A physician who treated famed UPMC surgeon Dr. James Luketich testified Wednesday afternoon that he obtained the certification needed to prescribe the drug suboxone at Dr. Luketich’s urging, didn’t charge him for his time and didn’t enter the prescription into UPMC’s medical records system, as is normal for other patients.
Dr. David Wilson, a pulmonary physician, said the arrangement was not unusual for him. He said he offered medical reviews to other physicians he knew, as well as their families, and also did not always put records of that work into UPMC’s record system. His testimony was part of a sometimes-heated hearing into whether a recorded conversation between him and Dr. Luketich should factor into a malpractice case filed in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court against Dr. Luketich, UPMC and several other physicians.
Dr. Wilson testified that he believed Dr. Luketich’s treatment was effective and said, “I’d been monitoring him carefully.”
“He was doing well,” Dr. Wilson testified. “We’ve been reducing the” suboxone prescription over time.
For the second day in a row, the judge overseeing the case, Philip Ignelzi, threatened to have attorneys arrested. And for the third day in a row, he banned the public and reporters from the courtroom so evidence could be reviewed by him and the case’s lawyers. In addition, a spat erupted between two opposing counsel during a break in the proceedings, which ended with one calling the other a “jerk.”
The three-day hearing — which was continued to sometime in the future because all of the witnesses have yet been heard or cross-examined — is just one part of a medical malpractice lawsuit filed in 2018 that has evolved to include an examination of and the culture within the state’s largest employer, UPMC, and the bitter dispute between Dr. Luketich and two former UPMC physicians, Jonathan D’Cunha and Lara Schaheen.
Read More
Bernadette Fedorka and her husband sued Dr. Luketich, UPMC and other physicians, claiming she was seriously injured during a botched lung transplant that year. The high-profile case, along with a federal lawsuit over alleged misconduct and fraudulent billing, have exposed backbiting among top physicians, as well as critical concerns about patient care inside the $24 billion hospital system.
Although Dr. Luketich did not perform the surgery at issue in the state malpractice case, the family contends that it was his poor management of the lung transplant team — caused in part, they allege, by his use of suboxone — that led to her botched surgery.
Dr. Luketich and his lawyers claim the recorded discussion was private and recorded illegally by two former UPMC colleagues, Dr. D’Cunha and Dr. Schaheen, as part of a vendetta against Dr. Luketich. He has sued them for defamation.
Dr. D’Cunha, now at the Mayo Clinic in Arizona, once ran UPMC’s lung transplant program and, along with Dr. Schaheen, who also now works in Arizona, filed multiple complaints against Dr. Luketich alleging misconduct. One of those complaints sparked a yearslong federal investigation of Dr. Luketich and UPMC, and led to a separate lawsuit by the U.S. Justice Department accusing them of endangering patients and fraudulently billing the government for millions of dollars.
Dr. Luketich and UPMC have vigorously denied the allegations. Lawyers on both sides of the federal dispute agreed to try to settle the federal case before it reaches trial.
After allegations involving Dr. Luketich’s suboxone use surfaced in 2018, he went to Caron Treatment Center so they could certify to UPMC that he was not having addiction issues — a document Scott Livingston, one of Mr. D’Cunha’s lawyers, introduced in court on Wednesday. Dr. Luketich has said the treatment center said he was not relapsing from a drug problem he dealt with in the late 1980s.
On the form, it listed Dr. Luketich’s relevant medical conditions as chronic back pain and “opioid use disorder.”
Dr. Wilson said he never asked to see that form.
Several times, Mr. Livingston, who represents Dr. D’Cunha, attempted to get Dr. Wilson to say he was treating Dr. Luketich for his “addiction.”
Dr. Wilson pushed back, arguing, “Dr. Luketich is a reformed prescription drug addict who has chronic back pain.”
Suboxone is used to treat both opioid addiction and chronic pain.
At one point, when Mr. Luketich’s lead attorney, Efrem Grail, and Mr. Livingston were arguing over part of Dr. Wilson’s testimony, a visibly angry Judge Ignlezi yelled: “If you two keep arguing with each other I’m going to get the sheriff down here and you’re both going down!” He then pounded on the bench, the booming sound amplified by his microphone.
Earlier Monday, a forensic audio expert testified part of the 2018 recording between Dr. Luketich and Dr. Wilson was “doctored” in one three-second snippet he was asked to analyze.
Jerry Hatchett, an audio expert from Texas, said Dr. Luketich’s attorneys asked him to look only at the three-second section of the nearly 11-minute recording that is at the center of the dispute over Dr. Luketich’s use of suboxone.
The section contained three separate “sounds” and two of them had a gap “that shouldn’t have been there,” Mr. Hatchett testified.
“That particular phrase has been doctored,” he said. “I mean it’s manipulated. Whatever was originally recorded is not on the [digital audio he analyzed] today.”
Like the rest of the recording, the “garbled” phrase Mr. Hatchett referred to was not played in open court. Judge Ignelzi has ordered that none of the substance of the tape can be discussed publicly until he determines whether it was illegally recorded. Copies of the tape were mailed anonymously to several people in 2018, along with a purported transcript and letter.
Judge Ignelzi on Wednesday afternoon again closed the courtroom to the public and media so the three-second snippet could be played and discussed by attorneys in the case.
Robert Barnes, one of Dr. D’Cunha’s attorneys, objected to Mr. Hatchett being called as a witness because Mr. Hatchett said in a court document that he did not complete his analysis of the tape and there was more work to be done.
In addition, Mr. Barnes said the plaintiffs’ attorneys still have not been given a copy of the recording to analyze themselves.
“But [Luketich’s attorneys] are saying let’s put him on anyway and see what he says,” Mr. Barnes argued to the judge.
Judge Ignelzi overruled him, however, and said he would allow the plaintiffs to come back at a later hearing and present their own analysis.
After the lunch break following Mr. Hatchett’s testimony, and before court resumed, an argument erupted between Mr. Grail and Thomas Duffy, one of the plaintiffs’ attorneys, after Mr. Duffy asked Mr. Grail to see the CD of the recorded conversation that UPMC had received from the FBI just last week.
Mr. Grail agreed, and had an assistant lay the CD out on a table in the courtroom. But when Mr. Duffy wanted to flip the CD over to see the other side, Mr. Grail told the assistant to put the CD away.
“I thought I was being a mensch agreeing to let you see it,” he shouted at Mr. Duffy. “But if you want to act like a jerk, you’ll be treated like a jerk.”
One of Judge Ignelzi’s assistants admonished him, “Mr. Grail, let’s act with a sense of decorum.”
Sean D. Hamill: shamill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2579 or Twitter: @SeanDHamill





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.