open homicide case of school teacher Rachael DelTondo.
The other involved whether a juror’s prayer, done in private with her father amid deliberations, improperly influenced the juror and consisted of prohibited discussion of the case outside the courtroom.
Attorney Corrie Woods, who argued on behalf of Jeter before a three-judge panel in Pittsburgh on Tuesday, said the Beaver County trial court’s failure to investigate these matters raised concerns about the integrity of the verdict and the justice system. The allegations, he argued, should have triggered the court’s “duty to investigate.”
Read More
Jeter is “entitled to an honest win or an honest loss,” he said to the judges.
The admissibility of the anecdotes was questioned by the judges; Mr. Woods said the prayer was reported to Jeter’s defense attorneys by the juror’s father-in-law, who heard it from the juror’s father.
Mr. Woods presented no first-hand account that the prayer took place, and there was nothing in the brief submitted by Jeter’s attorneys that said the women discussing the DelTondo case — what the Superior Court judges called a “famous case” in Beaver County — had connected the homicide to Jeter.
The attorney pointed to a prior decision that established nonspecific claims found through hearsay are enough basis for the trial court to begin an inquiry, which it did not do, he said.
Judge Judith Olson said she thought Mr. Woods was reading the law “a little broadly.”
“I could see every jury being challenged then in every case,” she said.
Senior Judge James Gardner Colins, assuming the story about Juror No. 3 was accurate, questioned why it would have been a problem even if she had prayed before such an “absolutely momentous decision.”
“What’s wrong with that?” he asked Mr. Woods.
“Absolutely nothing,” Mr. Woods replied, saying that the issue was that the juror talked about the case with a third party, her father, who was not involved with the trial, before making her decision on the verdict.
The Superior Court judges also questioned Mr. Woods on whether the evidence contained in the affidavits he presented to the court suggested the prayer influenced the decision at all.
Attorney Chad Parks, who was a prosecutor in Jeter’s trial, argued that even if the information about the women discussing DelTondo was true, it “doesn’t even come close” to showing bias on behalf of the jury.
There was no evidence the jurors heard or reacted to the discussion, Mr. Parks said.
Judge Alice Dubow asked if Mr. Parks’ argument would be different if the women had named Jeter or suggested that Jeter was a suspect in the DelTondo case.
Mr. Parks said such a discussion could have been an issue, but said the court didn’t have any evidence that was the case.
But Judge Olson, inquiring about the juror who prayed, noted that the woman discussed the case with her father because she was having trouble with the verdict, and asked whether that would count as outside influence.
“There’s no indication that they actually discussed any evidence of the case in this affidavit,” Mr. Parks said, referring to the affidavit that was submitted to the court as part of Jeter’s brief to the Superior Court.
The affidavit, the brief says, was submitted by an attorney who happened to be viewing the trial as a spectator when she overheard two women in the gallery discussing DelTondo. During that time, the attorneys, judge and court reporter left the room for a sidebar.
Michael Santicola, one of Jeter’s defense attorneys during his trial, asked the judge who sentenced Jeter for a mistrial after learning one of the jurors lived next door to DelTondo. That request was denied.
Jeter initially gained public recognition due to his connection to DelTondo, who was shot and killed on her parents’ front lawn in 2018. The case gained national attention and was featured on the CBS newsmagazine show “48 Hours.” No one has ever been charged in the killing.
Police investigating DelTondo’s homicide have said she had a sexual relationship with Jeter when he was a teen. He has not been charged in the case or named by police as a suspect, but he was interviewed by investigators.
Jeter was not present at Tuesday's arguments and is currently imprisoned.
Mick Stinelli: mstinelli@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.