A U.S. district court ordered a Pittsburgh-area home health care company to pay nearly $1.5 million in back wages, damages and civil fines Friday, after a U.S. Department of Labor investigation found that the company had willfully manipulated its records to avoid paying its employees overtime.

The department of labor investigation determined that Everest Home Care LLC, a local provider of personal assistive services based out of Brentwood and Erie, between July 21, 2018, and Oct. 16, 2021, withheld $719,962.50 in overtime wages from 218 employees.

In November 2019, the department began investigating Everest for non-compliance with the Fair Labor Standards Act, which sets the overtime rate at one and a half times straight-time pay. Officials met with the employer, examining the company’s records, and taking statements from employees over the course of three years, the typical timeframe for civil penalty cases, according to John DuMont, director of the DOL’s Pittsburgh district office.

The department was able to establish that beginning in July 2018, four months after the company was incorporated, Everest had knowingly paid straight-time wages for tens of thousands of overtime hours, according to Mr. DuMont.

Advertise with us

Dane Steffenson, Everest’s attorney in the case, said that the case was an example of overreach by the department. Mr. Steffenson was previously a DOL trial lawyer based out of the department’s Atlanta regional office and now specializes in employment litigation on the other side of the courtroom.

“I know that the U.S. Department of Labor, specifically the Wage Hour division and the Philadelphia regional office there, is regularly overly zealous in its desire to prove high back wages,” Mr. Steffenson said. “This leads to the department of labor extorting settlements from these small healthcare agencies who are forced to settle when they can no longer afford to defend themselves.”

Judge Cathy Bissoon, of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, signed the consent judgment Aug. 5, binding Everest to pay the withheld back wages, an equivalent amount in liquidated damages and a civil money penalty of $85,075. Effective Aug. 5, Everest has 60 days to pay the sum total ordered by the court.

Adam Welsh, the department’s Philadelphia regional counsel, said that wage theft and manipulation of pay records is “pretty typical” in the home assistive services industry. In the 2021 fiscal year alone, the DOL sought and retrieved over $13.8 million owed to more than 17,000 employees across the country working in the industry, according to a Tuesday news release.

“Wage theft is an all-too-common concern in the healthcare industry, and we are determined to use our resources to hold employers who violate federal labor laws accountable to the fullest extent,” the U.S. Solicitor of Labor Seema Nanda said the news release. “By recovering wages and liquidated damages, when appropriate, for workers we send a clear message to employers in all industries that consequences can be costly for employers who flout the law.”